Loading...
12 Staff Report - Moratorium on Death Penaltyr r t ~ .RM1 F f VA~ • - 'M- kw gone" K F S R R R4 i 8 MR, 112 The people oj'die State of California do enact! tlssfo``Itc~tiys.' it SUCTION 1. The Legislature finds all ck,' et es,' fO11011?tng: ~U Pui-suant to Senate Resolution 44, on August,' A2'7 r - )0~,~ Ze1 4 Senate resolved to establish the California Co312th1T Pion, otp Aet Fair.4dmbzistrcnion ofJnslice_ R (b) ne Cali%rnia Commission on the lair ,~i!(f7ziitisi~;cttir~r~ o~ justire I-v71I Studv and review the cadt7iirzistrcCtior~. irsti e ii.. Calunrniea to determine the extent to which 9- failed in the Past, resulting in 14?i"0ngf al executiony or' the w wrongfid conviction of innocent persons. The' eommi:SSZOi21 ~V11 ~ examine ways of providing, Safeguards, and tna~ingi(ityp"Ovejnoltsf 9 ® in the hall the criminal justice sYstein junetionsmnAitrake-anv rcoommerrctcaions and proposals designed to ji,'tt'tkTe nsat ,tllc t; 14 the application and adrni'nisi~,-ation of crirrliila~ jatsiicer inr 1' California is just, fair-, and accurate. J6 (c) The commission will be conducting its, wor4 mdi trrust] g 17 complete its stwh and make aria, recommendatibnsre rin,5j e 18 p . December 31, 2007. i a 19 (d) There arc current7v more than 640 inrna(eVo)r' d1:aX.rowm e 24 in California, more than anY other state in the-, coasnti1~1; -ante'' - p 2-1 those 640, more rhan 20 have appeals pendia2g' ih t&--.Ninth' 22 Circuit Court of Appeals, which is the linal!lirodeclitral, sheep R 23 before exc-etition dates are set for those inomies(. ti117iose, 24 cot2victions and sewences rise al rmed. 25 (e) Because 'the inature state of the appealsi child, ~gaa 26 pi oceedings in 3o many death penalty appeals, it s[ Jii 77F~j '7ilcel w 27 that prior to December 31, 2007', dozens of exe~'Wion! dates Tv'z M 28 be set, clemency proceedings will occur in dioseicases'„RclerneW.yi 29 clecisions will need to be made, and if clemency' -not,"gr-antrW,' 3,0 e ecutions will occur, all without the benefit bt-'t"lieL Ccrl'if~rn -a 31 Commission on the Fair Administration oj'Justicg-,sii 6 lings1atid; 32 recommendations. 3 3 y) In light of the final and it-revocable na£uAv 4'lee: deaA 34 peiialty, and to ensure that no innocent person is. c !elf°exm~ziter~i#i~ 35 this state, it is nmcessaty to place a rnoratoriutt zot~ ~ c 2ttigrt ~ 36 until the work of the Cal ortzia Comrnissibir., on] tlier Fai ) 37 Adtninistrution of.justice is completed. n 3$ • SEC 7 S'cetion.3700OfthePenal Code istirr~Er2~edflo,:tte'ud:;~ ds a ~ a ~ a, i ~a ~ I 19 s R Iwo OR @ aA I fW iks h&t ftJzURns 3 OW t. thVygW i Al VST First Degree murder'trials cost about S650K. Dead P t liy ease we sfi ep~#: lr +t r 1~. t t. 'i s f Degree Murder cases tape about 5 to 7 years. DeaW Fenat[Xi- cases,take Aoutt141Xeam-, approximately $90,000 a year to house an inmate 'ordealh,row- compared. fo,S30jP9*forAcigeneral' population resulting in an Additional.cost of $57.5,'mitlion annualf$., It is planned to ibuild a new deatL row to Sant uent .att et►sf~tt { 'Under the d th penalty system tials:have two separateul has" conviction ,aut ~scnk'encing):: Convicted defettdauts are catitled to an automaticfapRVA l~!Ihre~+investigative~eost's,aretgeneta'll~' incurred in capita! case, particularly * the proseeiitj$fk Innocence Issares` Over 1.17 persaus ha+ve been :exonerated [d leas ri cl'e~ttii, aw.,~2/ ~f ib; 3e talt!vt convictions are set- aside. f Parole on, a Capital Hart 'ehaxge was released ail t+~x;' er; g 9~ s; tiu+e s * several million dollars (there were two misiria'b)., The Senate Rules, Committee has appWated a Camtttissiiw: ~f~#l~' t~r'~d'm (created by SR. 44) to shady the critniiital,Xttttie+e s~~st~ t~ ~ti~~]ty~~ S rt. r_ .P_' a NOOkAIM over.100 olrg#aixatioas have paused' u n uen, e a Iut ,ii t fu ,Saga . r : Countylloard of SupervMirs gad Palo Alto City C'ouoak Rer~~til +arlh~ t~tlll:I:~is1 ati~s 1~si dyents► Iiave signed ara#oriaztt petitions., Alsp,, yvg f'eee%k~i7Q0A o r' o Town oun l s nks- aliforuia Law gave mabicipalities aacl c~t~ta ~l~a€t~t t~;`i ~as~l r~s ut fr~tpprf - national, local and state policies." Pafa.Afto CoUWciPM' a W&' eri*T&4 'Unfonattily homicides do occur in Los Gatos. hnctce, person~~lia~,er t~ cc nvikf4of;'cavUa t murder. Surely the case of a Buddy Nickerson u t i es asre t3 laws tzessi. ltQ~e~fra~ a a t death penalty acts us all iwhe diversion of pufflic tud't.lh'al oKh used4or,'ctl ►xeventioa,,?. violonee preventioul, assistaneoto faulty 7mesn0ers~oltitic#iras aritl!,au~rssc o'ks' ~ ~m Requcst to the T wutoupcR It is requested that Los Gatos Town Council suppodi arreso tion:3callingi f4r'g.moratoriium:or.*ei death.penalty wl %t the Commission on the Fair, t3fjm nistr ti n+,of'J ~stiee►stndir s: thv-criminai. justice system and the death penalty (scheduled td,run! M70!yca-rs);, ~ ~ ~ e ~ P 0 ® ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~ ! i , e a m ~ -:9.. r September 27, 200 d 5. Debra J.1onB, TQll~2 l~arl~i~~ rJ 4,F- Town -Manager's Office Tc lvn of Los Gatos 114,EjVlain Street , Ius Gatos, CA 956 ~Rc: ~`acke~~f'~o~~Councl~ei~tbeis,'~5ctol3e~~'~'~.1~ouricil;?~~'et~n~; Dear Ms. ivone> A group of conectri d Los Gatos residents Walt. "ac fress~t t IoAWn'" a,t'tli , s-eheduled October 3, 2005 Town Meeting rcc~t~~ s#i~~;a: lt~vadUt,,g .Wza$Qr`un~; cm executions. in C=,alifomia Please find ® important background info-nnation on this criti`ca7.a'ssue.-. Vv:e:•wouff el Jac 5~~ atelzil;~ ~ votl could distribute copies of this info rmatiar dafcket.~O.' t} i v r' arid;t" 1 ,Iembersprior to the October 3,"2005J~Ieetir%;. `Ti~ia~~l~.;~ai~for:vourftss s~ai~ti'e~lt tl~~! ti matter _ i5incerely~ ~ Tare Hills ' 1 06 1 b9 vasona 0alti5'Dr ve ~ I, 7 os Gatos, CA 9-503` X408)39-5-9230 Enclosure_ Dt ath Pmalty Mo ratmiuin 13acl<grn m a ~ R q jF AK ' jea aTsa p Y w imp' -T, 't 7rgam a CaUf e ~ ,v fun- I - .-w p it 3 P w a Mktg r + R&n&l~fflw FrZ tf ~ili'lw ~1 s*& x, 9M W-ft AMA s ~#A~'1~1ti11~1d r 4 4 MR NIXAMELOW E i t3 ~ 1DtjW Y e_ Y ap w C w w r y ~ ° a rR ® n A a ° ~ r y R ~ w r r I r r ~ r h - - ro a ' A 4 "1 E „ R e 16 y r uhf ya kf m m R; ,r. a R u ;e 8 a AX r R m E0 0 v r n WA At, ra ftokatx* W' mimmh i NNW a y a R ~ t in a a R R Al 1 a ,A . Q Fact Sheef a COSTS A d It costs approximately 560,000 more a year to~liotrse(aar,inztiae ~i#~.t`eafli.iroailiah: in the general prison population or additiari~tl`edst:df!~r9. million.,nnurtll;~ o First Degree murder trials cost about $650'j k'., -Death Nna'1(~;{casesl•cost hmutM.Ifo: SM Al. First Degree murder cases take ahout,5t foi 7,),i caw take about 20 years. Additionally, it is planned'to-build;-A:tiew,dUAtliwov#4n:Sai)I Quentin at a cost; of S200M, . g Elimination of the Death Penalty may safety, violence pr~vcdttion programs aqd;rqlrscfI.,4olk, °PigL>tz!o'cence Is~ucs A Natio3nal4,, 1.19 persons have been exonerate'd' atill jr:eleaNe.&rroTff.dr tir:t'dA,.~a 7V ("V f -death penalty convictions are set aside. E~ocall~;}~l3'utldcl~rE'c~:esu„entst to: !A'e ImprisonM- t Without Parole on a C;:apifaI{1VIuz~~,er,~ `1i:rrge„rKas~re`lease ftn, a. judgc'sorder after serMyvear Thecosfsiof;flitslcasct~~:laic~AcXttlIniisilral cost millions of d4 iars The Senate Rules C6mmittee has appoint i'jY,0MItU4oii: on:lher. Eair. Administration of Justice {created by SMOI ' lsfildrvthe t:rjminaA' streerssst;em and the death penalty. 7 Town Council BtyiAacss? "California Law gave municipalities, and ~ojlnflcilthe,raut~pxity'ltgripa~s; r"olulipnsi pertaining; to national, local and state polidr'es:,7P41b.AY& 6puv.cil • Lnfortunately homicides do occur in Los G':. Os; Jhnocenl; pvrsous,` Rayerbeen, convicted of capital murder. The extra cost'sioT'lh'tydl -,atl ,penaltv'iaffec s: uslsa'll; in+t-trer diversion of public funds that could be used ~n ~rime►p7~vetlu€i~crii;,assts#aiicei#tt a a 7amuy wemoers or YlCktlm ano our scnoois,. 1115 lC UK1. 0,01nale(I foal, tile, 1:011 ,4c Councitilas passed a resolution on a rnati4fna~ sti ~ 'Yli l+rieal.'atxY ion s dealiif with 11M Tatr•i-ot Act. 01 -Eeuaest to tine yown roatr261 It Is requested that'LO S Gatos'T w'n Coil nci'l-sugPoi-n::resdWio'ii calling for-.1w :tnoratorium on tine death penalty wrrilst the-( t~lr►missaiin,~in+'fS e: is r cirtiYtrist7li tide of Justice studies the criminal jtis#ice,system+aauf,Ihe~tteo r: en alt`". (~cfi Of Ilec~I run for 3 years). life rp: ]gfaets92305 a _ - G, b i 4 e` c{itQ Facts Moratorium 3urrt DPF About' rganiza it its alIin l f em, do { California " Gtv of Berkeicy City of East Palo Alto City of Mer,lo Park City of Palo Alt~~ " City of Portola valley{' " City of Oakland Oi y of -dlmas " Cit. of Santa CRIZ ® City of Santa Monica City of Sebastopol 0ty cf ""Jest I-}o;lYsvood County cfAlameda County of Marin " County tlf Sari Francisco F ' --aunty, cof Santa Clara lnii Black Mrn of Los .Angel Im! A Course in i41,acies Study Group (tihreedj " Abn!iticn R-)ad (Rohriert Park) :action Coalition for Global Change Action Resource Center (Venice) ® Adnan 171orn nrcarr Sisters (Cplifovnia~ " alarreca C:)unty Democrat c Central Committee A.lameca County Dern-:)n-atc t awvers Club, " I~.lareda Corinty Lamocratic Party Ala°11eca County Publir Def' finders ASSnciatiorl ~ AIpioM Farms (Alpine) A Awencan Civil Liberties ~rn;cn (AICLV .j =c,P Northcw California -of Southern California " Ee;~keN~y Chapter " 'Marin 'Lhapter " ° honterey Chapter Redw-)0"I Chapter " p -Gakland Chapter " -San t?iec o -hap,ter "Santa Barbara Chapter ~Sinta Clara italfey chapter :Dcnnraa County Cr.apter " A}I Sain<< Church (Pa53draj All Saints Cathr_,lic (--mrch (Los Angeles) ~ ~~.nerlcans for Democratic ~Wtion (Lo-q Angetes} Ftr-rcrlcan Federat!cm of Teachers, AFT Local t 21 (San d( Ci;CDr}~ j =,n-jencan Friends Servi.re Ccmaiittee. r raci°fc SDcuthwest keglon -Waufx~ t~tur.rltain Reyios~ " ,lime icon 7er~;tsh Cornrrtitt_ee (tcs,~rigeiLsf ~ firne; icar 7ewnh _ rijr2_ s nr11FlC2,Arab Anti l~I ilrllnatlQi} Cr;r~i;717ttee (H,J t; 51 , Arnnesty Nlerna'tional JS-L, , Caiifornia High Scnc;ol Chapter " -Hill-rest chapter =Lair: Ccunt'y Lila ;t', , mlIt~Gtar g ~ -Los Angeles Chapter_ #467 a -Marin Chapter ° -Oak View Chapter °°-Oaklard chapter -Ocean Beach -Palo Alto Chapter -San DiegD -San Francisco Chapter ° -San Jose Chapter -Santa Rosa Chapter Sierra Foothills Group ~6288 -University of Redlands Chapter' p Arrhdiocese of Los Angers, Office of Detention Ministr v Archdiocese of Los Angeles, -$an Gabriel Pastoral Region s =,rchdiocese of San Francisco Area Support Group for Family & Friends of Prisoners Armenian (?rthodox Church Art & Revolution Gonmwence (San Francisco and Santa !E~uz!Grouil }r Asian Arnerl an Tar Association AFian Lava Caucus (San Francisco) " Asians & Pacific Istande,s f r Community Errpawern,ci~t°( f~I~ Oi; act raneis~o,~~ ° g Association; of Micro-Po;v,=r Broadcasters (Berkeley) BEiv Association of San Francisco Bay Area Campaign t6 Free Mordechai Vanurru Bay Area Police `catch (San Francisco) Berkeley Bowl Marketp? ace uu ° j Berkeley Democratic Ci,tb Berkeley Fel!owsNp of Unitarian Universal r gerkelcy Gray Panthers (Berkeley) ° Berkeley Peace and Justice Ccrnrnission (Berkeley) ° Berkeley Zen Center ° L'uverly Hills Bar Assocratirn (Seuerly Hills) ° E.iPol, Jewl5h, Bisexual Caucus (San Francisco] ~ ° ciiFcl San Diego ° Bca3 -d of Rabbis cf Northern California Books Not Ear_ (San Francisco) Soys and Girls Club of Venice y Buddhist Peace Fellawsnip (California) ° ° 8udc1hist Peace Feil ws'iip Prison Project Butte A.ilianC~ fOr Medical Marijuana (Chien. California Attorneys for Criminal Jusdw California Catholic CLn*ere ce ° Califarrva Chumh IMPA+'T California COalktiGn for Yeomen Ptisonef T~aiifomia Ciemocrettc Party ° California ;'acuity A ssovati n -San Franc= State University -Sari Jose State University Califamia/Nevada-Kims al Conference of 1ha,` ked Meth d&f:C4wvh: Catifomla New re21 (Sl) Frank}sco) Calf Pala People Of FaAh OWN, Against The DcB", Pe~:IY?ri`~~~~1 ° CahfomJ2 Pris n Fccu< (San Francisco) Caiiforma Proven>e of the Society of ?e Is ° Cafifoana State bar Cordeon_ce of De.eaares Carifurnia Young Democrats rCampagn ra End the Death Penalty (Berkeley and L3s_hnc~e9'e~cfiapters , Ca:-rnetite S,ister5, DCJ (La Mesa) Catholic Worker cf Orange County Cat ciic~ Against the Death Penalty Center fcf- Environmental Health (Gakiand) ° ° Central California CtIn,Yaw WNW Committee (Fresno) nwo BE of R.igms Defense Cornmume ! .ntrs ;an Prophets or Jehovah, Inc rresnj l "hard h in Clc&a~i Parr (United Methooistl ° CISPFS. (Los Arsge;ps) Toy of Nameda Dernocrat'c Oub =laref t0';`. ~rrllt~ l l!lethc)d.tst Churcn litip death pe_nahyO # I dex.ph p?pid~CL~uli~lf Community of Nurturing Ccriversation (Santa Rc5a) Conference Paard of Church and Society for the United M1eth~dist)~?hurcFi . Conference c-f Delegates of the California Bar Association; Conference of Social Justice Coordinators of Southern CalifbrA'la, Congregation of Beth-Ei Council of Churches, Santa Clara County ($an )ase) ® Criminal Courts Bar Association Criminal Defense Lawyers Club of Sari Diego m !l riminai Justice Consortium (Oal Land) Critical Resistance (-Oakaand) 'Cull rer Marina Bar Ass0ciat'or C•eath Penalty Action Team ('San Francisco) Death Penalty Focus D:emncratic'Nomen's Club of Santa Cruz County Dernocratic Women s Forum (San Francisco) Democrats of the Desert (Riverside Coutity-) Dioces-e of Oaklard ~Diocese of Sacramento Diocese of San Bernardino 'diocese of San lose (Hur an Concerns rorrirnission), Ochres Mission Church (l_qs Angeles) Dnrriiriran Sisters of Missicrr San lose Dominizan Sisters of San Rafae; Dominican Sisters, St. Catherine Priory (Anaheim) Dominican Sisters, St. Frances Cabrim Convent,Los An~r1e!v. East Bay Church of Religious Science East Bay Community Law Center East Bay Peace Action !Albany) ° F1 CerrtO Dwrnc;crati: 01,t s a Ella Lauer Center for Hurran Rights, Espera;lza: (Huntinat, rn Beach) Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, Sierra Pacific Sytlo1, Faith United Methodist Community Church (Los Angelesl! Farr~iffies to Arre'nd Califorria's Three Strikes Farnily and Friends of Prisoners Support Group Father Bill aDannell Social Justice Committee (SerkeleA First bletlrev l Cnngregatinn •af Oakland; Temple Sinai I.Frst Mennonite Church of San Francisco "First Unitarian Universalist Church of Sari Francisco First Unitarian Universalist Church of 5tuckton Fast Unitarian Universalist Groups of San Diego, Peace ap~iFDemo~ra~y= ;Cti~ri;Gf;c • For'. 3clnes ~Jnlted Methodist Church, Adr-wristrative Council! ZEt'na~ Franciscan Affinity Group (Berkeley) Franciscap Sisters of tr,e Sacred Heart (Altadena) R.re` rfc Center for Tel m iolerrce Friends CDnimittea_ or, Legislation, of Ca!iforgTia (Sacrarnt!nfa)'j Gr°audmothers for Peace Tntemational (Elk Grose) Cray Panthers of Grater Oakland Orav Pantli,ers of Mann ~~3rav 1Ianthers of Sacramento Gray Panthers cf San Francisco gray Panthers of t-'est Ccritra Costa County ,EI Cerrito ' )t Greek Orthodox Cathedral of tl',e Ascension ((7akland ';!eater H'aV'ward Democratic Club - - R Green Party of Alarr,eda County Grer~ Party or Lake County fGrccn Party of San Diego CauriN Hayward Gornccratic Club Headwaters Action video Collective (Redway! 'Hire; Desert Catholic b%orker (Riverside County} f-"Ol' Faitn Fptscapai Chur'eh {Tngiewo d; Hlousino Arnerica (San Franc;sco) 1Hunian~'..eIatirti°,s Conlrni_,sionr City of Los Ange±es 'Hun' a~, Relations Comriiss cn, Orargr County Hufnan Retations Corrm;ssion, City of polo Al*_c Hur,-, frn efz r, ra C ,-rrri;ssiun, City of San Diego Human P,elatio ,s Commission, Santa Earbara I:curty f;~t ~i ~eatll~~ malt ~r %indc~ plip" piil~coalt6ol ' n a~ ~a r i 1 o. k ~i~atti ~'~~a1i~~•Fc~~~s m R r a ~ ~ Human Relations Comm ssior, Santa Oara County HunZan Rinhts Commission, Marin County Hurrran Right's Watch - California Hunrbotdt Mediation Services (Eureka) Hurt~hofdt, Unitarian Universalist Fellowst7ip (Baysidc-7 irnmacuiate Haa,,tCommunity Inner Changs (San Francisco') Interlaith Councll on Religion, Race, Economics, & Scoat.~Ustice (53rflos~)t International Jewoi h Peace Union (Berkeley) International Museum of Hurnan Rights (San Diegol Islamic Networks, Inc. (San )ose) lanes Mar-kunas Societ-i (San Francisco; ~obs for a Future/Homeboy Industries (Los Angeles) Zahn George Dernocrattc Chili (Oakland) Kehilla Can)munity Synagogue (Ferkeley) ~a. Kennedy Club of t1he San Joaquin Valley (Fresno) Koi An-i Congreqation ('Nest Hol'ly~.vood)~ La Peru del Stir (San Francsco) La Raza Centro Legal (San Francisco) I_ab'or/Cc,mmunity Allianc=e i_Coarsegold) Labor/Community Strategy Center: Community Riaht.Pri3~jeCt Lake County Democratic Club Lakes?'are Baptist Church (,Dakla_ndj p 1~ eague 2f United Latin American Citizens ~-state aoard " -Salinas Chapter Legal !~et-vices for Pri onevr with Children Lesbian and Gay Insurrc,ctian t-f-,GAI) Little Portion Franciscan Fraternity (Irvine} Los Angeles catholic V:lorker `Loy Angeles Couhty Bar Association acs Angeles County Publkc Defenders Assoclatiorl 1.~Ds Angeles Tinges 3 'Lutheran t11fcP of Public Floilcy (Sacrarnento) 'Lvrica Jerlchorr'busticDn -;Berkeley; T4AJESTIG: Murnia Abu-Jamal's' Emancipative StanforIll-earr, Ihvestiga a f~a~c~el j•",aria County ,P'rogre'ssives w Mann E~eath Penalty Moratorium Movement Harih Democratic Club Mat-in 1-Act-faith council fi-Iarin I Aerfaith Task Fcrce one the Americas lt-lcbarq! Commnnlcations (Darla Point) Media Alliance (Sari Francis Gj Mzdia iatc! (Santa Cruz) a Men Fnab4in?g Nev, So'u:ion4 (Los Angeles) h4ercv High School N'etropnlitan Greater Oakland Democratic Ciub h7iCah C:S Monter=y Cc~u.it,; interfaith Conirr~ittee for Social' tie ust ' r7a_t HOIl Redeemer Roman Catholic Church Mt_ Slia~;ta Reli4ious Science SoJetu Nlusiirr. Putiic Affairs Ccuncil (Los A.naeies) , tJz'io lz,l Association for the Advancurtwnt_of trolorea Peoplet kP `~l P P Eureka Chapter P-^onterey Penninsula Chapter -Salinas Chaptr-r Sata. Cruz Chapter -Sant 'a Rasa/S nOr7ra Co._ir~ty Chapter Nationai Alliance for Positive Action tSouthern CatifQrnj4 National Cog', tion of Free hien, Northern California ChaplY' rh- National lawyers :wild, San Francisco bay Area Chapte;; t,!atit)nal Lawyers Guild, Los Angeles CFrapter NeighL'; r^C., 'Unit3r r. U'iversali5t Chiurch - Social Jristiq~~C ti~r~'a fi! v ncii;.( sa 7erat~ Netvior" , for a ;-late Free Comij-,unlty, Santa 'Qara Ccunt:>l. New F~-llo6vsh(o United Church of Christ Church (6erl:e!ehy Ne. rc~an Center "_HthicArc Community; ,UCSDe Pdicaray~;a Center ,fn;' CGt'n1l;jnit+,~ fs. *ion (Berkel.eyl r I a. ~ c ~?earS~ ~esri~)h~ oC~3 ~ -~af~e1•~ ~f~'S{ m ~ worth County Tmie.i NQithern California Interreligious Conference: Peace WA:J'us€i'ceiCh)vjssian, , Northern California War Tax Resistance Oakland Coalition of Congregations - CFergy Council " _ Oakland/East Bay Democratic Club " occidental Arts and Ecclogy Center s O'Conner Hcspital Parish Nurses :office of the Americas (Los Angeles) " Older Women's Leagues, San Francisco Chapter OLINC: Publishing (Fre',nc) " Orange County Coalition Against the Death penalty ' Orange County Death Perialty Watch oui developi;rg wot-Id (Saratoga) " Our Lady Df Guadalupe (Fremont) C)dt of Control Lesdian Committee to Support Women Poiit~~~aEPrisori'ers~~Sa~Francis~ " Pace e Berle N,m iotence Service (Oakland) " Pacific and Asian American Center for Theology andsStrategjes e eiey) ® Padre Serra Parish ° P,.sadena Mennonite Church " Pa mist -ornmunity of Los Angeles 7-Os AnQe!_s)= Pax Christi, San Ffancisco Bay Area a Pax (fhrrsti, Sacrameiltn R Pax Cr isti, t. Joseph-Fremont Peace and Freedom Party, Los Angeles Peace and Freedom Party, San Francisc~a ent f n~mitleel Peace and Justice Center cf Sonoma County s g Peat7e Fresno Peaceful Justine at Caltech " Peninsula Peace and justice Centai Alt People For ]ustice (Sari Diego) Peopi;, Power! [Santa Cruz) " Peta'euma P;roaressives L " Phvsidans fr r Social Respoisibdjty, los Angeles Chapten' " Pilprim's Hope= Bible Church (Los Angeles) " Foor Claire Mi-ssipnary Sisters Porteruille Unitarian Universalist FeilowFhip (Tulare CoL&Cy.-)i Prisrrn Acti i5t Resr,urce Center (Berkeley) . " Prison Educatirral Foundation of Sonoma I-ountj Prison Moratori_im Project (Oakland) Prison ~ RaJiu prvje(J ;,San Francisco) Progressive )evvi51' A. Nance (Los ,o,ngeles) P'JFBLO (Oakland) QUeen of A,rkg Is Cattiolic Church (Alpine R.3bbinic Assoruiation of Greater San Jose Rainbow/'F'JSH Coalition 6?ei;gious of the Sacred Hurt cf Mary- Leadership Tearry p -th +1~d~~5terr;5 e,irari;F;rO.VIFr 75~r `;eligiouS 50Cilety cf Frienrjj,, r.entral Coast Preparative I,t~°~irac : eliaious So--iety of --Fiends, ChIcc) " Rc;4.gi0us SDciety of Friends, Inland ':-alie~,i RA'igious Sc, Jety of Friends, Marin Religi:;us s'nciet,,, of Frield•s, Moriterey Per;insula m " R, lHgious Society cf Friends, Grange Grove Meeting P.eiigio is : irty of Fr,°r7ds, PFiiD Alto Religious Society cf Friends, Redwaod FCrest " Rt. lleirjus ,,---laity Qf Fri--nd- San Fr'c ndt;c-10 . RrllgibLrs -Society of Fr=iends, Sacramento r°leetinW Religicu, [society of Fnerids. Santa Barsara Pee igious Society of F'i=nds, Santa Cru:. . " " R cus Sec _tw of Frig ds, Ukiah " Reli•gi~us _cciet•y! of Friends, Vthittier Monthl'y' Fleeting f eligious Witness with Heim=less People,(5an FrarClwcoti,~ Richmond Oia'rcE Democrat--c Club (San Fr-an Cisc~t 0 f vsaliG Pizza (San Jose) SaCrarlas,lto County Green hart;: Sacrc --ieatt Gi,urch : F;ancho ucamonga j S~fcrec ~Yart Co,~wenl Donvntcan Sisters,(`Los ,Angeles4t r ~a,r. eas R.nt~on ' 4ague lilts ir<itl;{~et~~~IT'~~ ort.~~ii~~~e:~:.~~1~}~~~~c=~i7~(itt~~t~• a•~~'~~~,~r~5.{ " 1, 01. ~I x r TAM. #~49W 1' UP- Rosa d~ z Maw ' %9*9~ 0 N erg tos FX& AWN - N=Z ill" . ft ; W-k R II I 1. 5 a ~ . a St. Peter's Convent (Sai~_ Francisco) ~ St, Peter Clauer (Simi) St, Philip the Apostle Varish (Occidental! St. Raphaet's Church (San Rafael) WSurvivors Internationai (San Francisco) 7emenos Catholic VVorker (San Frandsco7 ' TernPle Sinai (Oakland) Tenderk;,iri Housing Clinic (Sari Francisco) Thro~-,p'Unitarian UniversHst Church ~fikkun Community (San Francisco) TIKKUN Magazine "San Franciscoo 'Tools for Zhancie (San Francisco) Union for Reform 7ud tisrn - PatifiC Soutf-,',Y0st Council Unita!ian Universalist Cliurch of Davis Unitarian Universalist Church of Long Beach a Unitarian Un>versaltst Church of Monterey Peninsula-Socia( covci~m5:~ornmittcq Unita-nan Universal+st Congregation of hsarin Unitarlan Universalist Fellowship of Redwood City-Social Acb',3n.Cory mitteel Unitanan Universalist Ministers ,Association-Pacific So ,th jf$trj tt~ dp erg Unitarian Untversahsts of San )dater-Sociai Concerns Ccr;imfttee, United Educators of San Francisco UnivErsity of San Francisco Peace and Justice Coalition, Ursutine Western Pro,4;nce (Santa Rosa) Valley Oak Park ;Santa Rosa) Victim Offenders Rc _ornctli'aticn Program of MonterEy Mote Health (Oakland) War Resisters t<eague, Southern California Chapter' de5t Contra Costa Rainbow Coalition (Pichrnond'i Wo.- lnet Praductions (Gan Bernardino) )Women and U,Icrk Stud,/ Group (Berkelcy) LVornen s Equity Council of the United Nation Associatic:rr ~,Samtai~ V-.'emG^ s T.ntemational League for Peace and Freedom (kjAJ PFId Monterey Chapter - -San Jcse Chapter -Santa Cruz Chapter Tiie Workmen's Circle/Arbeter Rin_a of So(Ittiern r:aliformal (t~1o5f ~~a~~1~5 Youth Advisory Task Force. Santa Claru,~.b unty Youth Law Center (San Francisco) *A rna)onty of council members, sent letters to,the Govprtlorlillaieurof'a]res3lukio ' r There are also over 100 NatiQCtal 'dittg^n Ameri ar, Rar rssociation American Psychiatric Association Art,,er can Fsyci,~olctdical Association Ar,-nesty International Black: Radical Cargress C, tOc1i,_ Cnanties JSr,A. Fpisccpai Church, 73rd Gererat'Can~er~tion ellcwship f.F;ecogihrli t dr';~ Jev i;h Council for Pubi'le Affair's Jev~;sh Peace Fz!Iakv hfc. ,EadArs;)ip Conferer;ce of'IVnfnen Religious League of Indigenous, Sovereign Nation? of the 'Nester=n:Eiernispn~re~,~~crihau rc4t€b i~ Gtr+Ipj (League of Unlt;,d Latin. American `C; tizef~s ' t~h?GR° NAACP ~ Notion~P Assoc'ation of Crirmrai Defens= lawyers, MatiDnal A,ssocation of Social VIo~kers National EiuC 1--aucus Df State Legislators vatiunal Black Poiick, A, soc+atian National Confer-2nce of Blacl< Mayors National Cay and Lesbian Task Force Fea~_e Action Pecple ion thti Arl`erjC-ar) tr,+aV U,,icn of Amer can Netr,~v,' Ccr;r re~a±i on ~ t~ ~r~~,cicall,{~er7zl;l,, or itxle :;al~~'~id= c(a litia~l 911. 5 Union of Orthodox )ewish Congregations of`America Unitarian 'Universalist Association of Congregations United Artists Against the Death Penalty United Bectrical, P.adio and Machine Workers of America:(JE.)t to see a list of Joca! jurisdictions that have+ passed a:YesalLtlbn;i 'Last Updated March 20LM; e p L40( For Site, ~ Leh did death{»naltyr~'rr~ ~ fepiiane 4~5;x~~.fl~4~ . ae s a 16 . Ott{ l'~=, t~~.~ . catltpei~ 31t c~r4 Irk . l1p'?pPd-coaliti0 r I M J I 1 1 $ ~ k, a L m 9 . ~ ~ a 4 Fact Sheet COSTS It costs approximately $911,000 more 4 year'ta, ,©use;anAh te:btf,&AthF rd`w,,tlat1tt in the general" prison population or $57.5 millioni annual;, r First Degree murder trials cost about $650K;r WWI! Netialf~casesl ctisli Aout'. SEZf to: $1.3 M. First'Degree cases take about 5 to!7'_v, earrW. ~;eatii~'e~►aTt~~eases~ta'~e[al t, 2(t years. It is planned to build a aew, death row in Elimination of the Death.l'ettalty would free. u,ft'tnd'Efacanta~ ecuTi safety, violence prevention progt-Ams and f0schooft, Innocence Issues Over 117 perse :aye:been exonerated a,1i'. as dtc, cat` a 0 o f penalty convictions are et:uside.. tdc is C rs u',,s l n T ~ e~ Imprisonment 'Without Parole on a Capifal;lVlttrd'erLeha k s!~~Feasedfptl'a, j aid e's order after serving „l~1 yes~rs> UV. cosNOf-' fi1N-C: !sW",& b! left tb!'24"i'sfri~W cost millions e!.fdoIlarg; ahe Senate Rules, Caminitteg'has a ttt a; txmmi`ssionTat~t~e~ a r,~ Administration of Jitsti+ce (cre40 'by ~ ~4~t~SIud3~'#lie,cCrimi~ ~aStlceTSVstet; and the death penalty. "own COUROIR-Usinessl - - ~`twa fornia Law gave municipalities' and count" sj)licrnutliorit; Aos))ass! resa`luiio rcT pertaining to national, local and state policies;"'c!€1'lfc~,czuncilrentex'Iileiner,'~ 'Unfortunately homicides do occur in Los Gatos ,:nt11kceW;persons-have[been. convicted of capital rnttrder. The extra c~fsfslAf,Ilie, atl%'p~t~il#~~a QCt~ uslall~i~u.tlt diversion of pubfir funds that coati! be it d.fif Oi ferpteVettlib'tiAl,_ ~tane~ o faniily ,ffletnbers° of °victhns and, (var'schoolk, d fewest toAbe Towrt Conpcil y It is requested that Los Gatos Town Council''suppro tta ira~cilnl~tY,rall' tt~~for.'a' moratorium on the death ,-malt v habit tit ~.f h ulndi i' tt: ei ant d}~iil i ttati~ of Justice studies the crithinal;justice sy a uaAerc~ent~~e~~l't~ ~,~c?Ii~du~ .Yo: run tor 3 years). e ~ a 9 ~ K ~ e tE' i I ~ ~ Y lit i' ,.MW o-. f 4 W p 7 ~ 9 ~V S ' el- "Zt" m E a e a y~~F}upL~%[+~~, ~.Ey~Y~~~.]Rl1Q~$FCI,rv'~~~ ~~y(~5~~~rE ~gggy yy a ~ Ott 94 AT a mial y .gi yr5y NAM ~Y a WIT p ~A SNdSt~'~r€t ~ ~Fd ~ y ro ~ ~ kvet t 'ft's' ~1sa' . f ~z .Pied tMat~r'EaI' ;api lad w ltn tai q ~ B~ shim '"-www"'Mom-~ m®r-InSAM lo =M1 t AL anti onam "to a .d :-fit A a 4 W 3 3 I MA s i s f ~ s a n ~ r sd i d a r ~ yv r c ilk A A ~ a e 16 IL 4 s i a Rf t4 S w~ F n P a e a kDg n a Fr ~ t b* w- L419 a *ftw*4z-*- Wow had, No IrM mv, M ,F g x r ~ b 3eala Fe1[t~ F~~c~t~sK<'c~• , R A 9 I i obstetnuan detected fete t ~13earttones and concluded that'tttelfe~jus:diLt'no€;appear,t3DjOeiihi4apardylr C?n September 30, 1979, however, fetat'hearf tones eoultf'~otlQngen'b?lydeteEtec~and.t~~;fefUSttivasL considered still-born. Kevin Lie green, Oianna's husband, said he was not horfi7q at` ha fi'a-rel or;'t41ie; e~;eLtt:, r'- ptestitied'fhat: hef left the apartment, went to a hamburger stand for food, are,diy;Oren'Eeu-etiurned;•f4jund'; iis;MiLer had: bee it." attacked. Police confirmed his presence at the hamburgeT'staki V; itQ4 cqunteY•tgiV,'v4j a tf~E fogedl ib'his! pQssession was warm. Stilt, he was arrested and tonvic diol~ O:ctober'Z1, 119.80', of 'r hrs I~ifa;L+r ho iaad: receiver a severe injury causing extensive brain damages and~am e ra, estifi d~aaatnst hiknj. D'us 1g. the investigation it was learned that vaginal slides takenifiern'[~i8nna,LGreent skowe&Velpresencemfl spermatozoa- % Kevin Green was found guilty t)y a jury of second degrees~urde,'for~lief8ea€Fr of,~;ie~ ~re>7orn'tetus~,, ftAel ,attemp`"d rn+jrdr r of Dianna Green, and assauit v jth a d' adiy,'weapani sn~~ianna' ~'t~erl.,~~n.figY,er~~er;' 7, 1980, the court sentenced Green to fifteen years to N-'(Lin!state p'rison',, after the creation of an offender t)NA database, Catirornla"s:t~egfarfrrent:al~J'usti'certaborafor,,"i~T Caii€crnia, a DNA prof+le from the sperrn.atozoa in reer(~+rdyr v~ 4urd, ~ riot h r~gC~rr,fe n., Gerald Parker, a serial killer called the "Bedroom usher" for'.br',Eakin~nt'c51t'omen;s~Qdingl~~dlCb' ape, and kill them, confessed tc the attack as well as five other mur~~rsr,lLas°~f.pn:ffii'stbE~i~u~ciaf~base,t51}; and Parkers canfesston, Kevin Green was exonerated andirel'easedla-fter'spendi~rc~ sixfee ,years 6,11 prison. n October 1999, Governor Gray Davis awarded (irep 6U ;,J;eO I in> com,p r7 atro(': fgr'tt el years, hg spent in prison for a erirne he Jid not commit. (5ouree':;T#~e'llYin'ddd{it Pfo ect~; am Owens - 1985 Aaron Owens was convicted in 1973 for a doubie tiorniCi~r~rl 4~at~ieda,Cdu~St,i:, ~E wfi~fvd~td;fikel`r;have reCeivcd a death sentence if the Supreme Court had.dot hlefdEoL~i'y~ a,fewtmo ~±ti5reartier, in: F).arman v. Georgia, that the death penalty was unconstiturr nali.,$erausetor the roraEorii~rn'or~ t ?L death penalty in 1971, Owens received a sentence of Lifel-rul Rrisorr', ~nsltta~+ v~ntua7ky~'exbn°Cated' with the help of the presecutcr from his or iginat trial, JoXirtFTaylu} r, ~dy4'd realf~g'df~N~t e ,s+f?adff~e rH risidentified # y khe kev eyewitness wher, Owen's co-defendarntlfi'nalt'v,a mitted'ttiaf'fie,andha~no'fher' I. non had committed the murders. Owens Spent S `Dears i'n.prisoiV, d l^~ If 1t:1'c~d~113t:b2e R:'Ji' thel Sup,r°errre Court imposed. rrcratonum ongthe death psnal'ty~,~ie1 rria~~~hav~L~~er rExeeut~d~, s Ciit-'& Site M rsener;l f~wF11i3 infwf)deattlpenalY-y,0--gam ~ ~~~@~~ld~llf t 419.2;43'. ray ~ v ® ~ s Jattp J'/,,vavx. death pen, L'r I Broken System: Error 12ates in Capita~-Cases,,1l~7--~-;f99 -James Liebman, et al, Colunibia ~ :aw Set'odf, XOO(4 ff Abstract: n there is a growing bipartisan consensus that ftwsii tiArericasreaf` psnalt~ys}err! ha~{>[ reached crisis proportions, Many fear that capira.t'triaksirLItLpecp'eir~rt^t}eati,.t~ ;iwh pt~"; Leiong there. Others say capital appeals take too I'o~g;.~rii's~r~porf;,f~retfirst;s€ati'sttcal',sft{cl+~: ever undertaken of modern American capital app ears}(~;~~ 34cf}ifie0a~inis~af~,*c~pitai;case,sl ~ between 1573 and 1905), suggests that both ciairaps.aeicorct', Capital sentences do spend a long time under di ill;t view, s,t i !~fuds~~Fdoc~r ents,. ho+rre rer, judicial review takes so long precisei becatl~eiAZ1~ r can{ capi al:~p fences~ar t~~ persistently and systematically fraught with error'ttjal{gpribgsij;;A io~am(nQs.tt~.,V,('abtiity'. Our 23 years worth of results reveal a death pe~alt~ns~stem; cc~l(apsir~g1 nc7et the ;wergl t'}of' its own mistakes. -they reveal a systern in whictj lives,and pttblio►ordej arA-at'sta~te,,yet,foG' decades has made more mistakes than we wo~l'd~foierate,~ipEfat'i'es~ is~~ptfant'a~tivtfres.. 'They reveal a system that is wasteful and brokYer at?d, e del ~',f3 :addr ss d: a Our central fincings are as follows, ,Nationally, during .he 23-year study period, titie{ov,erall. afelofl.pzelL~dicia7;eCrur,'in li { American capital punishment system was 6fgiothi~ I ' wprdsr~'cc,ur s~ fp i?t Fs~r,ia~sr. reversible error in nearly 7 of every 10 of`the tE~ousa~~sof,~capita7;sen#e~c~~ t~z~;wer-~ fij l~ly~ '?evievied during the period. Capital Ss ais produce so mary mistakes that i#x,t keslt?ire judicial;insi?ectlc.ns:fo;~cat~k :tl eta;, leaving grave doubt whether we do catch them:ail'../ `ter, stat~fc urt5~tkirevl uf! 7°'~1bfideath! sentences due to serious flaws, a later federal, reljew q6LOa;"'5erio~si.extor,",'rerro,~ undermining the reliability of the outcome, in 4'%~c?f'tf~~;en~in~rig seac'es,. Because state courts core first and see all the!case's), ti b L l'ofm4sttt~eM~at f,'c rr~cflr ~ arroneous death sentences. Of the 2,370 death s~nte cestthrti~^rn odtkiiie=fo: serio.us!~rKari 901I were overturned by state judges, many of'wf tars'~'ere[tr€l ve~yi l.cadge5.~~ golf ~pcseal t~ death sentence in the first place; neariy afl of wfibrr~~w r :rlt? ~ti: Ereh'clden( a thel f~l; c,torate~l and none of 41hom, consequently, were dispose~iCtai ovet` r'rr~ ~ath!senferiees:ei cepft~or,' very good reason This noes not mean that fetral.t~vie~vtikirinEnessaCy'.Pilecise(yr 6ecausa o` the hL.ge amounts of serious capital d ~rot''tliat~'sfatela peli fe jradges•ars~ca11' df upon to catch, it is not surprising tt)a,t a substanta,n4~C~ 'et'bf'f#i ~capit l;}ucfgrr~ewtsltlie tr thro~:g`; to the federa; stage are still seriously flavavd., "To lead to reversal, error rnustbe serous, ind~e ThefrC{ost!carr~rnard rrcrsr~nromptr,~g~a> majority of reversais at Lila state pcst-corvictiori stag j,areL('I~!e r,eg'iotu y i rr ete:nf; defense lawyers who didn't even look for, and.d!~u oostiz 557f n-t S8~Ej„ im~o7~a~41~vt~fercei~li'ari the defendant w s innca:-nt or did not deserve -t'Ea:tfl :and:7?_ t ,aliee~~r resa utorsi' ~fi'c:*dlc~ discover that k hd of evidence but suppressed if:'ag rlk'~ep~n i'Drl,t p3 fo4?..,~F'. urrdrecls•4: ex:arnples of these and oth2r serious errors P eport. ] r 73 Q u to a 6 'q 1 e, - i =IIAVw- Zip 1' - , "Pl- Wig% m a• a I A ~ B t R ~ is Pt Y ;I I' x m ~ ~ R 4 a~ A 6 ~i Letter from Professor, RUth Silver TaUbO#,to:.tap4.j. a atQS,• ekl,L"f'fmrt: , Augus'1,2,0051 w w I any ve; y disappali,nted in your Editorial of August 10- ~085ientitl~dt Town faces death penalty - Garcia wo+.1d be very hap~ytiarN nf,ycu-r,l cove.,ace of the issue. You matte no attempt to prouide~Fa,balanceN dlsc~:ssion of the pros and cons of the moratorium oft it's;rel€;vance'tcl ocal governments Instead you chose to ridicule the;iT©wn Councijst cecisi)n becaUSe there hasn't been a hanging in Losl(5afoslsi~cp; In fact, Vice Mayor Diane McNutt and Councilman 5t~vel(~;li~kmanf5boOI'd:6ej applauded for voting to glace the moratorium issue gp,thel age0a:6ecausel of its iisca# it {aact an feral governments. Accordinge~atNf~rgh~ 18!E 198-8 article in the Sacramento Bee, California spend"sj$zQ !T-tifionf do';ars on capital cases Ir annualiy in addition to the ord'pa,ry~ qs_t of the justice system. The cost of a death penalty senenclarr'pxoeeds,. the alternative of fife'mprisonment. As Ccnnecticut'SiCljiefVater F,;torney stated "[e]very dollar we spend on a capital scrist-a~do]f r' we~can`t spend anywnere else." A total of 11 Californiriti~acJld; count-es have passed resolutions urging lawmakers fyn halt ex cutli~rlstifa; California until the fairness ard risk cf executing innocen'fPeflpleiar~e] studied This call for a moratorium on executions c~fa~ciclESr uvit~ tf)a S'ate's appointment to study the c6minal justice systern.and!t~tes~eat~ penalty. Santa Clara Ccunty passed a resciotion to OFgeir3wmat"ersitCE hall Caiifornia executions until its fairness and the risk o' xECUttha innocent people are studied. In his study of the deatfi,~er;a# }7t~i'r~;~OGt~~, Jamey l_eibman of Columbia University School of LawroMioluded system is "collapsing under the weight of its own mrsO~S(` Ac~,,cid:ing[ g, to the Death Penalty Informztlon Center, 69 people haveti~ie~C~}rel'easet~ frciii death rOVv'h i,ii evidences of their innocence frcni, i 970;tcX 1~~~ ; a ~i IocaJ ! es Gatos resident, Buddy Nickerson, was rece';itl~releasedl fr,on~ prison with evidence of innocence. Los Gatos should; torn n Ca- kfornla cities and 4 counties to support the,morato6nml, I uL-l Sily°f Taube Attor-iiey Adtju c' Professcr,Santa •Clara,University School of LLa vj Lus Gatos 0 _ y 4• rikowwatmis 49- Ogg" WORT 4A"Fw)wdmgl M, fm`~r~~~~`~ . I i s ier.els l ~-~-rr rr 13T. ~ Ff g r l Y tl i a q 4 re ~m s a 4 ~ W & a- F' a= AL 6 ti 8 b i 9 4t k ¢ y ^i ~ OF .p 44 a 10 No it e& t] ok s A w lA 13 ~e A' RP 0 I~ iA E 1. T 9 4R ~A d A R. i Ir W b r ® p r ~ a l7 W Zf_ ~ Mo}l x a 9 a m as a A A W b Wr M r. x 10, w IN i w I II~ Q z . SC O U u p IUJ 'Z ~ O 0 ° Y z o. ~1.. ' . z D p ILL m m ~ w ~ C9_ CIS . - z m 1 o' I n L O w o -7) p t c~ C~ M t^ c r c (Y) Q M 0 M 1 1 Q 1 1 i 'C ' co CO C C) co 0 M co M Q c~ - C' co N co N co C~ co N cV M N n r O c''1 M fO r,')- C~ p a Cn Q tC) G3 tt3 O Cn C7 if) Q U') co C) m m 0 C0 itO C~ O •4i> C7 tf) C] to C3 to p O ~ C3 LO © LO 0 U) C C1 r } C C] LO U U) M C to O to ko 1 Ch' Cri Cn C7) M M M (M M 0) 0) C a' CD 0) a) «7 LO 'O3 c~ if? 0) 0) 0) 0) i Q Q < Q Q Q I~ 1 < Q < Q 81 66 Q ' 6- + d Q < I 'Q. 1 C} U U U ~ C), ol lo 0 0 oj u ol 'U U U V 0 C QP 0 0 to 0 U) O' Mn O Ua 0 cn 0 W 0 U) O to O to O U) O Mn O Un O 0 O to O to O 'm O "U) O 0 O 0 O 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 O to 0 0 0 (n 0 N 0 U) O i ~n h ~ m m m m m m m m m m m « i m to m co m m m m m m 'm 0 m m m as m 4-+ .(g U} 0 U) 0 U) 0 U) 0 N 0 Cl) O Mn 01 cn 0 W 0 (n .0 U) O Ch O 0 0 N O U) 0 1 U) 0 N 0 Cl) 0 m 0 to 0 w 0 to 0 v) 0 (n 4 u) 0 u) O to Q V) O VY CQ a "Mn ~Q' _3~ J _J -j 1-1- _1 -w -J. ' ...1 ...3: J __j ._f _1 ~ ,i ,_1 _1 ~ _j I J} ~.of 1 --j WI p d W i 63. > [r- z < w Q Q o a ,Q Q LIJ z < r l ❑ d in } r- V N w IiJ > v ~ I t,- N w IN w Q ~ Q Q O U ~ .g ~ i~ ' U) E rs} rn z J CL LJ (D 2 . :E 0 z z r = ~ 2E 4 t~ g Z z d m x ¢ z W O o ~ ( o ~ ~C v ~ ~ m < ~ z < z o ~ z z w O CI} 0 - u z Q ~ w < m' 2 z d < (J 0 , ~ d w ~ i a t~ CL a. m co w CL m - ' a € ~ t3 ' u) ~ ~ a ' lf) O CQ f3) G 0 I o = O CLJ Cf~ 4) C3 , Q Q ti d? d l _ _ C d I s) r a Ln an 'r1 N CD CO Q s.fT 0 N CV (D a r ua t3) Ir - , m N ) c- d cD C3} t#? tin r C7 N d 00 C ) N (0 ~ CO 'G' c- Co ' (j] Co CO C7 r r c- r r Co lid r O N' O N CD r 1f r LC1 N C) (V r- i[ r III l , O w z m' <t l-" W Z O z z Q , Cl) te w . 0 +ij z Q CL m" LL ILL ~ m z m - F Q F- UJ Y .(I) as 0 2 w 0 4) Z 5 a - Z M ~ X (n < cn 2 r- = 2 ID = 0 Iw _ > < ,w c Y Z. l (9 1 1 Ol (D 0 10 0 (D 1 = T. z Q z z, Z Z LLI _ w o ¢ g o z I 2 w m QQ w m c~ ~ ~ w z - z - n ~ U f fuj > ~ w L < a U N N IZ .L o ~ Q L~ Q U3 o -J z 4 w w ' ~ W ~ - ~ c a C3' (a , Z w -j ~ w W m 2 U AL ~ rQ a1 a i a• w e a ma 0 a r 4M R i k a M. . am .ror LOA ~l m a m u w a x a~ N M q E to F' f' ~ ~l W E b ~ S a ~ ~ v ~i ~i I . I I i 0 uJil ca ~ ' i ll S ra C~ if3' J. ~ Z 4 CO M CO CD m m b p M CD 0 Q ,a ar t~ rn ~ ~ d Q Q ~t ~ ~ Q Q Q Q d ~ U U U 'U 'U U U U U U Ua 0 V3 O UY O cn O ~ 0 ~ 0 rp t] N O cn U u3 O to 0 t!f 0 (i3 lV ES3 tXS R3 ~5 ((5 CB (43 Chi {TS ti'f (D Q (31 (D (D 0 (D Q (D (D !(9 0 0 w 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a 0 o to 0 w 0 w 0 0 0 - ~ - ~ ~ -j -i -j cr- Of <L w w Q c Ia- n C m w II ~ o M p U I C 0 w 0 a a ~ ~ o `ct~ ~ cv rn cQ rr ui W ~ ¢ ~ Z = p Z 11` ~ U m .t Z .f ;Q Z 0 .0 w 0 w Z ,a C~; CD' Q < Z f)~ ~ Z -j ' a~ C W ~ v 1 ..t Z ~ Q U Q CL Q z 1: N a g a h I9 9 I a 71 S 3 + Y T I R 6 ' r m r. 21 4 Y 'i. R '9 4 ~ i r R R ~ 9 d A r{ k d 6 M ~ 6 8 h m y w n ~ m 2 a m a_ p m ~ J q r F d d m• b'. °S Y m m m 0 it w IL I R` I it a w w I. i d a ft A W 4 -1 -6 61% Swd x A W v 1 E mum= x 16 a m~ 0 ~ R a ~ it a ~i y o a a v r a i e: w q a Is A ~a a A