Loading...
Staff Report PREPARED BY: CHRISTINA HILL Event and Marketing Specialist Approved by: Town Manager, Assistant Town Manager, Town Attorney, Economic Vitality Manager, and Community Development Director 110 E. Main Street Los Gatos, CA 95030 ● 408-354-6832 www.losgatosca.gov TOWN OF LOS GATOS TOWN COUNCIL REPORT MEETING DATE: 02/20/18 ITEM NO: 07 DATE: FEBRUARY 7, 2018 TO: TOWN COUNCIL FROM: LAUREL PREVETTI, TOWN MANAGER SUBJECT: REVIEW AND DISCUSS SPECIAL EVENTS IN GENERAL, AND PROVIDE DIRECTION ON TOWN FUNDING, IN-KIND SERVICES, STREET CLOSURES, AND OTHER EVENT RELATED MATTERS. RECOMMENDATION: Staff is recommending that the Town Council continue to review and discuss special events in general, and provide direction on Town funding, in-kind services, street closures, and other event related matters. BACKGROUND: Beginning in May 2017, Town staff has been working to streamline the special event permit process and create clear and simplified guidelines. Since that time, the Town Council has had several event related discussions, including the adoption of a Town Code amendment. At their January 16, 2018 meeting, the Town Council discussed special events in general, focusing on four main issues including: grant funding for events; event fee structure; road closures; and, parking. During public comment, speakers voiced concerns about the items being discussed and requested more time to meet with staff to better understand the recommendations. The Council moved to continue the item to the February 20, 2018 meeting and asked staff to meet with community event organizers and provide the opportunity for further community discussion. Following this direction, community event organizers were invited to participate in an online survey (Attachment 1), and special events round table discussion. The round table discussion PAGE 2 OF 6 SUBJECT: REVIEW AND DISCUSS SPECIAL EVENTS IN GENERAL, AND PROVIDE DIRECTION ON TOWN FUNDING, IN-KIND SERVICES, STREET CLOSURES, AND OTHER EVENT RELATED MATTERS. DATE: February 7, 2018 BACKGROUND (Cont’d): was held on January 29, 2018. Eleven community event organizers attended the meeting and the majority of them had worked together to provide staff with a list of considerations (Attachment 2). Other discussion points from this meeting are integrated into this report. DISCUSSION: As the Town Council continues its discussion, staff has provided additional information below, including some of the considerations provided by our community event organizers. For those items where additional information has not been identified, staff has provided a brief description based on what was presented at the January 16, 2018 Town Council meeting. 1. Discuss and consider a Special Event Grant program or other funding mechanism. As discussed previously, a grant process could be considered as a way to assist community event organizers. The feedback staff received from stakeholders indicated support of a grant program if the process is simple, and awarded annually based on the community benefit/value that the event provides. Staff has benchmarked similar municipalities and found that all those contacted require full payment for public services and fees associated with special events; however, each of those jurisdictions also offers some type of cost-assistance program (either through grants or subsidies) to selected events approved by their Councils or committees. Attachment 3 illustrates the benchmarked data. If the Council would like to establish a Special Event Grant program, funds could be considered in the mid-year budget review taking place later on the agenda of this meeting. A Special Events Grant program should be administered under the umbrella framework of the already existing community grants program awarded to Los Gatos Arts and Community Service providers. If the Council would like to create a grant category for Special Event Grants, it should identify the amount of funding for this purpose. For context, the Arts, Cultural, and Educational Community Grants Program had a total budget of approximately $20,000 for each of the last two fiscal years. The distribution of the Special Event Grant awards could occur in one of two ways, or in another manner deemed appropriate by the Town Council: a. Divide the total amount of grant funding evenly amongst a specified number of grant recipients. For example, if $10,000 is allotted for a Special Events Grant program, five organizations would receive $2,000 each for their event. PAGE 3 OF 6 SUBJECT: REVIEW AND DISCUSS SPECIAL EVENTS IN GENERAL, AND PROVIDE DIRECTION ON TOWN FUNDING, IN-KIND SERVICES, STREET CLOSURES, AND OTHER EVENT RELATED MATTERS. DATE: February 7, 2018 DISCUSSION (cont’d): b. Distribute funding based on the specific event elements such as assigning a percentage or a flat rate to certain items. The amount awarded to each recipient could also be capped at a percentage of their total estimated event expenses. The Community Grant application process is now underway with an application deadline of March 5, 2018. If the Council provides direction on this new program, staff would work with event organizers to publicize the opportunity and encourage participation. As an alternative to a grant program, the Council could consider a Town-subsidized fees and services model, as some other local municipalities provide to their organizers. If this model is preferred, staff recommends that the Council consider the caveat that the Town staff may not always be available to provide the service given workload and staffing limits. If third party vendors were used, the Town would not be able to subsidize those costs. This model would require an application process and criteria to determine the organizations who should be awarded the funds. 2. Discuss and consider the closure of N. Santa Cruz Ave. for the purpose of special events. In the summer and fall of 2017 the Town allowed the closure of N. Santa Cruz Ave . for special events to understand if this closure could help alleviate some of the summer cut through traffic and provide a draw for residents and visitors to visit downtown. These closures provided the opportunity for staff and event organizers to evaluate the impacts on downtown and the surrounding community. The staff is recommending that the Council provide direction on guidelines and procedures for allowing the closure of N. Santa Cruz Ave. for events considering the following: a. Closure of N. Santa Cruz Ave. during the summer: As staff observed and evaluated the traffic impact of summer events combined with the cut through traffic Los Gatos experiences in the summer, it is staff’s opinion that Wood Rd. would need to be closed on a regular basis if the Council would like to continue having N. Santa Cruz Ave. closed for events in the summer (Memorial Day through Labor Day). Without the ongoing closure, cut through traffic intending to use N. Santa Cruz Ave. heading south, would most likely end up using the residential neighborhoods streets surrounding downtown. b. Limitation of number of events that close N. Santa Cruz Ave.: While the events of 2017 held on N. Santa Cruz Ave. yielded positive results in many ways, staff received feedback that they also impacted neighboring businesses, residents, and traffic less favorably in many cases. It was also discovered that a large amount of Town staff PAGE 4 OF 6 SUBJECT: REVIEW AND DISCUSS SPECIAL EVENTS IN GENERAL, AND PROVIDE DIRECTION ON TOWN FUNDING, IN-KIND SERVICES, STREET CLOSURES, AND OTHER EVENT RELATED MATTERS. DATE: February 7, 2018 DISCUSSION (cont’d): resources are required to ensure that each event is set up and carried out in the safest possible manner for the community. Given this, staff recommends limiting the annual number of closures of N. Santa Cruz Ave. to four events, including the annual Holiday Children’s Parade; and, only allowing single day closures of N. Santa Cruz Ave. c. Implementation of a standard fee and traffic control plan for closures of N. Santa Cruz Ave.: To be consistent and provide partnership with event organizers coordinating events on N. Santa Cruz Ave., Town staff is recommending that the Town provide a standard approved traffic plan to event organizers to use to implement the street closure. This plan would include a standard closure on N. Santa Cruz Ave., between Main St. and Bachman Ave., and would be provided at no cost to the event organizers. The Town would absorb the cost of plan preparation. The event organizer would then need to contract with a professional traffic control company to implement the closure. Town staff would conduct a site visit and inspect the closure before the start of the event to ensure that the specification s of the traffic plan have been met. There would be a street closure inspection fee collected for this service, and it would be identified in the comprehensive fee schedule analysis provided to the Council later this year. Staff had originally intended to present the Council with an all-inclusive type of package for road closures on N. Santa Cruz Ave., however after further discussion and consideration, staff determined that it was not feasible due to a variety of concerns including workload, staffing levels, and the associated costs that would be passed along to the event organizers. For newly proposed road closures, not on N. Santa Cruz Ave. between Main St. and Bachman Ave., the event organizer would be responsible for the cost of developing a traffic control plan, and this would be evaluated by staff on an as needed basis. d. Implementation of a standard fee and traffic control plan for closures of Montebello and the portion of Broadway in front of the Post Office : Staff is also recommending that the Town prepare a similar traffic closure plan for these streets to assist event organizers with the use of Town Plaza Park and the two adjacent streets. As mentioned previously, pedestrian safety concerns necessitate that event organizers need to choose between an event location that would close N. Santa Cruz Ave. or utilize Town Plaza Park, but not both. PAGE 5 OF 6 SUBJECT: REVIEW AND DISCUSS SPECIAL EVENTS IN GENERAL, AND PROVIDE DIRECTION ON TOWN FUNDING, IN-KIND SERVICES, STREET CLOSURES, AND OTHER EVENT RELATED MATTERS. DATE: February 7, 2018 DISCUSSION (cont’d): 3. Discuss and consider allowing unrestricted timed parking in Town lots for events. Past events have requested the ability to allow the timed parking spaces in Town lots to be unrestricted during downtown events. The relaxed time restriction would only apply to public parking lots, and the timed spots along public streets in the C-2, where residential permit requirements are not in place. In their special events guidelines requests, as shown in Attachment 2, the service clubs and non-profits groups request that Council eliminate restricted parking hours during special events and that no fee be imposed for this option. The Transportation and Parking Commission recently completed a study and observed that a normal Saturday has less impact on unlimited parking than during the week. The results of the study indicated that an average of 83% of unrestricted spots were occupied at the peak (noon), compared to 92% during the week (Friday at noon). However, on any given day where there is an event taking place downtown with the potential to draw a much larger group of visitors, parking can quickly become very limited. Given that most events take place on Saturdays or Sundays, and parking is enforced only on Saturdays between 10:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m., staff recommends allowing unrestricted timed parking during approved special events. 4. Other discussion items: Through the continued outreach, staff observed that many of the concerns of the community event organizers are centered around the unknown of new fees being identified and current fees being elevated out of reach. Aside from a fee for road closure inspections, staff does not anticipate any new fees being added to the Town’s Fee Schedule related to special events. Following the review and anticipated adoption of the Comprehensive Fee Schedule later this year, any fees that are being adjusted will not take effect until 90 days after the Council’s adoption (September 2018). Therefore, the current fee schedule remains in effect as it was last summer. CONCLUSION: Staff is recommending that the Town Council discuss and provide direction on a grant program, N. Santa Cruz Ave closures, event fees, and parking as they relate to special events. Through the Council’s direction on these items, and the previously approved amendments to the Special Event Permit section of the Town Code, staff looks forward to continuing to work with community event organizers to provide a positive and supported streamlined permit process. PAGE 6 OF 6 SUBJECT: REVIEW AND DISCUSS SPECIAL EVENTS IN GENERAL, AND PROVIDE DIRECTION ON TOWN FUNDING, IN-KIND SERVICES, STREET CLOSURES, AND OTHER EVENT RELATED MATTERS. DATE: February 7, 2018 ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT: It has been determined that there is no possibility that this project will have a significant impact on the environment; therefore, the project is not subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (Section 15061 (b)(3)). COORDINATION: The preparation of this report was completed by the Town Manager, Town Attorney, Interim Police Chief, Director of Parks and Public Works, Economic Vitality Manager, and Event and Marketing Specialist. FISCAL IMPACT: Based on the direction of the Council, fiscal impacts may be realized through the implementation of grant funding, fee increases or decreases, and/or in-kind subsidies for materials and services. Attachments: 1. Special Events Survey Results 2. Service Clubs’ Requests 3. Special Events Benchmarking Summary