Loading...
Attachment 1A— Ad — IR F M Ak I Liu Im THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Susan Kankel fmailto :susankankel@comcast.netl Sent: Tuesday, April 10, 2012 11 :16 AM To: Greg Larson Subject: Off -leash dog parks Mr. Larson, Having read many comments about Los Gatos having an off -leash dog park, and the perils and perks of such, might I suggest temporary solution? Since the Town owns the Dittos property and nothing is going to happen there in the next year or two, why not make it a temporary off -leash park? Automobile traffic would not be an issue, that particular section of Main Street is a hub for dogs and their owners, and it might promote some positive responses from the community. Very little would have to be done to the property, except perhaps a port -potty or two, and regulations can be copied from the other dog parks in the area. Please share this idea with the Council members. Thank you, Susan Kankel - - - -- Original Message---- - From: pamabond @gmail.com [mailto:pama bond @gmailcoml On Behalf Of Pamela Bond Sent: Thursday, April 12, 2012 4:23 PM To: Council Subject: unleashed dogs at Los Gatos parks Hi, I hope it isn't too late for public comment on the issue of whether to allow unleashed dogs during certain hours at several local parks. We frequent Bachman Park with my 2.5 year old and have since she was about 9 months old. It is a nice, quiet park for very young children specifically and already, there are people who leave their dogs unleashed at that park. We are usually there in the afternoon and there are generally at least 2 or 3 dog owners with dogs unleashed and running up and down the hill on the opposite end from where the playground is. It makes it very difficult to explore the whole park with our toddler because even though the owners assure us that they have "good dogs" or dogs that "love children" the children do not know this, nor is it possible to communicate this when they are very young and the dogs are active and jovial. We just avoid that end of the park though I'd rather not. I think that there is a reason why dog parks are fenced in. Bachman park is not fenced in and I feel that for responsible use as a dog park, the portion available for unleashed dogs should really be fenced in. I do think that dog owners should have good, designated parks to unleash their dogs and I believe there may not be too many in the downtown area. I wouldn't mind if part of Bachman became usable during certain times of the day, but I believe that it should be done responsibly and not at the expense of children. Bachman is one of a very few places near downtown to take our young children and I'd hate to see it become overrun with loose dogs. The smell factor is also a nuisance, I'm sure, for neighbors and park goers and so I'd hate to see it have more than limited hours as a dog park. ATTACHMENT 1a I can't speak to the other parks because I haven't been to them but I think it is probably the same situation at these parks. Responsible dog park facilities are a must where children and dogs are to play in the same area. Sincerely, Pam Bond 17121 Los Robles Way Los Gatos, CA 95030 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Thomas Tinor (tinor) . [mailto:tinor(a?cisco.coml Sent: Monday, April 16, 2012 10:03 AM To: Christy Wolter Subject: Off Leash Use: Bachman Park I will attend meeting #2 & #3 time permitting. I am a resident of Los Gatos (95030) and live near Bachman Park. I am a responsible dog owner and have used the park to walk my dog (on leash) for nearly 10 years. I do believe in "off leash" areas within designated parks, however I have seen that the dogs are not the problem. It's the owners who cannot control their dogs within a non - confined space. I have an older dog, and now have to walk my dog "around" the park for fear of a pack "meet and greet ". Many dog owners cannot control their dogs and they run "like a pack of dogs to any new or approaching dog. I have also had 2 bad experiences with off leashed un- controlled dogs running head and ears down at my dog. (Which I believe is a sign of aggression). I had to provide protection for my dog on both instances. I've also had parents in the park complain about the uncontrolled, undisciplined, unprotected area that these dogs are allowed to run in. If an area within Bachman is selected, my suggestion is to provide a fenced Rated area within the park. Not sure about the esthetics (since the open space is very nice), but the cost and maintenance of this confined space could be funded by the dog owner's themselves. I am in favor, which the specific users of that area (the dog owners themselves) either pay and /or contribute for the use. Thank you for consideration on this matter. Tom Tinor - - - -- Original Message---- - On 5/2/12 4:51 PM, "Britta Young < brittabo @verizon.net wrote: >Dear Council Member Steve Rice, >As a constituent of Town I feel very strongly that we should adopt the >provisional program for dogs off leash at the 3 parks in question. I >would like to see the parks opened for off leash activities from 10am >to >12 pm and 7pm to 8pm daily. This will meet the needs of all users and >allow a fair and equitable distribution of the Town's resources. > Sincerely, >Britta Young - - - -- Original Message---- - From: n e irwin < nancvirwinl @yahoo.com Reply -To: n e irwin < nancyirwinl @vahoo.com Date: Thursday, May 3, 2012 1:00 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @losgatosca.gov Subject: Off -leash proposal May 3, 2012 Dear Council Member Rice, As 27 year residents of Los Gatos, we feel very strongly that we should adopt the provisional program for dogs off leash at the 3 parks in question. We would like to see the parks opened for off leash activities from 10am to 12 pm and 7pm to 8pm daily. We believe that this will meet the needs of all users and allow a fair and equitable distribution of the Town's resources. Thank you very much for your consideration, Nancy & Glenn Irwin 315 Penn Way Los Gatos CA 95032 408 - 656 -1159 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Sue Farwell < s.farwell @verizon.net Date: Friday, May 4, 2012 7:51 AM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @losgatosca.gov Cc: Greg Larson < GLarson @losgatosca.gov Subject: Off Leash Trial Mayor Steve Rice, As a constituent of the Town of Los Gatos, I feel very strongly that we should adopt the provisional program for dogs off leash at the 3 parks in question. I would like to see the parks opened for off leash activities from 8 am to 10 am and 5 pm to 7 pm daily, or whichever times there is a consensus. This will meet the needs of all users and allow a fair and equitable distribution of the Town's resources. Sincerely, Sue Farwell - - - -- Original Message---- - From: "Connie Garske ( Ankenbruck ) " < connieankenbruck @gmail.com Date: Sunday, May 6, 2012 4:01 PM To: Steve Leonardis < SLeonardis @los at�gov >, Diane McNutt < dmcnutt @losgatosca.gov >, BSpector < BSpector @losgatosca.gov >, "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @Iosgatosca.gov >, Joe Pirzynski < 1Pirzynski @losgatosca.gov Subject: Off Leash policy Dear Los Gatos Council Members, I am responding to the off leash initiative which for most of us is a formality within the town in which we live. For those of us who have done the research, traveled to other areas that have successfully researched and practiced the policy for years such as the citizens of New York City, we have much to learn and gain as a society and as a community. Please view some points of those who have traveled before us and have years of documented data to support and illustrate why living in fear as it relates to these animals is moot. Proper planning and education can overcome those who are fearful as in most situations in society. Please read on especially the data under "6 ". Top 10 Reasons to Preserve Dog Off -leash Hours Policy in NYC 1. Off -leash dog owners have been repeatedly credited by Parks Commissioners with helping reclaim NYC parks from crime, violence, and decline. 2. The half million taxpaying dog owners of NYC deserve and need outdoor space to recreate with their dogs. 3. Off -leash recreation better socializes dogs, resulting in better canine citizens, which benefit the communities in which they live. 4. Off -leash Hours policy gets people into the parks, bringing New Yorkers together and making the City a more pleasant place. 5. Dog owners who use Off - leash Hours are a strong deterrent against crime in the parks early in the morning and late in the evening. 6. New York's dramatic reduction in dog bites from over 40,000 annually before off -leash privileges to just under 4,000 annually in 2005 coincides with the advent of the Off -leash dog recreation, official Off -leash Hours and dog parks. 7. Dogs off -leash in a natural setting playing, running, and being themselves are a beautiful sight for dog owners and most non -dog owners. 8. Many other cities and municipalities have agreed that providing off -leash opportunities makes good public policy and has had overall positive effect that strongly outweighs any negatives. 9. Throwing a ball, running with, and playing with one's dog is a legitimate park recreational activity. 10. Though dog parks are great, there are not nearly enough of them to meet the demand from 500,000 dog owners. I think data is something that greatly supports the stance of those in favor of an off leash policy and hope you will support an elevated society, not one that caves to ignorance. A Respectful Dog Owner, Connie Ankenbruck, Los Gatos - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Henry L Brooks < henry brooks @comcast.net Date: Sunday, May 6, 2012 5:26 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @losgatosca.gov Subject: Dog's Off Leash meeting this Wdnesday Mr Greg Larson, Los Gatos Town Manager: As a citizen of Los Gatos I feel that we should adopt the dogs off leash at the 3 parks in question Sincerely, Henry L. Brooks - - - -- Original Message---- - From: jennifer muraoka < iennifermuraokaegmail.com > Date: Monday, May 7, 2012 1:03 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @Iosgatosca.gov Subject: Off -leash hours Dear Steve, hope that you will favorably consider the plan for off -leash hours for dogs at our neighborhood parks. Thank You, Jennifer Muraoka - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Jeffrey McClanahan fmailtoJeffreymcc @amail.com1 Sent: Sunday, May 06, 2012 6:57 PM To: Diane McNutt; BSpector; Steve Rice; Joe Pirzynski; Town Manager Subject: Proposed Dog's Off Leash Program Dear Town of Los Gatos Officials, I am writing this letter to you as the Director of the organization of residents who favor an off leash program in the Town of Los Gatos, CA. The number of dog owners who occupy this town are in excess of 9,000. Many of us have united to work for a reasonable solution to park usage and shared experience of the land to which we are all entitled. When you review the proposed plan for 3 of the Town's parks to be utilized for a very limited number of hours of dog's off leash I would encourage you to consider the following: 1. Only the most forward thinking municipalities are up to date with real statistics concerning dog issues, ownership, socialization and recreation. ( This does not include Cupertino, which had an envoy appear at the first meeting in an attempt to end dog's off leash as they did in that City.) I would also seek that at all future meetings, only Town resident's be allowed to speak and make presentations. 2. There have been several public letters to either blog sites or the Los Gatos Weekly Times which have stated numbers and statistics which are not supported by the most reputable sources, or the statistics have been stated without proper context. For example, the number of dog bites occurring in the U.S. per year has no reference as to where the dog bites occur. As you can see from citation #1 below, the primary site or location of dog bites is in the home of the dog owner. 3. The largest city in the U.S., New York City, has a very successful and widely emulated Dogs Off Leash program that could be a model for Los Gatos. See citation #2 below. 4. We have a large group of residents of Los Gatos who are among the highest utilizers of the parks in Los Gatos. There has previously been no provision made for dog owners to utilize parks except by leashing their dogs. 5. There are many people who for one reason or another fear dogs, people of other races and /or ideas with which they are uncomfortable. These fears do not mandate that we eradicate every source of the fears. In fact, the Facist regimes of the world have employed this reasoning to create some of the most heinous acts in human history. 6. The group of residents of Los Gatos in favor of dog's off leash is attempting to create equality for the usage of parks for all residents of Los Gatos. Excluding young children, is just as upsetting to parents as is the exclusion of dogs to dog owners. Citation #1: Source: http: / /www.dogbites.org/ • The scene of attack is home or a familiar place. The majority of dog attacks (61 %) happen at home or in a familiar place • Dogs bite family and friends. The vast majority of biting dogs (77%) belong to the victim's family or a friend. • When a child less than 4 years old is the victim, the family dog was the attacker half the time (47 %), and the attack almost always happened in the family home ( 909 , 6 1 ). Citation #2: http: / /www.nycoffleash.com /html /FAQ.htm There have been many objections to the pilot program which employ emotion, unsupported data and the contentious statements without any substantiation. I have researched these issues and the above reference provides objective evidence to counteract the complaints. I am happy to discuss the validity of my or other's claim at any time and at any place. Please contact me if you have any questions. Sincerely, Jeffrey S. McClanahan, M.D. J.S. McClanahan, M.D. 408 - 205 -5301 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Jo Webb < career coach@mac.com Date: Monday, May 7, 2012 3:18 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice@Iosgatosca.gov > Subject: Off Leash Pilot Dear Mr Rice, My husband and I have recently moved to Los Gatos from the UK and are very pleased to hear that there are plans for a pilot 'off - leash' program in the town, in particular in Live Oak Manor Park. We would like to support such a move very strongly. Our Cavalier King Charles spaniel loves chasing her ball but has found her movements severely restricted once arriving in the US. In the UK it is standard for dog owners to have their dogs 'under voice control'; there are not many areas where they must be on a leash and we have 'right to roam' in most places. Although I totally understand and share people's concerns about dog poop I can assure you that we are both actively concerned to maintain the policy of picking up after one's pets and to monitor the behavior of fellow dog- owners. We feel that there are irresponsible owners (just like there are irresponsible parents) but that overall the positive benefits of limited 'off-leash' activity would outweigh any disadvantages. Sincerely, Jo Webb and James Field 130 Greendale Drive, Los Gatos, CA 95032 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: James Field Ofieid @me.com] Sent: Monday, May 07, 2012 3:20 PM To: BSpector Subject: Off Leash Pilot Dear Ms. Spector, My husband and I have recently moved to Los Gatos from the UK and are very pleased to hear that there are plans for a pilot 'off - leash' program in the town, in particular in Live Oak Manor Park. We would like to support such a move very strongly. Our Cavalier King Charles spaniel loves chasing her ball but has found her movements severely restricted once arriving in the US. In the UK it is standard for dog owners to have their dogs 'under voice control'; there are not many areas where they must be on a leash and we have 'right to roam' in most places. Although I totally understand and share people's concerns about dog poop I can assure you that we are both actively concerned to maintain the policy of picking up after one's pets and to monitor the behavior of fellow dog- owners. We feel that there are irresponsible owners (just like there are irresponsible parents) but that overall the positive benefits of limited 'off - leash' activity would outweigh any disadvantages. Sincerely, Jo Webb and James Field 130 Greendale Drive, Los Gatos, CA 95032 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Paul Bradbury ]°mailto:pwbrad(a0gmail.coml Sent: Monday, May 07, 2012 6:07 PM To: Town Manager Cc: Jeffrey McClanahan Subject: please help us help you To the members of the Los Gatos Town council; Thank you for taking a few minutes to consider our proposals for COHABITATION of dogs in the 3 parks under review. As a many year resident of Los Gatos and now a recent owner of a champion bred, show dog, please consider the foillowing. We spent ten years raising and showing dogs and now we seriously need space to be able to run our dog, especially to keep her weight down. I respectfully suggest that dogs can be controlled and are currently under considerable control especially in the Live Oaks park. Please come observe the dog & owners for yourselves and not just be influenced by the fear and the apparent lack of education that I witnessed at the last information gathering meeting? It was unfortunate that few were willing to hear OR cdonsider alternatives. We respect the concern and fear that some famililies have about dogs and may be able able to reduce that to some degree: if you give us a chance. A. Some of us are quite willing to have a "meet the dog" time. Where under close supervision, children and parents can meet some of the dogs that frequent the parks and (at least) BEGIN to learn to all get along and live together. i.e., My dog has obtained her "good citizen certificate" from the AKC (American Kennel Club) Its a formal test she passed demonstrating good behavior around people. Not barking, not jumping and not taking sandwiches from children. We often ask parents if they are ok with the dog OR are asked if the children can pet our dog. B. Many of us have discussed and agreed to "leash up" the moment we see a child. D. Others have volunteered to have certain hours be awarded (a time when NO children are even in the park). E. Many -Many of us already "pick up/ clean up" after our less responsible dog owners. It is noteworthy that many instances are from dogs on leash as well as off leash. We have each others back as we know and respect the privelage of sharing the park. F. Fenced Dog parks are not the (only) answer; In one well known park, there have been dog fights /injuries from non attentive owners, dogs not under control AND the often most important overcrowded, confined areas. people have stopped going there. G.In another recently renovated park, there is minimal PAID parking H. Many dog just dont run as much in a fenced in dog parkas when they are free. There are frequenhtly just too many bodies in the fenced in dog parks I. MOST Dogs need, and deserve, an opportunity to run free for a period of time to explore meet /greet and play with other dogs, without interference. With a COOPERATIVE effort by all, we can do this. J. We have agreed to "communicate and "support" other dog owners in the park, This will reduce the rangers time and efforts doing so. Just give us the opportunity to work out a solution. . There is no answer that will satisfy everyone as all of you so well know, but if we could only be given the opportunity to meet with and work out a compromise, we will never know IF we all can do this. There are many other topics to review and discuss, and I hope this plea for your help and support is well recieved and taken under serious consideration. Thank you for your time and attention. Best regards, Paul Bradbury CEO & President The Bradbury Group 408 - 309 -8095 cell From: Stephen Daly < stephenmdalype @ yahoo.com Reply -To: Stephen Daly < stephenmdalype @ yahoo.com Date: Monday, May 7, 2012 11:09 PM Subject: Proposed Trial Off -Leash Dog Hours Hello, I am a resident local to Live Oak Park and have been for 17 years. Originally I was going with my then preschool daughters (now college & high school), more recently with my dog,. I look forward to the possibility of a trial off -leash dog program. I find that the people that use the park are very conscientious and considerate of the park and the park goers. I believe that having "limited hours of operation" plan will create something much better then the typical dog park in that it will bring people together to help create a situation where the members know one another, look out for each other, & look after one another and foster a sense if community bringing neighbors together. I strongly urge you to consider and a program for creating rules and times for off -leash program. Thank you, Stephen M Daly, PE - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Anne Kiernan [anne_kiernan @yahoo.com] Sent: Tuesday, May 08, 2012 12:52 PM To: Steve Leonardis; Diane McNutt; BSpector; Steve Rice; Joe Pirzynski Subject: Off Leash Dog Program in Los Gatos Dear Los Gatos Council Members, As a constituent of Town I feel very strongly that we should adopt the provisional program for dogs off leash at the 3 parks in question. I would like to see the parks opened for off leash activities . This will meet the needs of all users and allow a fair and equitable distribution of the Town's resources. Thank you in advance for you consideration of this. Sincerely Anne Kiernan - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Priscilla Ryland [rylandpj @gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, May 08, 2012 3:07 PM To: BSpector Subject: Yes for off leash dogs Hi Barbara, Please Please vote to allow dogs off leash.... We are responsible citizens and as you stated at the meeting this would be better than breaking the law. Thank you PJ Ryland 131 Wilder Ave Los Gatos, CA 95030 408 865 1265 - - - -- Original Message---- - On 5/8/12 3:53 PM, "Victor Farah" < vicfarah @comcast.net wrote: >Dear Council Members: >Live Oaks Park is an integral part of our community. It is a haven that >is enjoyed by the entire community, serving as a playground, after >school sports field, a place to sit and enjoy its beauty or read a >book, and as a place where dog owners can enjoy their pets exercising >and playing with other dogs. >Since owning our dog, we have met and made new friends and acquaintances. > We have become more involved with the care and maintenance of the park. >We voluntarily police the park for everything from dog poop to broken >bottles, soda cans and tossed papers. >It would behoove all to see the community activity in this park on a >weekend or evening. A virtual 'Norman Rockwell' slice of life if you >will, with children in the playgrounds, dogs chasing frisbees, people >strolling, picnics, soccer practice, parents playing catch with their >sons and daughters, etc. >We can achieve this cohabitation. Its about time that people be >responsible, respectful, and caring for others. Will there be an >incident? Will there be a problem? Yes, there probably will be at >some point. But the real question is are people mature enough to take >charge and be accountable, without having to involve or demand the Town >to govern this or forbid that. Its time for us as community neighbors >to take care of our community and each other. >1 am a transplant from New York City. Believe me, if cohabitation in >NYC parks can work, it can work in Los Gatos. >1 advocate for the proposed program for off leash dog hours as a >responsible person, parent and dog owner. I welcome the "meet and greet" >proposal for children and dogs (it already happens on many occasions >when I walk my dog in the park anyway!). I support community life in >our parks for all to enjoy. >1 look forward to the upcoming meetings. >Regards, >Victor Farah >287 De Soto Drive >Los Gatos - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Chris Daly < cadaly @verizon.net Date: Tuesday, May 8, 2012 4:11 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @Iosgatosca.gov Subject: "off leash" proposal Mr. Rice, I have attached a letter in support of the "off leash" proposal. I hope you will read it. I would also like to thank you for your time and consideration regarding this issue. Have some time off leash at a couple of parks would only make this area where we live even better. Thank you, Christine Daly May 5, 2012 Dear Mr. Rice I'm writing regarding the "off leash" proposal. I am a wife and mother of two and to complete our family dynamic is a wonderful dog. I was at the first meeting at Van Meter School and I was very surprised about the comments against this proposal. There seemed to be a big group pushing the fear factor and also many people just angry about bad experiences with dogs. As a parent of course I want everyone safe. I know the group that meets regularly at Live Oak they are very responsible, caring, respectful people. They are people who live in the neighborhood and care for the park. We pick up trash, beer bottles, dog poop, and fill in gopher holes. We take pride in the park, the neighborhood and the community. We meet with our dogs and families when most people are not there, off hours when the park is less populated. Our being there off hours helps police the park and deters unwanted social activity and vandalism. In most dog training books and information on line it states how important it is to socialize your dog. Not just with other dogs but humans as well. Dogs need to run a lot, which is hard to do on leash. Exercise helps keep dogs happy, more controllable and calm. Just like people who exercise produce endorphins and endorphins make you feel happy, more balanced and calm. I have had my dog at the fenced in dog parks and I find it hard to meet the same people. There are many people who just run their dogs there after they get off work. The dog has been cooped up all day and they think if they just let their dog run and play with other dogs that's all they need to do. The groups that usually meet at the leashed parks really take the time to interact with their dog and the other dogs; they are more attentive to the dog's behavior and activity levels, as well as taking the time and effort in training their dogs. We try harder because we want to make it work, for everyone. Have some clear defined hours, like early in the morning and later in the evening would be wonderful community friendly thing to do. Sincerely, Christine Daly - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Harriet Lundquist < harrietcutts @verizon.net Date: Tuesday, May 8, 2012 8:10 PM To: Steve Leonardis < SLeonardis @losgatosca.gov >, Diane McNutt < dmcnutt @losgatosca.gov >, BSpector < BSpector @losgatosca.gov >, "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @Iosgatosca.gov >, Joe Pirzynski < JPirzynski @losgatosca.gov Subject: Off Leash Dog Program in Los Gatos Dear Los Gatos Council Members, As a constituent of the Town I feel very strongly that we should adopt a pilot program for dogs off leash at the 3 parks in question. I would like to see the parks opened for off leash activities . This will meet the needs of all users and allow a fair and equitable distribution of the Town's parks Thank you in advance for you consideration of this. Sincerely, Harriet Lundquist - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Rodriguez, Linda [ mailto :lindar(abserenogroup.com] Sent: Tuesday, May 08, 2012 9:38 PM To: Town Manager Subject: Off Leash Pilot Program To: Greg Larson I am a long time Los Gatos resident. I have lived in the Bachman Park neighborhood for over 15 years and, I am a dog owner. For the past four years I have joined the group that meets at Bachman Park in the evenings with our dogs, off leash. Consistently over the years many of the children and parents in the park have come over from the children's play area to pet the dogs and enjoy their company. All members of this group take pride in the park and clean up after their dogs and are very careful not to let their dogs in the children play area. I am in favor of an Off -Leash Pilot program in Bachman Park for designated hours. All dog owners should take full responsibility for the actions of their dogs, the maintenance of the areas designated for dogs and most importantly be proactive with dog owners that have unsuitable dogs off leash. In addition, I am in favor of the off -leash program being limited to the dog owners within the neighborhood of each park. A tagging system should somehow be a part of the program. I feel strongly that if this is not enforced each park will be negatively impacted with dogs and dog owners from outside of Los Gatos. I hope that the City Council gives the responsible dog owners of Los Gatos the opportunity to test this off leash program. Thank you, L ndavS. Rodwtgaek 408-234-6083 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Je Delwat @comcast.net] Sent: Thursday, May 10, 2012 10:04 AM To: Town PPW Subject: Dogs Yes for off leash Sent from my Whone - - - -- Original. Message---- - From: Leesa Gidaro fmailto :leesa.gidaro(abgmail.com1 Sent: Thursday, May 10, 2012 7:31 PM To: Diane McNutt; BSpector; Steve Rice; Joe Pirzynski; Town Manager Cc: Leesa Gidaro Subject: Dogs in our Parks! Dear Town of Los Gatos Officials, I am writing you to express my support for an off leash program within the Town of Los Gatos. However, I believe we would ALL prefer the status quo over any proposal currently on the table, and there was overwhelming support for this by both proponents and opponents during the community meeting last night. That said, I would make the following points: - As a dog owner, I have seen first hand that organized groups are far more likely to properly supervise their dogs, and care for our community parks. - As an active user of Bachman Park, I can attest to the fact that dog owners create is far less vehicular traffic than those who frequent the park for other activities. Parents, children, and members of organized sports organizations (such as Tai Chi) often show up in cars, while dog owners visit the park while out walking the dog. - As a resident of Los Gatos, I've also seen firsthand that dog owners far outnumber other park users at Bachman on a daily basis. On any given day (during the school year) the park is virtually empty, with the exception of dog owners and their dogs. They are the highest utilizers of Bachman, and as tax payers should be afforded the same recreational use of our public parks as anyone else. My hope is that town officials would prefer to see this segment of the population of Los Gatos utilizing our public spaces rather than an empty park every morning and early afternoon! Please, let's adopt more progressive practices and ensure Los Gatos does not continue to lag behind other communities across the country with outdated views on off leash dogs. Sincerely, Leesa Gidaro Cell: 408 605 -0075 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: 7Seas (Comcast Mai)I [kian @7seasimport.com] Sent: Thursday, May 10, 2012 11:28 PM To: BSpector Subject: Off Leash Program Dear Barbara, Thank you for your effort in trying to resolve the current dilemma with the off leash dog issue at Los Gatos and Monte Sereno. As with many issues in life, there are forces of competing interests at work, one side that demands total safety and security at the parks while on the opposite sides, dog owners are demanding freedom to have their dogs off leash without breaking the law. I support the implementation of an adequate off leash program at the parks in Los Gatos and Monte Sereno, which aside from providing a needed open space for dogs to exercise, it would also decriminalize that activity of many good residents that have been marginalized as outcast in the eyes of the authorities. As for the safety issues for having dogs off leash, I believe the answer could easily be obtained by studying the reported incidents involving dogs in the cities that have implemented similar programs. I do not know the answer to this questions but common sense would suggest that there would not be much of an up tick in these reports. On many occasions, my children and I have enjoyed the companies of other fine dog owners in the early evening at Bachman Park. While the dogs share a playful time off leash with other dogs, the greater joy to us have been a sense of connection to our neighbors and community. As such venues, where neighbors gather and community strengthen, becomes less practical in our time, it would be especially a sad loss if it falls victim to excessively cautious regulation. There are no ordinances or regulations that city council can enact to forge neighborly relationships and build a community, it is simply not within its purview. But you do have a chance to protect and enable these assemblies where such relationships are fostered and in doing so, add a little joy to our four legged residence. I hope your final decision would address such a need. Thank you and with much respect, Kianfar Kianian 408 402 5330 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Laura Howard < Iaurgome@vahoo.com > Reply -To: Laura Howard < laurgome @vahoo.com Date: Saturday, May 19, 2012 12:28 PM To: Diane McNutt < dmcnutt @los atosca.gov >, BSpector < BSpector @losgatosca.gov >, Steve Leonardis < SLeonardis @losgatosca.goy >, "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @Ios atg osca.gov >, Joe Pirzynski <JPirzynski @losgatosca.gov >, Town Manager <Manager @losgatosca.gov> Subject: Off Leash Hours at Los Gatos Parks Dear Town Council: (1) As residents of Los Gatos, we support off -leash hours for dogs and urge the Town Council to approve the pilot program currently under consideration. (2) The Town has purchased a small piece of property on Ditto Lane that has no heavy vehicular access, but it does have easy pedestrian and bicycle access from Ditto or from the adjoining trail. Since that property was purchased over market value -- apparently with Council's or Town Developer's consent but without notice to the citizen's of the Town - -we suggest that that property's use be for the citizens as a park and an off -leash area. Sincerely, Laura Howard and Gene Faucher 35 College Avenue Los Gatos, CA 95s030 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Mark Wainwright Finailto:mlwainwright@mac.coml Sent: Monday, May 21, 2012 2 :45 PM To: Diane McNutt; BSpector; Steve Rice; Joe Pirzynski; Town Manager Subject: off leash hours for dogs Dear Town Council: As a resident of Los Gatos, I strongly support off leash hours for dogs and urge the Town Council to approve a pilot program currently under consideration. In my experience near Bachman Park, dog owners have been very responsible for cleaning up after their dogs and for keeping the dogs separate from the children's play area. Sincerely, Mark Wainwright - - - -- Original Message---- - On 5/22/12 9:25 PM, "mpb2419" < mpb2419 @gmail.com wrote: >DearTown Council, >1 have been a dog owner and resident of Los Gatos for the past ten years. > During the past two years I have taken my dog on extended walks where >I've met dozens of responsible dog owners, also Los Gatos residents. >Most of the time during my extended walks I have found area parks >nearly deserted. At these times I've taken the opportunity to let my >dog off leash where he is free to run in a restricted area well away >from children's play areas and /or people that wish not to deal with dogs. >Despite how the Council rules on this issue, I will continue this >practice at the risk of a citation. >What I would propose is what makes a good community a great community: > reasonable compromise. Such a compromise may take into account times >and areas of a park when these parks /areas are not populated by >children or others not wishing to encounter well trained /behaved dogs. > My suggestion is Sam until 9am and then 5pm until 7 pm that dogs be >permitted to run in specifically designated areas of certain parks. > These are times I have personally noticed an absence of people, save >dog owners, at most park areas. >1 also suggest accountability in the way of an Off Leash Dog Alliance >that would issue photo identification of owner and licensed dog through >Los Gatos Monte Sereno Police Department at the full expense of the Off > Leash Dog Alliance members. Suggested regulations to this membership > might include: > -Areas of dog play be restricted to at least three hundred feet from >any obvious (sandbox /jungle gym) children's play area. >- signed agreement by all members that would include provision of up to >date inoculation records of all dogs wishing to participate. This > agreement would include a provision to hold the City of Los Gatos >harmless and would thus hold the owner of any participating member >absolute and complete responsibility for the behavior of the dog in >their possession. >- membership in the Off Leash Dog Alliance be residents of Los Gatos. > -a committee to investigate any /all complaints of citizens regarding >dogs in violation of any policy /procedure agreements set in place by >the City Council, comprised of members of the Council, Off Leash Dog > Alliance, and at large members of the concerned community. >Just an idea so that we might find a a reasonable compromise. Thank you >for your time. >Michael Brown > Monte Sereno - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Leslie jmai Ito: cree56(cbcomcast.netl Sent: Wednesday, May 23, 2012 3:26 PM To: BSpector; Steve Leonardis; Steve Rice Cc: Diane McNutt; Joe Pirzynski; Town Manager Subject: Off Leash Hours - Yes Please Hello, I am a resident of the Bachman Park neighborhood. Please approve the pilot program which you are currently exploring. have been here for the past 27 years and have always enjoyed walking my current and past dogs off leash. I have not seen any dog fights or problems with children at any time. I have met many lifelong friends and so has my dog. Please record my vote in favor of off leash hours. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions. Leslie Holms - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Anne Kiernan < anne kiernan @vahoo.com Date: Tuesday, June 5, 2012 9:34 AM To: Dorrie Romero < DRomero @losgatosca.gov >, " gcsparrow @comcast.net < gcsparrow @comcast.net >, " bra nt@browsersys.com " < brant @ browse rsys.com >, Christy Wolter < CWolter @losgatosca.gov >, " edpurchases @comcast.net < edpurchases @comcast. net >, " garrettpainter @aol.com < garrettpainter @aol.com >, " jon a lambert yahoo.com < jon a lambert @yahoo.com >, " shylo51095 @yahoo .com < shylo51095 @yahoo.com >, " kdeloumi @yahoo.com < kdeloumi @yahoo.com >, " robrennie3 @aol.com < robrennie3 @aol. com >, " sandylgordon @vahoo.com < sandylgordon @yahoo.com >, Todd Capurso < tcapurso @losgatosca.gov >, Steve Leonardis < SLeonardis @los atg osca.gov >, Diane McNutt < dmcnutt @losgatosca.gov >, BSpector < BSpector @losgatosca.gov >, "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @losgatosca.gov >, Joe Pirzynski < JPirzynski @losgatosca.gov Subject: Bachman Park Off Leash Support Group Letter Dear Los Gatos Council Members and Parks Commissioners and Staff Please find attached a letter signed by many of the Bachman Park Off leash support group which we would kindly ask you to take into consideration when deciding on the Los Gatos Off Leash Program. Thank you in advance for your consideration of this matter. Sincerely, The Bachman Park Off Leash Support Group - - - -- Original Message---- - Prom: Terry McBriarty [tmcbriarty@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, June 06, 2012 8:00 PM To: Council; Town PPW Subject: Off Leash Dog Park - A Mom w /kids and a dog who would like PM hours Terry McBriarty 15075 Garden Hill Drive Los Gatos California 95032 To Whom It May Concern: I am writing with regards to the proposal of the off leash hours at Live Oak Manor and /or Bachman Park in Los Gatos California following my attendance of two out of three of the community meetings and the Parks Commission meeting on June 5th. I was unable to attend the first meeting at Van Meter at which apparently the first and only poll was taken as to who was in support of and who was against the off leash pilot program. I am a mother of two boys. One born in 2005 and the other in 2006 and have lived in Los Gatos or the vicinity prior to their birth. When they were very young I was at Bachman Park at least one day a week 2006 -2008. 1 was there as part of an organized playgroup through Las Madres, so there was a regular group of us in attendance. One of our group members lived very close to the park. I became aware during that time of the off leash dogs at the park. At first I was concerned about the off leash dogs but over time as I could see that the dogs were generally well behaved and not interested in the children but in the other dogs I had no problem with the off leash dogs. The dogs ran off leash in a large area on the grass and if the children wanted to venture into the area where the dogs were one of the mothers would go and supervise the children or redirect them back to the sandbox or play structure. I don't remember any negative incidents occurring in my years there. My friend who lived near the park and had two children (the same ages as mine) never expressed any concern over the off leash dog behavior. I mention this because she went to Bachman twice a day for about three years during that period of time. I understand that there has been a vocal group of mothers who have complained about the off leash dogs and that some of the Park Commissioners have gone to Bachman and expressed concern that people have been "frightened" of a dog or knocked over but to me this is part of sharing the park and the self - righteousness of the people who have children and believe that they are more entitled to use the park than those with dogs offends me. Some people have children and some people do not. Some people have dogs. I do not think that the dog owners are asking too much in asking for a few hours a day. Perhaps 1.5 hours in the AM and 1.5 hours in the PM to start and the hours could be expanded if they work. 9- 10:30AM and 5:30 -7PM perhaps. Compromise. Sharing. Cooperation. Community. I live within walking distance of Live Oak Manor park and would love to be able to walk my dog there and be able to play fetch with her or watch her play with other dogs and interact while my children are able to play safely in an area that is appropriate for them. This is not poinp to be possible if only the voices of the people who want separation of children and dogs is being heard. NOT EVERYONE WANTS THIS. Just because these people are the noisiest doesn't mean that they are the majority. I am offended by the manipulative fear mongering that has gone on at the meetings and the position that these fears "must be addressed." Really? Dog bites happen that is true. No one is denying that at all but there is no increased correlation between off leash dogs and biting behavior. In fact the opposite has been found to be true. My Mom friends with dogs at Van Meter ask me when the the off leash dog hours will be up and running so we can have a playdate with the dogs and the kids at the park. We won't be able to do this if only morning hours are approved. Perhaps the council could look at a schedule that would be MWF and Tues /Thur to allow AM and PM hours at each park? I know that this suggestion will be easily thrown under the bus as "too confusing and complicated" but especially those of us with children are used to juggling complicated schedules and those with dogs are already used to dog park closures. The Parks commission had discussed cancelling off leash hours in the event of a birthday party or large event so it seems that perhaps the pilot program should have some more flexibility than is currently planned to be built into it. We are planning in June but I am not sure when the program would actually commence. Hours that will work in June, July and August won't work in December when the parks will be in total darkness so the pilot program seems like it perhaps would need to be a little more flexible. So many concerns arose out of the community meetings and some on the Parks Commission felt that all these issues needed to be addressed before a pilot program could be addressed. For instance the problem with dog waste at Bachman. No matter what happens with this program there will always be irresponsible owners and those of us who are responsible cannot control or be faulted for the behavior of those owners who are irresponsible, though numerous responsible owners have stepped forward to try to make owners responsible for their dogs. The off leash dog program shouldn't be responsible for all that is wrong with dogs in Los Gatos. Several people complained about their dogs behavior while one leash towards off leash dogs. This is actually due to poor socialization of their own dog and if they have a poorly socialized dog they should not walk them during the off leash hours. http: / /www.aspcabehavior.org /articles /155 /Dogs -W ho- Are - Reactive -on -Leash. aspx So much has been made of the danger to children being bitten but they are actually much more likely to hurt themselves by falling at the playground. http: / /www.aspcabehavior.org /articles /57 /Doq- Bite - Prevention -.aspx In New York dog bites actually dropped off considerably with the implementation of off leash hours. http://www.nycoffleash.com/htmi/index2.htm While there are presently off leash dog parks available there are not very many and they are often very crowded at the peak hours. When they are very crowded they are often crowded with larger more aggressive dogs which is uncomfortable for mid -sized easy going dogs. I have witnessed many a problem at the Campbell dog park and as much as I think it would make us sound very stuck up if we set up some kind of program to limit our to Los Gatos residents or to specially grant permission to dogs to be off leash I think that would ensure the success of the program. This would be something beyond just requiring they be licensed in Los Gatos but evaluating each dog for appropriateness for being off leash. People would of course have to pay for this service. I would be more than willing to do so. I would love to bring my dog to a dog park where I know that all of the dogs have been evaluated and have been determined by a qualified individual to not be aggressive and to be appropriate for off leash behavior. http: / /www.bouldercolorado..qov /files /openspace /pdf brochures /vs -doq- brochure pdf I also would like to see the council to explore a location in Los Gatos for a dedicated fenced dog park in addition to approving this pilot program. Los Gatos is a town with 9,000 dogs and those dogs have varying needs some of which would be met by off leash hours at their neighborhood parks while others need a fenced park not because they are dangerous but because they are just a little too unpredictable and might just run off. If a site could be identified and a budget set perhaps organizations could help with fundraising to build and maintain the dog park as I know there are a lot of people who would really like to see this dog park happen. I was at Oak Hill Play Lot today which I once again found littered with cigarette butts. There is a large cement area and a large dirt area that do not seem to have any discernible use and could easily be fenced and used for off leash dogs. Perhaps increased use of the park would cut back on people drinking and smoking at the park. Of course at a small park of this size we would want to limit it to Los Gatos residents only, but even with our limited space available it is possible to find spots for enclosed dog parks if you care to look for them. Another option is to enclose the children's play areas at Live Oak and Bachman so that the children would be safe from any dogs running amuk. 1, for one, loved enclosed parks when I had younger children because you knew they they wouldn't be wandering off. Please do not listen to the fear mongering people who apparently write letters and attend meetings for fun but don't actually go to the park very often. The meetings were attended by many people, some of whom hadn't even been to any of the parks! People who sit at home and write letters or complain at meetings should not dictate the behavior of people who go to parks on a daily basis. These people who use the park on a daily basis deserve some sort of compromise in some hours for sanctioned off leash use. Sincerely, Terry McBriarty Van Meter Mom of 2 Terry McBriarty tmcbriarty @gmail.com tmcbriarty @comcast.net - - - -- Original Message---- - From: " gcsparrow comcast.net < cg sparro @comcast.net Date: Thursday, June 7, 2012 6:44 AM To: BSpector < BSpector @losgatosca.gov >, Joe Pirzynski < JPirzynski @losgatosca.gov >, Diane McNutt <dmcnutt @losgatosca.gov >, Steve Leonardis <SLeonardis @los atg osca.gov >, "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @losgatosca.gov Subject: Dogs Off Leash Councilmembers: I moved to accept the staff proposal to the council and got 5 votes. I am rather neutral on this subject, although rabid on the subject of dog excrement. Every time I go up St Josephs, I pass (and usually pick up) at least 3 or 4 bags of dog poop that have been left on the trail (probably by owners of dogs on the leash). There are also several piles of poop just left on the trail. I would request that if you do initiate the pilot, that you consider what you will do if it is not honored. le, if dog groups /individual owners do not adhere to the proposed off leash hours, poop scooping, etc. The blindness of people to the obnoxious behavior of their dogs is unbelievable. It took me personally months to get it that my yippy chihauhua mix (don't ask) was driving my neighbors crazy. From my own informal polling, most people are against the idea. However, you have an untenable situation, and the pilot might be the best solution to put this puppy to bed. I found this article about what is going on in Vancouver, a hotbed of DOL controversy. There are lots of links, but I think worth your time. htt : w ww.vancouversun.com /life/ Left +leash +dogs +bites +worse+ than+ their +barks /6551504 /story.htmI Barbara Holden, Parks Commissioner