Attachment 05Surrey Fann Estates, LLC
Supplemental Letter of Justification
Surrey Fann Estates PD Subdivision
Supplemental Letter of Justification
Surrey Farm Estates Subdivision (PD) Proposal
170 Twin Oaks Drive & Cerro Vista Court
RE: General Plan Amendment GP-12-001, Williamson Act Contract WA-11 Cancellation,
Planned development Application PD-10-006
Honorable Mayor Rennie and Town Council Members:
This memo provides a summary of our modified site plan in response to comments received from the
Planning Commission on February 28, 2018.
Planning Commission Direction
At the February 28, 2018 Planning Commission Meeting the Planning Commission reviewed both
the Original One-Access plan and the Two-Access plan. The Original single access plan was used to
begin the DEIR studies. Following identification of the environmental issues that would require
mitigation and the discovery that there was a recorded easement for a public roadway from Cerro
Vista Court, we set about developing a plan that resolved favorably, nearly all issues raised.
The Planning Commission voted unanimously to recommend approval with the following direction:
a. Recommend approval of the Alternate Plan (fwo-Access Plan)
b. Reduce the number of lots (possibly eliminate lots 6 & 7)
c. Easement for Public Access to Open Space areas
d. Provide a more legible Tree Disposition Exhibit
e. Look specifically at trees # 18, 62, 302, 303, 336, 33 7, 561 and the stand of trees on lot #7
f. Cut and fill to not exceed current proposal
g . Home sizes to comply with HDS&G
h. Provide specifics of the easement giving access from Cerro Vista Ct.
1. Accommodate fencing for wildlife
How Dodge Family has responded
The Alternate Plan (Two-Access) was produced following identification of the environmental issues
that would require mitigation and the discovery that there was a recorded easement for a public
roadway from Cerro Vista Court. We then set about developing a plan that resolved favorably,
nearly all issues raised in DEJR. This Alternate plan eliminates the need to cross the central habitat
area. Grading quantities related to the addition of a culver crossing are eliminated.
Page I ofJ Surrey Farm Estates-TC Supplcrncnt-3.26 .18.docx Rcv:4.2.18
ATIACHMENTS
As stated in the DEIR, the Alternate Plan is the "Environmentally Superior Plan." Additionally the
Alternate Plan reduces the traffic using Twin Oaks and Longmeado\v Dr. by 40%.
The Dodge Family supports and also recommends the Alternate Plan as this plan allows that all
impacts identified in the DEIR can be and will be mitigated to a less than significant level.
Reduce the number of lots
Following a serious review of the Planning Commission's desire to reduce the number of lots, we
looked at various options. As an environmental consideration we felt that removing the significant
Habitat area from a private lot and instead include the Habitat area into the Open Space ,vould
benefit the community.
Accordingly '\'C have dropped Lot Number 8 and have extended the Open space all the way down to
Street A. Secondly we have reduced the size and modified the upper property line of Lot Number 7
to include the entire upper knoll area into the dedicated Open Space.
\Ve have moved the building site of Lot Number 7 to the lower portion of the parcel. This places the
home below the line of trees, reducing significantly the number of trees remo\-ed along with a
significant reduction in grading for the driveway.
Easement for Public Access to Open Space
Both the Trail and the Open Space will be accessible to the public from the trail. The Open space is a
dedicated area (by a recorded covenant or deed restriction) to ensure that it cannot be built on in the
future.
32% of the 17.55 acres are in the Open Space easement. That is nearly 113rd of the total site as Open
Space
Provide a more legible Tree Disposition Exhibit
See sheets A-1.1 -A-1.4 & A-l.la-A-l.4a. We are also pro,iding 8.5" 11" pages of the arborist
"Tree Disposition Table." We also included the arborist "Tree Comparison Table and Letter."
Look specificall~· at trees #18, 62,302,303,336,337,561 and the stand of trees o~Jot #7
No. Location Removal Re,·ised Health Size
Tree #18: Comer Lot #2 Road grading Transplant Good 20"
Tree #62 Lot #2 near basin Road & basin const. Transplant Good l 8"
Tree #302 Open space Road grading Remove Good 28"
Tree #303 Open space Road grading Remove Good 28"
Trees #302 & 303: Not removed on Alternate Plan (2~access plan) No grading nearby
Tree #336 E.A.R. Emergency road Transplant Fair 23"
Tree #337 E.A.R. Emergency road Transplant Good 25"
Tree #561 Riparian Habitat Not Affected ~ot affected Good 18"
Lot #7 Trees Original plan Home pad See Alternate Plan
Lot #7 Trees Alternate Plan Not removed, unaffected by Alternate Plan
Cut and fill to not exceed current proposa!
Grading necessary to implement the Alternate Plan is reduced significantly from the Original single-
access plan. Cut and fill for Original Site will not be increased.
Page 2 of 3 Surrey Fann Estates-TC Supplement-3.26.18.docx Rev: 4.2.18
Home sizes to comply with HDS&G
Homes for both the Original 10 lot site and the revised 9-lot site will be in compliance with the
HDS&G. See the data tables on the Cover sheet (CS)
Provide specifics of the easement giving access from Cerro Vista Ct.
See attached Exhibits: Road Easement, recorded April 4, 1973 and Preliminary Title Report color
site illustrating the easement location.
Accommodate fencing for wildlife
At this point the Town is in the midst of developing Wildlife Fencing Guidelines. The Dodge Family
are quite willing to work with the Town Staffto develop a list of fencing conditions that can be
utilized as a part of the development.
Request for Approval
The above response by the Dodge Family demonstrates that we have carefully listened to the
Planning Commission's comments. Clearly the Alternate Site Plan is the "Environmentally
Superior" Plan.
Now, with both the elimination of one building site and including the Habitat Area in the Dedicated
Open Space the Alternate Site is even more environmentally sensitive to this 17.55-acre site. Nearly
113rd of this site will be in Permanently Dedicated Open Space.
We respectfully request your approval of this revised Alternate Plan.
Sincerely,
Rodger Griffin, F AIBD
Paragon Design Group, Inc.
Page 3 of3 Surrey Fann Estates-TC Supplement-3.26.18 .docx Rev: 4.2.18
This Page
Intentionally
Left Blank
ANDJtEW L. PABllll
RAL>H J. SWANSON
PEGGY L. SPRJNGGA Y
JOSBPH E. DW<aAK
SAMUSLL PAU
ALAN J. PDINIII.
LINDA A. CALLON
JAMBS P. CMIHMAN
STBVBN J. CASAD
NANCY J. JmtNSOM
JBllOLD A. llJTON
kOBER.T L. CBOa'l13K
JONA'JHAND. WOU'
ltATHLBBNlt. llPLB
RETIRED
SAMUBL J. COHIIN
llOBl!R.T W. HUMPHREYS
BUGHLISOlA
Rob Schultz
KBV!NP. XELLBY
MARK MAKtEWICZ
ROBE&TA S. HAYASHI
JEFFRBY S. XAUFMAM
JClUB HOUSTON
DIAN L SHB11Jlll
JOHN P. DOMINOUll
HAUY A. LOPEZ
awuJ!S w. VOU'B
MICHAEL VIOLAJffl
awsTINE H LONO
AA&ON M. VALENTJ
aaJmAN B. PIOOMS
Town Attorney
Town of Los Gatos
110 E. Main Street
Los Gatos, CA 95030
BERi.INER CO 11 EN
A 1 l ~: 1 U U [ i' ~ '1. T 1 ~·· ',',
•
TEN ALMADEN BOULEV.ARD
ELEVBNTH-.PLOOR
SAN ~OSB, CALJFORNIA 9S11l-2233
TELEPHONE: (408) 286-5800
FACSI~: (408) 998-5388
www.lJcrtiner.com
a.....om-
Mon:ojl; CA • Mlllluhr, CA
June 5, 2014
THOMAS P. MURPHY
THOMAS D. MOIU!LL
Sli'IH J. COHEN
LAURA PAUZZOLO
KAaA L. AaGUBLLO
ANIJRBW'J. orounA1'INI
l!DALINA M. Ml!NDONCA
DAWNC.SWBA1T
ICATHLEBNP. SHERMAN.
SAMD1tA G. SEl'ULVl!DA
OP COUNSEL
·SANPOlU'.l A Bl!IWNl!ll
S'DIVENL HALLOBMSON
!'LU& IL UBHAUI
DICWONO
NANCY L. HANDT
1HOMAS ARMSTllOMG
Re: Surrey Fann Estates -170 Twin Oaks Drive. Los Gatos, California
Dear Mr. Schultz:
MASON L BRAWLEY .
JENNIP'Ell Y. LEUNG
MAZAIUM A. VAXHAJUA
TYUill A. SHliWEY
VIVIAN7. WANG
H. SKINlfY LIU
SARA L . N)LL()CK
Bl!AU C. (XlUElA
MAllY E. LOUDBN
STl!l'Hl!N C. SCOltDEUS
JUDY A. JBNSEN
DOIUS A &:AJ!lJN
SUSAN B. BmtOP
LBSLm XALIMMcllUCJH AN1'H<»l1 D. JOHNSTON
As you are aware, we represent Surrey Farm Estates. As part of the Surrey Fann Estates
. project application 1 currently pending before the Town of Los Gatos (''Town''), we are requesting
that the Town accept an easement for roadway purposes that was dedicated to the Town in 1973.
This roadway easement, if accepted by the Town, will provide for additional access to and from the
Project site and will directly benefit the entire neighborhood.
History of the Road Dedication
In March 1973 Irving Yabroff, William Yabroff, and Ester Lou Yabroff dedicated to the
Town property to be used for a public thoroughfare and to become a portion of the public street
system in the Town. This dedication was made with the understanding that it may be rejected
initially, and at the option of the Town, subject to 1he Town's right of acceptance at any time in the
futme. Pursuant to Town Resolution No. 1973-41, dated April 2, 1973, the Town consented to the
recordation of the dedication. The Town further rejected the offer of dedication, but reserved its
right to accept the dedication at any time in the future ("Road Dedication"). See attached
1 General Plan Amendment. Rezoning, Tentative Map, Williamson Act caocellation ("Project").
4829-2840-4763v2
JH\19628001
Rob Schultz
June 5, 2014
documents: Dedication dated March 29, 1973, Book 0311, pages 3 81 ~ 383, recorded with the Santa
Clara County Recorder's Office on April 4, 1973, Resolution No. 1972-41, Book 0311, Page 384,
also recorded on April 4, 1973 and Map of Tract No. 7613.
Subsequent to the Road Dedication, Map ofTract No. 7613 ("Tract Map 7613'') was filed in
the Santa Clara County Recorder's Office on August 26, 1986, Book 564, Pages 7, 8, 9 and 10.
Tract Map 7613 subdivided the lands known as the Cerro Vista subdivision. As part of the Cerro
Vista subdivision, Lot 10 was created and was subject to the previously recorded Road Dedication.
Current title to Lot 10 of the Cerro Vista subdivision is vested in Carol Hing Hoeppner, located at
15955 Sierra Vista Court, Los Gatos. See attached map of Lot 10 depicting the Road Dedication and
other easements, which was taken from a recent Chicago Title Company Preliminary Title Report,
dated May 12, 2014.
California Map Act
The Town may now accept the previously rejected offer of dedication for the benefit of the
future Surrey Farm Estate subdivision. Pursuant to the Map Act, at the time the Town Council
approves a final map, it shall also accept, except subject to improvement, or reject any offer of
dedication. See Govt. Code§ 66477.l(a). In addition, any suchofferofdedicationshallremainopen
and the Town Council may by resolution at any later date, and without further action by the
subdivider, rescind its action and accept and open the streets, which directly benefit the residents of a
subdivision, which acceptance shall be recorded in the Office of the County Recorder. See Govt.
Code§ 66477.2.
Benefits of Accepting the Road Dedication
At the recent neighborhood meetings held for the proposed Project, neighbors expressed
concerns over traffic using only one point of access. The neighbors requested that the Project
applicants look for access alternatives to serve the Project. The acceptance of the Road Dedication
will help alleviate the concerns of the neighbors by providing additional access to and from the
subdivision. This additional access will directly benefit the residents of the future Surrey Farm
Estates subdivision, as well as the current neighbors surrounding it. In addition, it is anticipated that
this Road Dedication will accommodate the extension of, and the connection to, the existing Hillside
Pedestrian/Equestrian Trail.
Thank you for your time and consideration of our request.
4829~763v2
JH\19628001
Very truly yours,
BERLINER COHEN
JOLIE HOUSTON
E-Mail: jolie.houston@berliner.com
-2-
Rob Schultz
June 5, 2014
JH:cem
Enclosures
cc: Surrey Farm Estates
Greg Larson, Town Manager
Laurel Prevetti, Town Community Development Director
Matt Morley, Town Parks & Public Works Director
4ll29-284047S3v2
JH\19628001 -3-
This Page
Intentionally
Left Blank
.,·
.,
•
I.
..,._ •• I
•!' • · .. :~· ••• . ~·~ ··.•
• •, •· .. ! ...... . ··~ ... ~?: .. -· ·-....... .w,,·.· . ~ ... .;., .. :
t ";•. • . ti-.. _
.J ..
IIECORO ~ IIETURH TO: TGIIII CU:RK , P O IDX 9'19 , LOS GATOS, CA. 9S030
,,,..,.,,, 11110011 I.IQ 381
NOTAXOOi:
lawful purpose• fvN!vu,,
Ula ~ert:y so dedio11ted to be a pahJJc t:horov.pfua ~
to becOlll8 a pa&'t::lan of tha J)Qhl.:lc atreet: ayat:ai in the Town of
Loll Get:ot, County of Sant:-11 m.ai.. St:at. of cal.:lfom:la,
!hie dedication ie lllilde lf:lth the urulentand:1.ng that it lllilY
be rejected 1n:ltially, at: the option of t1la 1'Q,n of Loe Gatos,
eul>ject to tbe Yam's l"ight of acoaptanca at -. t:ilna in t118
future.
1'ha .follalr.lng :ls II dasCripl:ion of t>Mt X'Nl. ~arty ao
dedicated:
, •
" .. ,, .. . .. ,, ., ...... '°:···· ~ "·
..
'
j
•.• .J • . , .. ,.
BXHJBU' "A"
·:.·_ . ..;. ... _ ........ "' __
3528-2
.3/27/73
DAD
:i:ev. 3/29/73
ROADWAY KASB14BNT OVBR :r.MIDS 011' YABROl'F '1'0 8B CONVBYBD
TO !l'HB TOlfll 01" LOS GA'l'OS
All t:llat certain ~al p:n,party situ.ta in the 'l'OWn of Los Gat:os, County of
Santa Clara, State of California, baintJ an eaa1H11Bnt for roatlway purpoaea
and the installation and ~aintenanae of public utilitias deaaribecl &15
followa:
BJ!GTIIRDIG at an angle point: in the westerly boundaey of that certain -n4ed
paroel. map f1.le4 for record 1.n Book 21.4 of Maps at: p&90 37, Santa Clara
County Racords, aaid poi.nt: al.8o beitu; the 1.nt:araaction of said -t:arlY
boundary with the nort:hwaaterly proJ.ongatian of the southweete:d:y bow,daey
of P1u:-ael ':L'Wo u ahoWn on said Amended Parcel Map; t:henae leav1119 said .
POINT OF BBGilll!IIIIG along the aoat:herly prol.Ongat:ion of aaid westerly line
south &•53 1 00-Meat: 1',3!1 feat, t:henaa leaving aaid aoutberly p:r6lungat1on
from a tanvent beuing of l!Ortll 55•34•03• w-t ai.ong a c;mi:w ta t:be rf.vht
with a radius of 40,00 feet th%ough a central angle of 2•37'52" for an arc
l&119th of 1, 84 feet to a Point of Ravuaa Cllrvature, t:hanae from a tangent
bau":lng of North s2•5&'ll" West-a1ong I!' cw:va to t:ha left: with a radius~
:zo.oo feet through a aantrll angle of &1•1a•2e• for an arc, length of :Zl,50
feet to a Polnt of aeverae eui:v.turat t:hanoe fr11111 • tangent bearing of South
59•45•2111 Weat. al0119 a 01Jrve to the right with a ra41ua of 500,00 f-t through
a central angle of 14•3e•2g• for an~ 1angth of J.'2.7.77 feet to a Point of
aeverae curvature, t:hanae from a tangent bearing of Soatli 74•23•50• Heat
al0ft9 a carve to tha left. with a radius of 20,00 feet: through a oent.ral anvle of 13l908'00" for an arc length of 47,87 f-t: to a point of ·caap on
the southerly line of tbe parcel. of land 4eac.ribad u ·Paroel Ho. 1 in tbe
l)ee4 to the ChU.c!ran'a Cowlts:y School, a Corporat:!.on, reoorded. January 31, 19"6
in Sook 1331 of Official Reaord9 at pa9e 5B, Beta Clara county lleoords1
tbanca al.ong said $0Utherly 11-ll'ort:11 79•3&•10• Wast 157,97 feet, thence
leaving said southerly line •lon<J a tangent: curve to the ri.ght: with a radlua
of 340.00 feet through a central angle of 6·00 1 00• for an ara length of
35,60 feet to a Point: of ColllpDlmd CUr1rat11re1 thenae f-a t.angent baadng
of Horth 72°36'10• West along a curve to 1:ha rlvbt with a ralliwi of 80,00
feet: t:hrough a oanti:al angle of e2•41•so• for an arc length of 115,63 feet:,
thence Jrorth 10•12'4D" Beat 27,08 feetr thence along-a tangent. curve to the
left with a radius of 40,00 feet t~h a central angle of 41•24•35• for
an arc J.engt:h of 28.91 feat: to a Point of :a.versa curvature, thence f:co111 a
tan99Rt. bearing of lllOJCt:h 31 •11 • 55• Wast al.Oft9 a cur,ra to the ri9)1t with a
ra4ias of 40,00 feat through a oentral angle of 2&2•49•10• fOr an arc length
of 183.48 feet to• POint lllf"RaVerae CUrvat11re1 thence .from a tangent bearing
of SOUt:h 51°37'15" weat along a ourve to the left with a racUua of 40,00
fe1tt: through a cents:al angle of 41°24'35• for an arc length of :JB.91 feat,
thence south 10~12•40• Wc,at 27.08 feat, thence along a tagc,nt carve t:o the
oontinued
···· .. -. ··-
·-. • " / -,.,.
" -• ' •
~
·•· , .~ •
' .... .,,.
!
•••.;w
I_
•
Ii"· ..... .=· •
. . ":. ::.: ~
.... ·-···-· ··-· .. .-.... -............ _. ··--·-· ·······---·-·-·····. ~.,.:
Bxhibit: •A• -JlolufW!I BaallallaDt.,,,
page £wo 3528-.Z
DiU)
l.ef"t with a r&tiw. of" co.oo l!'aet. ~ a oenulll. angla of a.z•c,•so• tor
an arc leDVtb of 57. 82 r.et to a Point. of CompOllhil C1J1Vatue1 t:helloe b11111
a tangen~ be~!ng of Boath 72•3&'1t• ... t: along a carve to the 1.rt. with
a ra41ua of 300,00 f .. t. t:hrollg'h a cantral angle of 33"00'00" for an arc
length of 172.79 feet tu a Point of _Clapound curvature, ~ca fE0111 a t11119ent.
hearing of 1'ortl1 74"23'50• But: alOh!J a cu~ to t:ha le.ft with a radius of
f&0,00 f-t. through a central angle of 1'"38'29" for an arc length of 117.55
feat.1 thenoe Nortb 59"45'.21" But 50.11 feet , thance along a tangent. ouxve
to t:he J.ert. with a ra4:l.1111 of 20.00 f-t. through a aeni:J:al. angla of s2•s2•21•
for ;an 11ra lenvth of 11, H feet: to • point on aaid waaterly bOUIIC1uy, t:henc:a
al.0119 11aid Wt1at.:1y·bounllary 8outh &"53 100" WHt 51,2C feet to f:ha POilllT OF BIIG.IIHIING,
prepare.! by the f:I.J:111 of
NACXAY • 80Nl'S
• •
Santa CJ.are
•
-' -
·•
f
I
l r
'
:
i
I
j.
, . , •
l •, .. t :.o1
I;. ,j
..
~· ... .., . .. ~
RBSOLU'tl> N NO. J97l•'tJ
I1£sar.un0R CllN&Blff.UIG 70 RIICDRDUXON
OF lllSfllJte)lT COII\IEYlllG XND11ES! 11/1
RIAL PIIOl'Ell'l'Y' •
Rli80U1BD, the TClWn of LOIi Gatoe c~nn to l'Rctlrdatiaa of
the atbc:lllld :lnat:ruinmt or ded:loattGn, •• provlda4 by GIIYl!l'rllll!nt
Colla ftotion 27281.
Flll1'HBR IESOLIIBD • that 1'le rown or Loa Gates l'&jaota the
ott'er al! decll.oation ev:lc!enced by ttia 1naU"tmant, nel'ViJ111 its
ript to IUlcept the l'ladioation at any ti119 :ln ·the rutm..
PASSBD Mil> ADOPJED at • __ __,rss-v~J .. •,.r _____ neattng_ of
the Town C01111cU of the Town of Loa Gllt:0 11 haM on the ..l!!!!...
day of _._.;.;A;r;.P;..t'l;..lc-_____ , 1 973, lly the fall o,,!113 Yot2 :
AYES: COUJICILHBN --~~~h•~c~l~11 .... E~,._.Psf'"""Cll,...f~tas,.... ____ _
Mllcls I, Pfftuca
Esoa Jcn,an
Jebo 8, I PGbntc
Buth Conpgn
IIOEB: C0Ut.1:I£~l£N __ .,.l(o,..na,.,._ _________ _
SIGNED: NAYOJt OP Tit! !OWN OP LOS GATOS
A!!'SST:
cu~· ,~~~ftos o~TOs
•
DATED .•• 1 .
" .'" ~· ..... · ... 1: ,~ . .Ir'" ....... ~.-· . "\ ~, , ..... ..
I •
, .
J . ,: • : ~l· ,.,. ..
,..
I
0 1 2
standard Scala 1 :1
'-·
. . .
-.t~ --
Legend
D Property In Question -Fee
Item No . 4 -Easement for Roadway
In 04/04/1973 Bk311 Pg381 of Official Records
Affects said portion as described in the document
Item No. 5 -Easement for Public Utillty
In Bk564 Pg7 ofTract Map
Affects said portion as shown on map
Item No. 5 -Easement for Pedestrian/Equestrian Trail
In Bk564 Pg7 of Tract Map
Affects said portion as shown on map
~ ~ --./
/
"'O I
g k-~ ; i
/~I§,~
~ i ..... / .... ....,,
'" ... J,_.-I ' ... ~
, ... 0 'i~-.. :--\ ·~ . ..._ I B co I 'to:.ti' -...
I a,"'O t l
I >-I 1
1 00 I n Z · o I
• I • I l:~r M,• L..... I !, o~, l'8 > 61,• -I , t) 'P.
I ~
CO I I
I
I
I .
~~ . . .
;1'
N
I
'"'
-:..,
0
~
02014 Tille Onler ND. : FWPS-29811140618, Prelon!oay Report dahtd May 12, 21114 Dn>wlng Dala : 05117/2014 • FNFI
Chicago Title Company
87S N. Fhl 81n1a1. 81dle 4DO
San Jou, CA 85112
Rararen .. : "'°'MOr'I P...., No, : 537-30,010
Properly : 15955 Cem, Ville Cl, Los Galoe, CA95032
Pllll Showing : LOTS 10 Ni SHOWN ON lHAT CERTAIN MN' ENnllED, "TRIU:T NO. 7613", WHICH MAP WAS FILED INTHE OFFICE OF
TliE RECORDER Of THE COUNTY Of SANTA CLARA, STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN AUGUST 26, 1986 IN BOOIC 5M OF MAPS, AT PAGES Sl'eel
7. 8 , 9AND 10. 1 of 1
,..,._ ... ,
This Page
Intentionally
Left Blank
--"" ~ ~~!:~:~ !::~!t
(~,-...~~ (831) 594-5151
)
'-'....) 7327 Langley Canyon Road
Prunedale, California 93907 ..A.....~~-
A Comparison Between A Single Access Entry Road Plan and
A Two Access Entry Road Plan
Surrey Fann Estates
Los Gatos, California
Assignment
I was asked to prepare a comparison chart showing the impacts to the existing trees
between the two plans:
Plan A-1 -To Construct a Single Access Road to the Site, and
Plan A-IA-To Construct Two Access Roads to the Site
Observations
Previously this was attempted with two spreadsheet charts, but these were long,
consisting of multiple pages, and difficult to compare in such a format.
After attempting to achieve this task again, I find that these charts, when viewed side by
side, are near identical, which few differences between the other. In order to make the
chart more manageable I have revised the chart omitting all of the trees (as requested)
that would not be expected to be impacted by the construction proposed by these two
plans. This Chart is attached.
Thus, instead of preparing two near identical charts, I have included in this report a single
Chart listing the impacts to both plans, but those trees impacted by the Alternate Access
Road off Cerro Vista Court are noted as "Alternate Access".
Also, I shall list the differences between the Two Plans with regard to the impacts to
individual trees later in this report.
First, it appears useful to identify the scope of this comparison and the similarities
between the two Plans. The Civil Plans C2 and C8 indicate that the grading for the
roadway, regardless of the plan proposed, and the grading for the retention ponds would
be done at the same time. The grading for the retention ponds are identical on both of the
two plans. Thus, the impacts to the trees, as a result of grading for the retention ponds, is
identical between the two plans. Also, the grading for the driveway to Lot 7 and the
grading for building pad for Lot 7 is shown on both plans as identical. Thus, the impacts
to the trees as a result of this feature are also identical. The entry Roadway from Twin
Oaks Drive, titled Street A to the bulb tum-around is identical. The proposed Storm Drain
construction between the two plans appears identical. All of these features, which appear
to be identical between the two plans, create the long list of impacts to trees listed in the
attached chart. The differences between the two plans are as follows.
,
Los Gatos, CA
Comparison I
Plan A-1 provides the access to Lots 5, 6, 7, and 10 by proposed Street B, which would
cross the swale between Trees# 550 and the cluster of Trees# 545,546, 162 and 544.
Retaining walls and a drainage pipe would be constructed. By this plan Trees# 545, 546,
and 162 would not live very long (5-10 years estimated) as a result of this construction.
Tree# 550 and the trees near it (north of the swale fill area) should survive in good
condition. Tree #544 and the trees south of the swale area should survive in good
condition.
As the Access Roads proposed by the two plans do not connect, the Alternate Access
Road Plan A-lA would not impact the trees in the swale area (Trees #545, 546, 162,
544).
Comparison 2
Plan A-1 would provide a "Hammer Head" turn around at the end of Street B. No Trees
would be removed, but Tree # 160 would be Transplanted.
To the same geographical area of the site, Plan A-lA proposes instead an Alternate
Access Road off Cerro Vista Court. Trees# 160, 163, 164, 165 are proposed to be
Transplanted.
The proposed Alternative Access road would significantly impact Trees # 161 ( 56 inch
diameter Valley Oak) and Tree# 383 (49 inch diameter Valley Oak). An estimated 30%
of the root zone of Tree 161 would be damaged by fill and retaining wall construction,
but Tree# 161 would be expected to survive with regular irrigation for 3 years. An
estimated 20% of the root zone of Tree# 383 would be damaged by the road
construction, including the construction of the proposed retaining walls. It is expected to
survive this road construction, but the impact to Tree# 383 would not be limited to the
road construction. The proposed new residence on Lot 6 would adversely impact the root
system of Tree# 383 by an estimated 10% -15%. Also, the impacts of the landscape
amenities upon Tree # 383 cannot be assessed at this time, but these impacts (road,
residence, landscape) must not be considered separate and independent but must be
considered collectively.
Tree # 154 would be severely damaged and, thus, required to be removed resulting from
the Storm Drain Construction. It appears that Trees# 152, 153 and 155 would survive.
This feature is the same for both plans proposed.
.
Los Gatos, CA
Tree# 592 (32 irich diameter Coast live oak) would suffer relatively minor root damage
as a result of grading for the retention pond. This feature is the same for both plans.
Tree # 593 (10 inch diameter Coast live oak) would suffer relatively minor root damage
from Storm Drain Construction. This estimate is based on the trunk diameter, which
provides an estimate of the size of the root mass. This feature is the same for both plans.
Respectfully submitted,
Michael L . Bench, Consulting Arborist
International Society of Arboriculture Certification # WE 1897 A
American Society of Consulting Arborists Member
This Page
Intentionally
Left Blank
'Field alli ~ ' ~.. .. . ~ ". . ·, · ' ...
TreeN1111e DBH DBH DBH Hght Spnl fflth Stre CD/18 Tppd
1 Coast live oak
Quercus agnfolia
Coast live oak -
II 15 20 3 2
' 7
8
' 110
il
i2
Valley oak
Qucrcus lobala
Coast livo oak
incense cedar
Calocedrus decurrens
·coast live oak
Incense cedar
Cout·llvc oak
Coast live oak
Com£iive oak
coast t1veoat·
Coast live oak -
CA black walnut
Juglans hindsii
j 1, Aleppo pine
1Pinus halepensis
English Walnut
I
115
' -~ugJ~~
16 ,Aleppo pine
17 viiitey 0°ak:
18 Coastlive ·oa1c
i, Coast Hvc oai: -
20 .Coast live oak
21 Coastiiveoak
22 ·c'aiifomia bldeye
Acsculus califomica
23 Coast live oak
·u :Coast live oak
25 coast ilve oaii:
26
121
121
12'
130
Coast live oak
Coast live oak
Coast live oak
valley oak
1
31
32 ·European olive
Olea europea
j ;u vaney-oak· -
f34
I
135 1:
)38
' 39
40
\41
1,2
I~
i i46
!,1
;
Valley oak
vaifeyoak
Vaileyoak
Coast live oak
Val ley oak
vaiteyoak
Val ley oak
Valley oak
Valley oak
Coast iive oak
Coast live oaic
Val ley oak
Coast live oak
:6
is
,9
5
4
,9
i
7
:s
·'7 ·
;1T·
'if
!5
! ..
If
'fi !
17
;io
·s
122
I 'i o
.,.
!if ' 'iT
!fo
16
110
14
ii9 .. ,., ..
14
12
17
:i6
8
;1s
25
!iS
II
·6
12
'1
8
16
11
DBH -Diam_. Breast Height
Hght -Height
Sprd -Canopy Spread
Hltll -Health
!3
i
:,s
10
;25
115
1is
)ti
-;20
' ~is-
20
ii5 ,2 I
30 l ·1
,rs n 3
I i
10 -2
11
3
.j"
)
Ii
.I ,.
I
Y 1x·
3 X
·1 i .
, ..
1·rs ·--~;1·
L-.. i
35 'i'"
,3
',r
ps r 14
70 'i 2
;x
I
·35 !f Tl l:X
1 .. -... .! .... I ts 2 4
f45 ~f o li" ~3-
35 \o 'r --4
120
I .. 20··
'f36
'20"
,[5
20
)o··
·2.s
;js
).0
"'.20 ;
'45
·35
20
30
'25
'50
60
-25
40
-20
45
10
· is
45
20
120 ii :2
'"1s"·--y· 2 .
-i Jo 1r ·r ·-rx-
20 1f' .... 4 _I X .
l'B" 11 ::.r -pc
:4 ·x 1s·
p
t
lJ
i -
2
j
4
;j
2
X
;-j o.. ;2 3
20 3 4 X
'15 2 3
I is 2 3
i is ·,3 · i
is I 2
/30 ;2
20 1 4 X
Strc -strudllre
CD/18 -CO-Dominant stems w/ lmbedded Bat1<
Tppd -Topped
CBL? -Gables Recx>mmended
3 3 D isc ing of the root zone:
·. 3 :2 biscmg oftlie root zone
Moderate ly Sparse Canopy
:Primary leaders
1/D -Insects or Disease
RC -Root Collar Covered
H20 -Needs water
[48
!49
(50 ; Aleppo pine
L
i 51 Valley oak
f5i
I 53 Valiev oaF --
!s.; .coasiT1veoak· i·· i .. 1!5 j1~--... 12 ·1 · i~s 'coastifveoa1c · J i · 120 :is !1 12· · l· i:~ '~!:!:!:-..t!s _· J "'' ~:: ):--··_:f~-t-·r
.Coast live oak
I • I I ~ ( iss :Coast live oak f"ii ..... i' .. ii/f ". Tis . ··11 · ·14 ··J ...
f59 Coast live oak .. ··!6-. ·;· tis . ·hs. ·-!r · l,r .j
fciO !Coastlh·eoak ···_.13 :·· i . j -~O .. pr "j f ·ir ·t
l.. _t.
i
I
I
l
i
I ... -·t
--, ·-... L L \
I
I j 'l" --..... ·t ··-·
! .. .L i
"1"" ..
I
!
.. !-
;, ..
I_
t,1 'coiistHveoaf :s I y20 11s :1 ;3
1
1
,
63
2 lcoast1ive-oak' _-,.-_
1
i~
5
~ .. ys_ .. J _ _ 12~ _to: E _j.3 :_p< l '/ ,
coiistH~eoiik · L • • 12s !30 .1 _ i3 ·; .. ·· ·i
-: --··).
I •
l :
I lu !Coastliveoalc ·rs'.. ·r f --!zo . ·i 1s · ·11 ·1i· 'I ...... t f _j__ l"
l---!LC
I 1u:
·itc
!6s '.coastliveoak ··for ·:· ·:·· -1l1s -her · :i-i 4 \,c ··f ·
~'' tva11eroai"·· ····· : :~j!~--~~~t .· -~[-... _.l~:.· ..f:~--· I ~--J:.1·:~ .. T.:· _·_·:t ·.· :.t. ·J .. , ... · __ [_· __ · .. -· · · ..
[67 :coastliveoak · :12 ! , i30 j30 !1 J 2 j , I i -, ,
f,s I Valley oak ·19 --· . T ... r ....... tjs . ·125 · .. ri J3 .... !.. . . ..... ·r ...... +· ··1_! _ 1 I
t,9 ·coasthveoak ·:i2 · ·--; I -· t40 · · )o h · 12 ; ·· ·. "f. .... 1 ; I 1 ..
i;: '~~: .. : 1:. l -1 11;1!'----il ;:-j; l l r -I . r Tl ·· ! . fn JAfcppopine-· -"TIT 'T -. ~. · 1i.s'"··-is"" ·r .. j4 -T .. ·rx ... T' . ·1 ·ttc
t73 :Coast live oak .. ·-;io ··t . --[ · ·)2s··· ·:20· Ir· ··1}-.I .... -~ .. ·+ ! .... J L .
1:: :~=:-:!::~ ~-· ---_--·J :1~-· --·,,-~-·: -.-.1_-· --~--~-K~-~-·;~:~. -r~--l ~ .. :-~:--~:I . -~-r -.. i: . ..t ·) .--·:--r .. ·._: ~ ... · ·
• r • 1 : • : 1 1 i t1, ;coast live oak :1 . T" ... ·r .... ·12s-.. TH-. C .. t3" 1 .. --j ' -·1 · ·--T . t -... . . ("' .·
111 ;vaiieyoaic l2I .. ·j . ·1 iso .. :so !1 .. :3 -;--: ·. · : · .1 ·! ! ·
i_1s :vwteyoak ·-[2_1_ .. t j--.. ·t~: j~o_: ji · :·1!~·J _· .. J j -.j ..... ::J.:::
j79 :Caiifumiasycamore )41 1 '.50 J3S ; 1 j4 :X i ·1 I
! Platan~ racemosa . . ! . ! I r . l . . L
[SD ;California sycamore j~~~-.-.L .. .r ·· _1 6~--~~i~.-:.]~ · __ f ]. ·.· ... -T · .. ::J _: I ... i.
181 :eatifomia sycamore 137 i · !' /40 !30 ;l j 3 1 ; ~
In ;Californiasycamore '"j4f " -1 ··· r ·iJo· rjo-.. jf "P" ·1 ' ··1 . "!"
!83 . ;A1eppoj,ine .. ['1 . ' ·, j1s ps · ,i )i , . -·r · · J
t' 1c!!moast'dt,:l:·v;e·:;~-~-~-.t ... ·1s -f r~.-J~_o_· .. t ... :t.J___ ·· .. -r .
!85 ...,.,. i46 !'35 ,so '1 13 . : X ' i '
Is, :Ateppopine ·116 .. i . ~---j:-· F""!~--t "f'" !" ·--r--i ·
is, ·'>.feppoJime ;1s : ; · 140 hs · :4 ji · ; · 1 1..
):·:,~.,. !~, l L i~!;:lli j j i
t :::: t i t r I :);;-_,, r i" i t
!92 ;Va1feyoaic'--. ·1 ,;-,-.. t ~ff ·--·fff~ /s-· -·r.r .. )" t--.. 'l' .... ;
1,3 Aleppopine ·13 I . .. ']B ... \25 · :s --;r .'. .. ix . I
!94 Co asi i,veoak ·•3 r ]30 · r20 ·· ji--· ·j2 ·. [! I L t I I 195 Coast live oak ;6 JS (io · · /2
i96 Coast live oak i,, I Coast iive· oak
25
I
:20
it
:2
;3
' i4
·rx
Strc • Strudure
i
!..
·r ..
I
·!
I -i
CSH -Diameter ereast Height
Hght • Height
Spro -C..nopy S pread
Hlth -Healt!I
CO/lB -Co-D;,mlnant stems 1\/ lmbetlded B<lri<
Tppd • T;,pped
CBL? -Cables Recommended
.. T ...
,), .. _,.. -~-· ....
I I
.i .. ·(
i r
•:•.
I '··. i
. J ... ·--........... ..
; In Upper Canopy
]~~~.
/LC
. l · -l~c ., .
I M'alor Tnmk DCC&}'
l
T t '. --·· -
'
:WRustGall
I
I/0 -Insects or Disease
RC -Root Collar covered
H20 • Needs Water
Tree Name DBH DBH DBB Hght Sprd mt11 Stn: CD/IB ' Tppd Cbl? VD RC mo otu
Valleyoak -25 --·--·-· ·3:S -1·, ... ~y· ··1·U~~Yl.;;'I. ::i "'l,l\:.,"'tl'-., .. '-'-'1 ,it1.1'n,U '"nlU 'jl.ali,·}-·-·-98 ' . f I i r
'· 99 Vahey oak 10 35' 30 2 2
100 Coast live oak ·10 j 5 J.20 !i )'
! ' 101 Coast l1ve oak ;13 35 30 l 4' x
102 .Coast live ou /7 .. !3°5 ;20 ·: 1 .3
I ,. -
103 Coast live oak 15 '.35-30
104 Coast live oak /8 jt5 ,35 1 j ;Horizorital siiuctuie
~
105 va11ev oak: 7 '35 15 1 3
1116 coast five .oak 122 :·.{o :40 ·, 1 :.f
I .... L .
107 Valle\' oak 6
..
25 15 2 :4 jf ·tc·
' 108 . Coast live oak 12.°J"· I "i4(f. '}i<>' ;r 'i
I ' 1109 Coastliveou 1f ~-is · -3°il° ·1
110 •Wild plum· i6·-;Io po· ·ts -i4
..
.Prunus cerasima I I ; I I
1111 coast Hve oaf 29 40 ,5() · 1 3
112 Blue oak ;i 4 -]35 1-. ii :1 135 ; I l. ' -•---'i ill Coast live oak 1•f" ·30. 30 1
114 i Va1ie'y oak ·1 11 j2S P: ·1r :4 !LC I.. l
its vailey oak· -7 ~is 20 ·'2· .3
n, ;Coast flvc oaic ,s .. i. :is ·12 .. 2 !20
! ..... I I
i17 coast hve oai: 17 :40 30 1 '2.
i18 . coiist Jive o«ic H S ·140 j2S IC 12
.I .
it9 ·va11ey oak 13 2S ·2s t ·!4
120 ·• coast live iiak. :18 ·;40 ]30 )i •j
,.
vaitC} oak io !_ \s"· .i ·r 121 40
122 · Coast live oak ')14 ·ao ;Ton -"]40 -135 ,T :.r 1x · : L . ! I 123 coast live ou: 12
124 coast tive oak l j4 ,·40 130 (3-.2 l. ... I !. ..
125 coast five oaf 10 =jo 2S "i .3
126 coasdive iiak !IK ;25 !40 ·.-1 ·4 iX i r \
140
j -I
117 Coast liveoak 13 2S l 3
128 c oast ffve oiik . i'l9 .. ;40 1 40 -; 1 .. •4 ix
' I ; ;
129 coast Hve oaic IS 40
0
30 ·1 2
130 Coastfi'-ve oak-'20 '40-jl )
ill coast hve oa1.:· 'f
,J __ • 25 IS '. l 2
132 Viilteyoak ;2i (ts :45 11
!
Valley oak
l jo .20 j ,133 7 1
1134 Valley oak ;39 sb :10 1 2
I ' rus Coast live Olk: 8 )o 20 1 .2
[illi Valieyoak )7 -;B 15 : i 1 ! ' I
137 Coast live oak 5 5 3 15 10 s 4 lierblcide ciamage?
I Coast live oak ,i :X 1131 ,10 :20 j20 4
ru, \ ·-2 Coast live oak 8 20 IS 1
!140 Coast Hve oak 18 20 :25 '1 4 (x i. IHI European olive 21 IS 25
1142 Wild.Plum ,5 : rn }O ;4 '3
I I
1143 Wild Pium 6 lo 10 4 '3
!144 European oiive : il :5 :S fil :20 1
1145 Aleppo pine 12 '20 15 4 X
!1~ Aleppo pine ·JI 20 20 1 j ,x
j.., ' Aleppo pine 11 30 20 1 3 x
I
DBH -Diameter Breast Height Sire -Structure
Hght -Height CD/18 -Co-Dominant Slams w/ lmbedded Barf< 1/D -Insects or Disease
Sprd -canopy Spread Tppd -Topped RC -Root Co llar Co"'!red
Hlth -Healttl CBL 7 -Cables Recommended H20 -Needs Water
e ailile
li48 Aleppop~
I
1·149. ;Aleppo pine
hso .Aleppo pine
r 1Sl . Afcppo-p1ric " .
j 1S2 ·; Aleppo pine
\IS3 1Aleppo pine -
l 1S4 ; Aieppo"j,ine
! 155 : Aleppo pme . ! 156 ; Aleppo pine
J' 151 Incense cedat .
rtss .-Aleppo pine-
1 I.-•-•.,,., ... __ ,
j 159 Aleppo pine
I
i 160 :Valley oak
I 1'1 Vaile}' oak
j m coastltve oak
i163 :va1iev·oai
j1,4 /Valley oak
, 165 coa.,tiive oaii:
!1'6 .. jValley oalc . -
li61 :coastiiveoai. .. ·
!168 :van;y·ciak ·
169 \.a11ev -oak°
I 110 /Ituioi,ean oHv"e
,
1
--.i.
72
11 1&ropeaii oH~ci ·
:Yalley-oiik ·· ...
.... ___ -· , .• .._ ... _ •• 1
!173 ,Valle\' oak
1174 . :Europeanolive -•· -
1
115 ya11ey oak
:176 TVaJ.iey·oik-·
Ii,, ! Valley oak
I
i178
1179
Valley oak
Valley oak
180 , va1,ey·oa1c -
1s1 Vaiiey oaic. · ·
i82 · Valley oalc
I l __ , __ ·---..
I i83 Valley oalc l 184 ;vaiiei oak ..
' " ! 185 vaiie\' oaic
! 186 vaiiey oak .
!i87
1188 !
1189
!
1190
11;1
1-,192
1193
European oHve
:vaiiey oali. · · ·
European olive
Valley oak
European olive
European olive
I 194 :va11ey oak I 195 Valley oak
!196 Valley oak
! 191 ·. -vaii~ oiik
'·
J~~--
:12
'i ff
iii '
f·. 18 L ....
·10
DBH • Dlamew-Breast Height
Hght • Height
Sprd • Canopy Spread
Hlth -Health
·,:~
130
--+20
I
---i-.
'
l.
i
.l "
·-i x~: ·t
Strc • Structure
.. . ' .... r-
·l · · r l ----·i-
t . .L !
f
' i
.j. .... '
i .I
!
I --r . )'op cited-discmgdamage
. f . _ J't'op ~e~~ ?ls~:~:d~ge ...
-~--. ·r · ... J _
j .. . I •• !
I
(12
.-.. ··'.
.!3 .. ;
-1 -••:• .. ,!. ..
I
~
J
1.
.I
I
I .J
' ! ..
.. ·'---.... -, .. ·-------·-·-· ......... -----· i Top died-discing damage
... j
·1 -·····" . j .... -
I .T .....
.L
I
' ..
i ,--. ' ....
, J\.iistletoe
, !·
... ~ r:
CD/l!!I • Co-Dominant Stems w/ lmbedded Bark
'fl)pd • lb?ped
1/D • Insects or Disease
RC • Root Collar Covered
H20 • Needs Wat.er CBL? • cables Recommended
1,a
1= 202
203
204
285
29'
207
ios
209
110
211
212
213
214
215
l:u,
I
'217
illl
219
228
221
222 1:
/us
1:
Im
229
230
231
Im
I ;233
I
1234
I:
i231
1:
,240
1241
1:
,244
1245
1246 1u,
TrffN•mc DBH DBH DBB H&)at Sprd IDtll . Strc CD/IB Tppd Cbl.T I/D RC 1120 ota
Vaiiey·oait -
Valley oa1:
va11eyoaic.
vaiievoak
·vatiey oalc-
:
Valley oak
Valley oaic
.Valley oak
caiifom1a·bay 1iiiireI
. Umbcllularia califomica · Vanei ·oa1c ·· -----
:Valley oak
Valley oak
,Vaitcyoiik
Valle} oak
Coast .live oak.
Vaiiey· oak
-Vailey oak .
vaitevoak-
)flue oak
'.Quercus douglasii
Valley oak
,European olive
' Vaiiev'ciak -
European olive
Yalleyoak
Vlilicy oak
Valle)' oak
Coastiive oa1c
vaifevoak .
:valley oak
va1iey oai
Afeptio i:,iiie
a1ueoa1c:·
Va11eyo11k
Va11eyoa1c
Blue Oak
n1iieoa1c ·
B1ue ·oa1c
i3tueoik
i:iliie dak
Blue Oak
B1iie Oak
Blue Oak
va1iey · oak
Coast live oak
Coast live oak
Valley-oak
coa·st ·rive' oaic:
Coast hve Dill
Coast live oak
Blue Oak
12
'is
8
·,u ·
io
:9
' 21
113
i · io
14
'12
1H
j -·
14
('i4 .
16-
114 L, __ _
13
ii '
10 ·
·\n---'fo·
·'--· L 8
TB-
s
l lf
i -·-IS
;32 '
ff
i9 'f-
-:10-
I
38
i 19
i
i6
i 14
'14 '
;14 '
10
:34
20
:14
27
/is
·22
·,B
'14
14
17
:17
12
121
D8H -Diameter Bn!ast Height
Hght -Height
Sprd -canopy Spread
Hlth -Hearth
,-·-;lo --···'"'~ · ~u-f ·-,Ju~~;;t'"'-'1 :i;·-'""-n ·1r~11~g1u11 · ,...,.liil 11·.1,c;··
·-. i p : ~ I •
35 JS
·3s
20
12s ·
'Jo
30
-:is
)S : ·.3o .
i40
·,ii)
i lf
.35
IS
·:25 ·
I
3ii'
jio
25
:fo
i25
;30'
40
]2s''
'30
130 . 135
'js ·30
I
-135 . '3-0
L .... J ...
·3S :20
i t's
)
2 2
i i j
14 4
j4' ·:4··
·3 -3
12 3
4 .s
i
iJ
L
3
!2
3
j .. ;I
T
i
''i t3
' 2 2
If ·;3'·
.L,. I
3 ,2
15
:sis-120·-
1 'i<f"'
! .
20
\40 .
'ro
\j<f
lI
L
2
lf
' J .•... s
,To
!30
25
;-,o
3S
,-
\o ·
:ro
40
'.35
IS
'20 j
'jo
TI
'· 2
j4 ,
·3
)4 :4
.. -y
t ··-··· --.-· ( i"
20 r T
1io · n -:1
' 60
Ao -
i.
·25
:2<i
I_
3S
i20
Jo
~
3
'2
j
'i'i's '1 ,i
40 2 2
:2s ,2 3
I so 2 ·3
·,fo ;4 4
40
:35 -'45 ii -i
35 -30 3
:'40 :i6 '. i 3
45 35
40 ,30 '1 2
3S 40
Sttc -Structure
CO/[B -Co-Dominant stems w/ lmbedded 8ar1c
Tppd -Topped
C8L? -cables R8:ommendecl
i
• I
I
I
fMajor leader-failure
!
Topped at 8 feet
1Dead ·
I
1/D -Insects or Disease
RC -Root Collar Covefl!d
H20 -Needs water
. 248
!24,
I
~ •me
·va11ey~--· .
, Coast iive oa1c ~19 ·
l2so , __ : Coast live oalc ...
. B1ueOa1c"
. Is . . .. -
I._ .. L .. L
:251
1252 ;Blue Oak
i2SJ coast live oaic.
I
12s. ,toast iive oak
i 255 Coast !i~-e oak
tw coiist iivc oaic ·
I r2s1 j3iiie oak
I
!258 '.Coast live oak
)259 · ·coasi iivc-oiik ·
i .. .--... ·-~. ---·--··--~-!260 Coast live oak . .
[ 261 : C~ ~iye ciak
(262 _ '~-~~~e~-
1263 : Coast live oak
i . --. . . --------·. !™ .Coast live oak
9 :9
·r9 ---· i.'
:tf
"jii
; i:f
f9-..... r.
,14 ,
r~!.
;10
1"ff
I hs y,·
"'1ii
i
!
!-:8
j265 . 1Coastiive "oaic -
i2" I Valley oak
jii>. ;
;u--. ,
)261 · 'coai.t ITveoa1c· .. ·· ·
.. _,_ ...... -r _ .. _l_,,· .: . · t~ · -!r -
Im :Coast live oak
l2,9 · coast live oaic
121, 1coasi ·live ·oa1c··
I !m · :"ciiast ti,:e oai:
im .t:\ia.st live oak -.
!273 -coasi five oaic -
r214° :-coasi llveoalc--
!215 'coiisdi~e-oa1c --·-
i2" Coast live oak I 211 '. Unused Number .. I
[271 · COIN live oak
1
Valley oak
·cO¥t1iveoai ·
Vaiiiri, oaic ..
,sfue Oaic--
:eiiie 6ali.
:s1uc0ak
:Coast iive oak
:BfucOak .
Blue Oak
'Blue Oak
·eiiicoak·
•B1ueoaic ·
·e1iie oak
·vaifei.-ciaf
Coast. live oaic
va1Teyoak
va1iey .oak.
i
1.3.3.. :2s
]2.3.:
,17 -r1 ··-,
-!iY: I_
12s ·
:9
)29
\26 ..
tw·
iis
ps
:if"
bs
, 14
i1
. L .•. I 10
• I
j
. p-r -.. [
:'fO ..
i a2.
j26
:8
Jil
I
Poison oak 18
1. :297
!.
loxtodendron d1verslioba ·
Coast.live oak___ • i21
..... : .... .i .
DBM • Diameter Breast Height
Hllllt· Height
Sprd • Canopy Spre11d
Hlth • Health
[10 -
; r ·
I
,.
!
-;·
··tJs ·· .... -,:1;,;
.L .... ------
/30 (50 i . ,
·12:s--l1s · · ;r -p ---1 . !30 )s ·.·i --p· ··r
. i~ _·. 1~0 .. ·12· ···-,3 ---1
i40 ;20 1 . ~2 -. !
· ;4~.... j:-~3-~o-· ! 1 ... Oi"~ _:· !x
; 15 ; 1 i3 :
• i • • Jx
----i:---·t: · r!~ l!-
.:?~.-~.:J~-~:_-_J--:.:. J~.
!35 125 i l 14 !X
;2s · jJo · _ p-·r r-1
· T3s iso-1 ·:2
(20 ..
-~ -,30
!35
r2s
iis
:10
i . 130 . ·1 1 '2
! .. L J..
:15 •l !2
::zo -·t35 IT j2.
i _ ...... ! ...... J .•..
"[
... : .
. ,· .-. f
. L ... t
I -,-' {
l
strc -Structare
i
I -!--
' ··i
I
i
1·
J
I
i .r
j
'
-~ .. !_
' i.
.• 1
-~ ....
I
-l
.. · 1· ... "'j'"-· ... l ' .
J .. .L __ ; __ . ·1'.--
: I
' I ···r-. r ·-·: . ··r ·--
1 .. ~. __ • • I
I
I . ~-~-j '
J
i
. -i -·
i-.
.. ~-.... ·-.
I
~ ··i ..
l
I
i ................ -~ .... ·-......
:Major trunk.decay
T
I
CD/lB • Co-Domlna!lt Stems W/ lrT'bedded Bark
:ppd -Topped
CBL? -Cilbles Recommeml<!!d
l/0 • Insects o r Disease
RC -Root Collar covered
H20 -Needs water
Tree Name DBH DBH DBB Hcht Sprd IDtb Strc CD/IB Tppd Cbl! 1/D R.C mo Nota
,ua Valley oak IS 40 3S 1
12,, European olive \6 :5/5 '.514 )5 ·20 ,i ·3
I I 1: Vai!ey oak 4i:i" 4S 40 2 2
Coast iive·oa1c '6. 15 'lS .i ·2
,302 j '·· ' Valley oe1c ·2s 4S 4S '1 2
1: Coast live oak '.i4 30 145 i I .2
i
va11eyoak 7 ·25 30 j
f: va1iey oak · :13 -;:10 t30 i ,2
I ' Valley oak 6 )30 10 3 :i
;..._ :10 r--1307 Vailey oiik : t()° '20 ls ;4
1 )6 I_. 303 . va1ie" oaic 35 30 I i
l~. ~0~_1iv~-~-·w :-rs i i() ;i" 2
i i~. .H °3o ' 1310 ,Valley oak: .3S 1 2
1311 'valley oaic ;io !30 120 (2 ,2
i .~ .
i312 w1ev oa1c 6 15 is ·3 3
313 ·Valley oak · ~6 ·:10 li o ....... '4
l : io· I
314 • Coast live oai:. 5 10 2
315
..
"c:oasflive oak f 6 :is· p~ ( ;2-
1316
i
Blueoai:· 4 20 15 I 'i
1317 , coast Gvc oaii: · j'1 . ·:B iis n· ·,-1
'
318 ·va11ev oak . '14 25 ·20 3 ::r
31!) . coast live ciak. 16 . L :B ps ·12 ]3
European olive s 20 20 .I.
320 4 3 I 2
1321 · .. Euroiiean ofwe· · •6 15 '4 ?o j25 ! I '.3
I I : f 322 Vaileyoak 12 30 ·30 ·3
323 va1iey·oa1c 1 ··-·,45 !35 12 .1 ! ,16
t3U .... I valiev oak .. 16 35 2S 3 3 X
: coast iive oiik .. :13 ·-'j"(j"" p:s ·· i i" ·2 r -325
l_._ t _
32' vaiie.,,. oak 16 35 ··30" 2 "3 ·x
327 Cout live ·oa1c j6 ;10 po , I ;3
' I
328 . coii.;i live oa1: 5 io 16 I 3
32' 'vaffey oak !IO is :j5 15 "4
Coast live oa1c 20
I ' 330 5 IS l 3 X
331 uiiuseii Number. L. 1-1-
1332 va1teyoak 10 40 '20 3 2
[333 Coast live·oak i if
..
.40 120 . i i
1334
J I coo.st live oai: 7 20 :·is 2 2 jm Valley oak i IO :Jo !20 ;J .. 3
.336 Valiey oak '·23 45 40 2 2
!337 Valley oa1c . 25 :SO /50 1 .2
J I Coast live oak 1338 6 15 IS 2
1:: : Valley oalc 15 45 'JS :2 ;j .
!
Coast Jive oak 26 so 70 2
I i:u1 Valleyoalc is '.45 Jjs !i
f342 Valley oak 13 40 20 3 2 130 Valley oak 24 :40 ;30 ,2 4 )X
1344 Coast live oak 7 15 IS 2
i:us Coast live oalc ?g ·2S i JS :2 2
!3" Valley oaJc 14 35 25 2 2
i
;341 Coast live oak -16 is \I t 2
L_
DBH • Diameter Breast Height Strc -strudUre
Hght -Hefght CD/IB -Ca-Dominant stems w/ !mbedded Bari< !/D -Insects or Disease
Sprd • canopy spread Tppd -Topped RC • Root Collar CD'lll!red
Hlth -Health CBL? • Cables Recommended H2D • Needs Welter
I j 1m_·Name
!348 Valley oak
'-
\349 :coast live oak
!3SO ·coast Gve ·oak:
[351 -co~·11vc·oar -
j3s2 ~·valTev iiai ·
I
j3S3 vaiiey oak .
1354
I
;3ss
Crabappie
Matus SJ!.Cc1es ..
Coast live oak
I , . ···----! 356 · Valley oak
'.357 1iicense cedai !
1358 incense cedar
j
;359 :incense cedar
! 360 Incense cedar
[ 361 . iii.c'ense cedar ..
j3i'i2 incense ·ceaai -
\363 . Aleppo pine
i364 · 1ru:ensc ceilai .
i ... ---·· ·----· ;36S 'Incense cedar
j366 'Incense cedar·
!367 :fnceosc·cedar -! I
:368 Incense ccd
' I 369 : 1nceiise· ce11ai
' r 370 . Incense cedar -
1-!371 1 Valley oak
1372 Coast ltve oak
!373 ; Unused ~umber
I
:374 ·unused Nunibcii I :vai1eyoa1c [37S
137' . C<>11-5t h"e ·oat-·
i377 :co'ast liveoak ___
l I
[378 · ·ciiast 1Ive oa1c --
!379 1 Coast live oak
!380 ·"cc,w Hve oak ..
I
1381 :Coast live oak
I
ln1
I
. vaftey · oai
f3B3 -vaiiey oak
1384 I • Coiist H,·e oak
i38S Valiey oak°·
1386 vaite> oak
' 13~7 Valley oak
388 European olive -
t389 · Coast live oak
!390 vai1i:y·oak
[3,i
I
·Valley oak
!391 Hybnd°oaic
i g_~~-S. spec~es.
:393 Valley oak
i394 va11ey oaic
I
E395 ·valley oak
1396 vaiiey .oaic
1397 '\•'alley ·oak
:5
!-;6
i7
)_ .
6
.hi "'
L -['
-r ·-. . 1 -'~--. -
]9 ··
I
(9
'6
i ' .~f ___ · __ J __ ·_·
·10
··1-r····r··-
-... _ ... .!-...
5 ;3 .
I
· is /i .
··:-,-·<
-'i ~~~--:-!~-. ·10 '8
Ji~~. j8
'9 Ju.··-·j .
:6
. !~9 -. · 1 ·
43
j36
__ t_ ·-
:23
! i7
1 ...... -
·12
"/if
:26
]1~
.26
jn
11
i 18
J ....
·24
Ill
i
·r
.8
l.
CBH -Diameter Breast Height
Hght -Height
Spr'd • canopy Spread
Hltll • Healttl
':is
. !._ -.
:40
-~fs ··
I )o ··
' ·• 1f . '136 Ti
J..... • .. 1
: 15 ;20 i2
·,30 [30
'.3S 1
65
2 l.
.2
I
:'j(
X
i._ .. E J.· :2
i
. ··~1 2
·!1
Jr
i . :2
ii
J.
l I
'
Tx
I
L
Stn: -structure
I
i.
j·
I.
i
I ·1
j -
I
. ! ..
I
·t,· ... ~
.... -(-... !
.i
. ·I··
i
I
1
!
i ·•
CD/18 -CO·Oomlnant stems w/ Jmbelided Bark
Tp;,d • Topped
CBL? • Cables Recommended
i
I
t Partial for Line Clearing
' ! CD High Risk
' j_ .. --. -. --
;Dense leaf litter -Very good
.!
'
! Split in progress
[Previous Cb Failure
!
'
UC • Insects or OlseDSe
FtC • f\oot COiiar Covered
H20 -Needs Water
Tree Name DBB DBH DBB Hgbt Spnl ffltb Strc CD/IB Tppd Cbl! 1/D RC 1120 Notti
3'8 Valley oak 17 20 30 2 3
399 Vaiiey oak )2 :20 ;25 j ·.2
1: Vailey oak 10
<.
15 20 3 2
Va11ey·oak :1i 15 ;1s '3 2 ~ Vailey oak :i2 20 20 j -f
· Valley oak: :3i1 :40 /35 ; ~ ,2
I
Vaiiey oal ii 30 40 2
J40s Va11ey-oak: '2i j5 :10 !2 2
I: I
Vaiicy oak Ii 25 2S l
Va.11er oa1c f:io 'is ;25 ,5 ·s IX : Pr1inary leader gone
1-1 .. ',fa-L , ..
Valley oak 27 35 ·3 3
f 409 -Valley oak: 1 12 ·:-is ?5 ;2 ,4 ::x ·x ~Previous ct:f faifiire -·1imb <iecar
1410 . 'Coiiit _l~e oak .
f J . I
is ·41Y '4S 1 ..f
1411 'Valley oak 123 )40 ~ 15 '3 ;3
[412
; I_ I
va1ieyoaf 10 · 30 15 2 ·3
[413 : vailey·oa1c w ·;JS 130-,j ·1 2
I ( f,n4 ' , .. ! Valley oaic . 12 35 ·2s 2 2
41S · ;vaiier oaic ,n ;30 i~0:-1~: i j" 3
; j __ . :
416 Vai1ev -oaic --16 ·30 35 5 4 3 r Vailcy oak -;13 ·:25 · ]20 [3 ·-2-T
Valley oak -is 35 r_ ---i_._ °2 418 30 2
419 ; ciia.,i1ive .oak !30 Ifs '45 '60 It ....
va11"eyoaic . I ! l_
420 is 35 30 3 2
421 Valley oak . !]4 '30 "1,"3 0 l i ;:f
: i I \ .. m Valley oak 23 35 40 2 : 1
423 Aieppopine :6 ·:i-o no ;i 'I
•12s -I .. ' I
424 Aieppo-pine 9 25 1 '4· x
•425 ,Aleppo pine ;;; 1:i-s· ·12s IT T
426 Aleppo pine
,_ -~ J ... ··1 8 25 25 1
427 :Aleppo pine 7 T2s ,26 I j !I
! I.. ..
428 Vaiteyoak 24 30 35 2 2
41' . Valley oak !JO 20 )0 :,f · 3
.•. ; r
1430 Aleppo pine 8 10 15 . i :3
431 Va11i:y oak : 18 :25 1j5 ,2 '2
' ,
432 Bliieoek 16 30 25 3 3
433 va11ey·oa1c ( i 1 30 !25 13 · 2
!
. Valley oak . i2 °lo IS ' . 434 3
435 Coast live oaic ;17 ,30 ,:35 /2 ; I
,436 ·Vai1eyou: ii lo, Valley oak 16 30 :35 ,°3 3
[431 Valley oak 40 35 30 3 4
' [m Valley· oak . / 12 30 '25 '3 2
f: . Valley ·oa1c 12 js 20 '4 3
Biue-oak · 26 40 '60 :2
' :
1442 Blue Oak 23 40 50 2 1
I:: Blue Oak ;25 45 'so ;2 1 Disci ng
Aleppopme 8 25 15 1
1 ... s Blue Oak 9 ,9 Di:ad
i \446 Valli:)> oak: 12 35 30 4 4
'"7 Valley oak ;29 40 55 3 3 ·-
DBH • Diameter Breast Height Strc • Stnlctllre
Hght -Height CD/IB -Co-Dominant S'tems w/ lmbedded Berk 1/0 • Insects or Disease
Sprd -Canopy Spread Tppd -lbpped RC -Root Collar Cowred
Hlth -Health CBL? -Cables RecOmmende<f H20 • Needs Water
I j ~Nallie
448 : Coast live oak
[449 ,Aiei,poi,foe ··
t4so ·Aleppo-pine
f· ... ---·· ....... __
1~51 :ft.J~p~-~~~-1'52 Aleppo pme
i453 incense "cedar--
i 454 Aleppo pine
:'55 I
1nunse ccciar-
145' · Incense cedar
1457 ! Incense cedar
[4sa 'incen.'IC cedar r,s, ,incense ceilai ·
r :Afeppo piru:-. •460
I
!461 • .Aieppo -pine
(
· 1riceruie cedar •462
L1u ·1nceiise ceilai I
f464 :inceiise cedar
i465 '.Blue Oak -·
I
~Vailey oak i"' 1467 tBlueOak
1468 ;Viiiieyoak
f
[469 fBiiie.Oak --·
!470 t .Blue oai.:
(
:471 'valicioaf
l,n
I :Valie" oak
1,13 jBlue Oak
t Blue.Oak :474 t,,s : Valley ·oak --.
t476 Blue Oak
1477 :BiueOak
L_ ••
1478 Blue oak" ..
!479 :Blue Oak I
1-:vane} oak
L,u ,Blue Oak
t
1482 Blue oaf· Im :Biuc ·0a1c
!484 ,vaiieviiak
!485 : va11er ciik
;486 Valley oak
1487 va11cyoak I
1488 va1iey ·oai:
I
!489 ,Valley oak
1"490 a"iueoai..· ! .val1iyciaf j491
\492 Viiifeioiik I
1493 'Valley oak
j494
'
Vai1eyoak.
[495 :\Talley oak
'"6 Aleppo pine ! . t497 Aleppopmc:"
'
.. .J~ .. Oi
:17
hx .. r-·-. r·
J . ·-·· I .. . :21
... J~!-:
:20
h2
ri! ... l
:13 i ' -12,r
... L..
'21
I .... l .
1 .
.. j24 · ' . 1 ..
.... _J___ j --···-'···· : 18
-' -:20 ;
i ·
L
114 -·· · T
I ... •
·23 • ... ·--i~~~ :·_j
21 .
[is ... ··r
,2i
·11 9
,11
·:12
.I .
OeH • Diameter Brellst Height
Hght • Height
Sprd • Canopy Spread
Hitt,· Health
i ,·
~-.
. l '
i.
!
r·
i
i f·
i
.I
}
... )
.-!..
I
I
i
jTop 2/3 dead
.. , -.
L ··-.~. -··
.! ..
j
h op2/Jdead
I .....
i
1.
l t ... T
I ' l . . -~
I . -... ,
1 · · ... r .
l l ""i
! .
I .. J.
·p-o !3 l~ ..
;ss ,J ·2 -·· ·140· --,20 · ·· 13 · · ·,r-
... _ .• 14··s· · · · l 3·· ·11
1 ·1···· ]45
f!.: J~s t . J~ · J
.JO ·.:40 :3 :2 . .I fjo ·· _-·1·2s 13 :4
I '· ' .40· :40 2 t i
140 . "i40
.i
t JO ·h ;1
~·:·}?·:_· .. J~~ ·. "!i !f .!_
Strc -Structlre
I
I
I
i"
l
~ -.
CO/lB • Co-Ooml:iant stems w/ Imbecded Bark
Tppd • Topped
CB~? -Cables Recommended
,
i
l/0 -Insects or Disease
RC -Root Collar Covered
H20 • Needs Water
TncNa-DBB DBH DBH Hglat Sprd ffltla · Stn: CD Tppcl Cbl1' IJD RC mo Nota ,,. Valley oak 12 30 30 3 3
"'' Blue Oak ;Iii 40 :45 ;3 2
580 Blue Oak 19 .30 45 3 2
SOI .. Blue Oak :7 ;
·is !IO "i4 3
502 ; Aleppo pine 8 '7 ·2s 2S 3 3
503 Aleppojj1ile •10 :2s iis j3 .3
.! i ' 504 Aleppo pine 11 ·2s 15 ·3 j x ·
505 fncense ceilar ·s ·:10 : io jf I
! '
506 . Incense cedar s 15 10 4 .1
507 Inceruie"cedai 1s _fo t"i6 is A :top 2/3 cicad
I I
,sos Incense cedar s io 10 .3 3
1509 Incense cedar :s . -rn-:10 }f ·,3 "fjf
Aleppo pine
I 1C .• 2s" I i_ (
510 2s· 2 .3
511 ,Aleppo pine Jio fls ; fs :i !3" '.X
! l
i512 Aleppo pine 15 25 :25 3 2
513 · Aiewo p1iie I i2 i2s !20 ir / l I i .•
51" Incense cedar 6 15 10 ·'3 I I
515 Jn"cense cedar '6 (IS ! ..... ·1~f Ir ·
I_ -
\ 10 i _
516 Incense cedar 6 '.10-· io 4 i
517 Incense cedar-i s· rH> po fJ ; i
518 Incense cedar -s ur 10 3
519 :Aieppo-pine i ii 120 1_20· "l3 13 rx
520 L • L I -3
,
Aleppo pine 9 20 20 2
511 A1epi,oi,ine !W ·:25 ,20 12 .. 13·-
I '·-Sl2 .Aleppo pine 9 •io IS 4 3
S23 . 'Incensc-cediir -·s ho ·,10
i )2
524 -'. incense cedar s 10 10 3 I
S2S --:-jijeppopine i,o-·1:io if() ri-'.;r --,x
I
ffi . ·Incense cedai ·1 is io 2 T
527 ! Incense ceciiii is · fo iio (4 i i
528 Incense cedar s 'io 10 4 . i
"' Aleppo pine \9 ·2()
1
1s· if :4 iX iTopdead
! ; I ,_ k,
530 Aleppo pine 11 20 26 2 4 X
531 .A1ci,iio.iiine /13 ;is !25 j ·:·3
J
Aleppo pinci" "io 1s J ·2 S32 11 2
533 : incense cedar 6 :f6 : ici' ;3 ·• 1
j534 Aleppo -pine t"6
.. ' 30 3 ·4 x· 25
I: Aleppo pine Ii ·20 i ts i-4 ·4 iX
I ... ·20 : I
Aieppop1ne 10 t"s 2 3
I
S37 Aleppo pine i16 I 20 120 '3 ·4 rx !
S38 Wild Plum 9 6 10 10 4 2
S3, WilciPfum !9 ·.10 , 10 ;3 2
' 540 Coast iive oak Ii ;is 30 2
1541 coast Hve oiik 'is :7 35 ,Js ;r ··,
Coast live oak 35
'· 3 S42 12 1S 1
'543 Coast live oak 11 ,35 !JO ,i
1544 Valley oak 3S ;
10 20
ls.is Coast live oak ;S 15 10 i 3 I
l ! [546 Coast live oak 12 25 20 3 X
I
Coast iive oaic 13 25 :i \S47 :30 2
OBH -Diam_. Breast ~ight Sire • Structure
Hght -Height CD/IB -Co-Dominant Sll!ms w/ lmbedded Bark r/0 • lnsed:5 or Disease
Sprd -Cano11Y Spread Tppd • Topped RC • Root Collar Covered
Hlth • Health C!IL? -Cables Recommended H20 -Needs Water
I I TneN•ine
1548 Coast hve oak
[549 Coast live oak :
isso Blueoak
I
:s51 Coast live oak
~ss2 coasi1.~e oak l
1
553 coaii11veoak.·
1554 'Coast live oak
rsss ,Coastlive oa1c ·· ..
'556 Coast five oaic I
'S57 'Coast live oak
~sss ci>a,i iiveoak .
lss9 ;Coast live oak
~ 560 . Blue oak ...
i561 :vaiiey oak
t 562 . toast frve oaic . I
[563 ;~1-live·oa1c -
I
1564 .Coastliveoak I 1~5 . ;Coast live oak
l5" :vaitey oak-,.
1
567 ! Coast live oak
568 Wiid Piwu -· .
j569 , tciasilive oak .
' j570 Blue Oak
I
's11 'Witdpium
f 572 ;Monterey Cypress
' Cupressus macrocaipa .
i573 iValley oak
I
I
1578
·ince~ cedai
: southern magnolia
)Magnolia gnmdiflora
· Coast live oak
iCypress ·
• C~pr~~Sll~ ~~ci~s
. Coast hve oak
!s19 :Coai"iii've oaic .
(580 'Coast live oak
'581 , Coast live oak
!ss2 va1Tev oak ·
1583 Valley oak
; I 584 Coast Hvi: oak
! 585 · Valley oaic--
!ss6 Vailer oak
i587 ·coast live ·oak
i -·-·. ----·--------; 588 Coast live oak
lss9 \'aiiev oak -. I ,
1s,o ~1oiiterei pme · I 5n · va11i:y oar· ·
' 1592 coa.~·11ve oaic
:s93 Coast live oak·
\ 594 Incense ceciar
'
f 595 European ofive
! 596 C'oastiive oaic
OSH -Ola:r.eter Breast Height
Hght -Height
Spill -canopy Spread
t-11:h -Health
j 3
:2
'
Strc • Structure
1
.. i
I
CO/IB • CO-Oorninant Sterns w/ I mbedded Berk
Tppd • Topped
CBL? -cables Recommended
I 1Di:iia ..•
.. l
Notu
l/0 -Insects or Disease
RC -Root COiier Covered
H20 • Needs water
m
593
m
600
'81
'°2
TreeN-DBH
,Coast live oak /40 ... ~.
c"oast iive oak 30
ciia,;i liveoak 'ii
BiueOak 20
Blue Oak /17°
I
Blut:Oak i2
DBH -D1a1netB Breast Ht!lght
~ht -Height
Sprd -Canopy Spread
Hlltl-Healtll
DBH ·--DBII Dpt bl1' 11D --35--,1 "' ',· ...... ~=···, -. -.."" •• "". •r"-"' ...... 7'1-U
I "30 45 1
':ff ,45 . a ·2
40 30
\40 ·130
;
25 25
2 j
.1· if
2 3
Strc -Structure
C0/18 -Co-Dominant Slams w/ lmbedded Bark
Tppd -Topped
CBL? -Cables Racornmended
RC 0
1·1.:ai ··---.·~
Ne1a ·-==1
1/0 -Insects or Disease
RC -Root Collar Covered
H20 -N-'s Water
Jl&ae
1~03 -~Valley o ak
D61i • Diclrneter Breast Height
Hi;ht • Height
Sprd -Canopy Spread
r1lth • Health
Strc • Structure
CD/IB • Co-Dominant StAlms w/ Imbadded Bar ~
Tppd • Topped
CB~? -Cables Reco,r.mended
1/0 -Insects or Disease
RC -Root Collar Covered
H20 -Needs Water
Surrey Farm E1tates lmpam to Trees
ByPropo,ed
Plans A-1 u.d A-lA
Sarrey Farm Estates Lut Date
Los Gatos, California
Tree Name DBH Condition Reviewed Dlapoeltlon Reason(•) tor Dlspoaltlon Impacts
j1 :eoaslrl~~-/1°a<i: ;~it,_ro.;,·f~iik611i ,i-:~~~~f~'nt · ;~~~:~/68~~~~~011 ' ' · · j
12 :~:~~~a~~~lia ,6 . '.Good jfoii0/14 -:Transplant '.RoadwayConstnictkin I
!3 !=-~:~bata ·· ;1s ;Excei1ent 110120114 -;transplant · :Roadwayeonsiruc11on Ii
4 ·~11veoa1<·· 'il 'Gooil -1nrl'loJ14 -~Ri!move· --;RefeniloiiPondConstrui:ilon ·
5 lrncense cedar ---f5 . -:Gooi:t' -!lifflb/14 · -~Remove · -·:RoadwityConsfruction ·---------1-
,Calocedrus decurrens i ; · ·
15 ·Coaslllveoak ----~13 1Good--iiOl20/14 -:iransplant ·'RoadwayConstructio·n i
'7 :Incense cedar --... i4 -. ,;Faff . /10/'l0/14 -'.Preserve iRoadway Coiistructiori=lciw Impact I
8 !eoasrliveoak 1en ·i aooif --J'f0~0/14 ;trarniplant i RoadwayCoiistruciion !
!9 ;eoast live oak . :, .Go·oa -;,0120114 '.Traiispiant . !Rriadway'Corisfrucikin 11
I
• , I i
10 jeoastnveoak ,8 ;Good· -J10J2oli4 :Transplant -fRoiidway~nstrucilon -·-i
11 ,Coasilive oak· 17 :G-oodiFair 110.12'tm.ii :Praseive -:Aoaclway·c::ons1rucllon .--1 • f I f . I
12 1Coiittiveoak 111 -·'.Gooif-l1Mo/14 :transj:ilant ·(RoaawayCoiistiuctlon
13 iCafriofnia black walnui'-\19 :Poor ' .. i rn12oi14 -jAeiiicive -:Floadway Coiistructlim I
;J~lans hindsii i ' J
,14 1A1eppo plne :5 · ·Fair}Poor · \10120rt4 :Remove 1Ffoadway eoristiucliori ·1
1s · i~'i~~~~tsis ---; 11 · :Poor ··--hor1t>Jf4 -;Ftemow ·--ilfoadwiy Coristriictlon ·--i
'16 · *5
p1~~-·-·-·--· · !f2 '.~oor -·lto~o714 ·-!Remove 'RoaawayConsfu:tion ~
11 :va11eyoai< -· --!11 · -Good ·--:10120,u · -·rransplant · i~oactway·coristrucllon ·-~
111 !c-oast11veoak -120/16 ·--;Gooi:i ·-hoi26/f4 -Ifieroove -]Ai:iadwayeonstruction I
19 JCoast lfve o·iik 1a --:FalrlPooi fn,12oif4 -:i:temow -iRriiiawayConsfnicilon -_j
24 jeoast lfve o'iik i21· ;(3'ooa!F'e]r'!1oi'roli4 -· ;Remove -:~oiidway /Storm Drain Construction I
25 '.eoast lfve oak : ff --;GoocJJFairT1 ol'lofi4 --jrransp1aiit · \Roadway rstorm ora,n· Construction · -, , ' . I
26 1eoasrnve oak 110 -\1oocliFair i1oi'20714 --''Transplant · :Aoac1way'Construcdon i
27 :coast live oak ---)1 s · -;Good/Fair \1ID'lo/f4 --'.Remove ·-· )Roiiawaytonslfuak,-n j
28 !t:ouillve·oak ;Hi' --'.Gi:ioa -r1012i1/14 ;'rrariipla'nt '.A'oai:fway ·eo·nsfn.icdoii I
29 ,Coasiflveoal( \14 . __ :Good/F"afr l:f (ft207f4 ··-·'.Remove -:Roaaway·construcli<iif -~
JO ;Valley oak --.19 . :Fair --Tf(j/2oif4 -:Remove ·,RoadwayCoristrucifon/Slorm Drain ·l
34 ;eoasHiile oak 12 :Good -·;t0/20/14 -lfrarisj)larit ·siorm brain Construction --. !
35 Vaney·oak --;17 ~GooaJFalr ho1'i<>7f4 -~Remove · 'storm t>raln Construction -
48 :va1eyoak is "FafriPoor \1<>flofi4 -:Remove .Aeteiriiori'Pond Conslruciion
U :Coastlive ·oak i'tll/15 -·· ;Good ·-j101'l0/14 -\Remove RoadwayConstruction -
&3 jCoast live oak : t 5 :oooa· -; H>l:i!o7i4 -Remove Roadway corisfruct1iin ·
I ;8 -"Good -1'!'012t)/14 1Transplant . Retention Pond Constiuctlon
If: ;~= ~= ::: 16 .. Good/Fair! H)/'l0714 --'Remove --. Reteriiori' Pond Construction
' .90 ·Coastliveoak ,12 Good/Fair p ot20/f4 ·rransplant _Roadway Construction
f109 ·coast live oak ·15 ;l:xcellerit ii'Ofi:0/14 . ;'Remove ---:RoailwiiyConstructii>n
110 ;Wild plum --;6 -)Ext Poor i tOl'Zo/14 :Remove· 'Roadway ConstiLicilon
1Prunus cerasifera
123 ,'toasrtive oak ·
124 Coast live oak
' 125 Coast live oak
1
1
126 :eo~ live oak
134 ,Valley oak
, 135 Coast hve oak
h38 \/afleyoak
!137 ,Coastliveoak
Prepared hy Midlall Beodl
Coas.ttiog Arborist
12
/14
:10
.16
-39
8
7
,51513
Dead j10120l14
;r=rur i10/20/14
' -Good !10J'l0714
;Good/Fair i1<>i20/14
'Good 10/20/14
Good 10'20/14
Excellent 10/20/14
Ext Poor 110fl0/14
' 'Remove 'Sanitary Sewer Construction
'Preserie Sanitary Sewer Construction
·Remove Sanitary Sewer Construction
.Rerriove ·Sanitary Sewer Construction
Preserve Retention Pond Construction-Low Impact
Transplant Roadway Construction
Transplant Roadway Construction
Preserve Retention Pond Construction· Low Impact
i
I
J
j
'
<
I
' _j
October 20, 2014
Surrey Farm Estates Impacts to Trees
By Proposed
Pla11$A•l andA-lA
Los Gatos, California
·1j8 ·1.Coasfl1ve oal< ·---·-po --------Gooa/Fair 10!.!0/14 · -f Preserve --·fRetention-PonifConstruction-Low Impact --.
!139 )Coasflfve oal<--. . . !s -----tFair ----·fo121ITT4· -treserve---~tentionPonaConstruciion: Liiwlmpact -.. -,
1
152 !~ppopi"ne" .. -·---·-1 a·--'""1"Goocf" .. -f0/207'14 ---IPreseive--'"isanitaiy'SewerConstructlon"'' I l,49· :Aleppo pine -·-----------19 ----jexcellent f,f2/2omr ··:Remove--f aradfrigror Retention Poncf___ -... ··-----· -----l
1153 iAleppo pfne .. -.. 9 --·-· -1crood""-··-1®0/f.f-· 1:Teserve--fsiiiftar{Siwifr conslructTon
)154 :Aleppopme . --··. . . f16 _____ ·-rex
1
-celJent -_10/2o7f4-j eriiove-·--tannary"'Sewer"Construcilon -... ,
!155 '.Aleppopine "" ----... I~ ... Goocr -· -110/'l0Jf4·--l5reserve -•SariitaiySewerConstruction I
/1eo ~lliyoak _____ --·---__ __I ~,-------tFiiir ---10/11m--1Transplanf-i AHernatekcess ConslrucUori . -. . J11 ' I ' I ;1e1 !valley oal<----·-. ----· -rss--.. --\Good .... --T2727>7f<l'. -yreserve ·----i~-derate-Roofl>aiiiage"".:AffiimaieAccess---· .. ,
;162 ,Coasffiveiialc ... ·---· -... r ----· ·-... ·1Giioa.. ·i111l8i1s-· ·-:Preserve ·· -i~:~~!~~~~dby .. GriiiJing·an·crRetaJnliig " ---: :~= ~::;:.:~-_:~--=---~·:· .. ·.1~_;_·-... _-.. 1::~-~ :-r=· --~::;::~-,1·:;:~=-:~:::;:~. -----~~-~------~--1
i: ~::.; . . f -: ~~,~ ~r~~~1JOia .. ~"°"'"'-: ~----: I
:299 !1:uroiieanonve ·· .. · · · · ti5i5/5T-f · jcroo,r --·1'10120/14 --+mimove --fRo-acfway ·eo-nstruction -· ----·-------· 1
!301 ;eoast nveoa1c-···· ---.. · -1s----· -lcrooa -· 1ID20'/14---+rransi>fanf 1Roaaway (foiislruciiori·-·-· ---· -·------j
1302 /valleyoaC .. --------· --r,u·-.. ·-··-~oa -··--fo7'l07f4 ___ ,Remove-·· "]Grading __ ... -....... --. -··---:
1303 :Coasfllveoalc: ..... _ .. -N ... _ .. ·fGooa ··-· 1012Dtr-i ... ·fR'emove ·1Gradiii'g · · · ...... _ .... -·--· ·-\
f330 ~Coast Hve oar ---... -· s-· --·· 1'Gooa· --1' 1012o7f4-J:
1
Remove--· 'FfoadwayCo-nsfrii:iion ·--· ---·-... ----------1
I • I ' I !331 '.Un"usea f.fumliei 1 . -"'I .. I ---'j --·-! -. -.. -. . . -. j
!333 jCoasfHve oak ----i· 11-r ·-· ·--lGooc:f "". iT072o7i4 -rrranspTanf · -jRoadway·Construclion j
336 fVaJiyoak _____ . ___ .. _ 2s·-·-·.fair ·--. Hil'ib714""--1Remove-··:lfoacfwayConstructlon-i
3YT i'i7iilliif oak -. .. . . --...... 25 -.. . taood .. -"f0/2o/14 -.. \Remove"' . ~'Roadway-Construction . I
338 !coiifl1veoa1c · -··--......... s------~Goocc · -1oi20714 __ J TranspJanf"-1RoadwafConstriii.':tion"... ·· 1
!342 '.valieyoa-c -------·-· · --fff ---·-· · ti=arr--·-11®om ·-1Remove --l Roa"ilwayConstruction · .. i
1345 ;eoas1Tive oak .. · · -----· --·rs .. -· ·--1·Faff----110120114 --)'Remove .. -:R'oaciwayConstriicilon 1
'346 !Valleyoak · . 114 -1 Fair . f<>l20714·---·~emove·--tRo-adwa{Construction I
!349 jeoasfllveoal< .. · -------~ .. -· · ·fcrooil ·-.. -J~o.1201n --:Uansplanf ~oiidway Oonsfruciiori ·· · -1 i:~ :::::.:: -.. --~:-,,·:. . •... !::=:: ;::~t=~-:::: · 1
!357 lfricense-ceclar"· . if .. lE'xcellenf -Tif1207i4 .. /Transplant .. :Roadway C'onstnicifcin .. •
:358 ;incense cedar .. -.. -jll -· JGooir·---no12on:.r ··-'rransplant" -~oacfwafConstri.Jctiori ·-~
!359 Jiioenseceaar --. ·---15"'"' -~Fair-· ·-+@'R>/14 --!Remove "1Roaaway'Consiruction I
i3so hncense ·ceaar · ---· · s -.. -.. ·,Poor · .. · f, 012oJl4· --!Remove ___ --f AoadwaYtonsiuciion i
!361 :Incense cedar .. ·-----. -·Tr ·--... _ .. jGoocr·· ··-1 1oflo/f4 ---·J Remove -----·
1
'Fioadway Construction j
f 3&2 )rncerise ceaar ........ · .. -ts ---_ .. !Ext Poor -t,o.12o/'f4 .. · 1Jteriiove -'jl10acfway~iinstructiori r:; :.:.::~::~r . ::~ .. --..... · 1;3_·.-·: __ -~·-1::: ·~:~:1::::~~· i:;;:;:: ~::~= I
:36s 'Tricerise ceifaf' .. -· · · · --;9 -·-· · _ .. _!Excelleiif fo12orr:.i ·· +Preserve -1'Roacfway ·consiructiori j
1366 :incense cedar'···-··· · ..... ~e -· ·1<iooc1 · · ·h012o114 -·!Preserve· · ·ir~oaawafConstriidion 1 !:~::--I~--r=· l:: ~;:;:: J::~:!..~ ----1
:319 ,Incense cedar ... ··· .... · ~s-· ..... · iexcenenr J1101'2o7f4' · 1'frarisplanT -;~adway Coiisiruciion· I , I' , I ,
370 .lncense·cedar -... --... ff 0--. -"11=aif'-· . -ff072o/f4 ... __ (Preserve·-· iRoad'way Construction-Low lmpact
t371 :Valley' oak' . . ·-· is .. IGood' . t10120M ~P'reserve . -rRoadway Coiistrucifon-Lciwrmpact --
!312 :Coasfl,veoak __ 'i5·13 .... -ii:alr · ·· ·_ ~!~0120114-· !Preserve ... -Tffoaclway Construction
;m :unuseaNum&er -1 -• .. ·
Prepared by Michail Bench
Consulting Al'borist
.. J.
. ' i
i .... ,
October 20, 2014
Sun-, Jlarm E1tata lapacts ID Trta
ByPnposed
PlansA-1 udA-lA
[314 :unused Number i--· · ·· i I
f382 /Jaley"'o-ak ··-.s --;Poor -j1o720T14 '.Remove ;FfoactwiyOonsfriletion
t
383 '.Varley oak -49 Good -/10120114. -)Preserve ;Minor Root munage ::AJ1emate Access
403 ,Valeyoak ;3g · Good !10120114 :Remove· ·;araaing/DrivevayConstii.Jctloii
f449 -;~ pine ~9 -'.!=air ;'10/20714 -;Aeinovti :Grading"/ DrivevayCoiiriui:tion
451 ;Nappo plrie :11 'Fair "/10120114 . :Remove 'Grading J Drlveviy Corisiticllon
452 j1Jeppo-pme h4 · ··lu --(1<>i'l0tr4 -;·Remove :-a,i:fdmgJOnvev ayConstruclii>n
454 :Aleppo pine i 11 -:Fair --iro12M4 !Remove -~Grading, oiwevay eo"ilstrucilon
455 :lncense·cedar --)s --:ext Poor roQ0/14 --'Remove __ :Griding -
~51 !1ncenii1 cedar ;s --rext Poor -· 11M011, -'Remove -Gradiig -· ------· · -·
1
460 ·:A __ ~~-·po_-_-i>_lne_ -_ /9 .. --!Fair" -i1Molf4' .:118'nk;ve ;Graifing'/briveviiyConslructlon --
461 ;.._,., pine i10 'Poor -~101ioJ14 · ·Remove ·Graiirig -· · ------
~ ;1ni:enseceilar :1 ----:Ext Poor irni"lo/14 -"F~eiiiove ,Grading -
2 rArippopine -jsn ___ ;t:ilr --tt0~07f4 ~Remove -;Gridlrig/Drlvevay'Coiistrucilon ·--
:lncanse cedar :s --:-ext Poor li0'20lf4 --~ve :Grading
!
!Aleppoplrie ;11 'Falr --;m120114 -;R-iimove ·-:Gradirig/brfvevayCorisfructiori
1s12 ·).Aieppo ·pine ---l1s -· l Fair ---· 110120114 --Remove /Grading ---
51s ·!1nceose cedar ----\8 iFair ·-110/20/14 --;Remove :Grading --
511 ~nceiisecedar --;! -:Poor ·-h-0120H4 -1 Aernow --;Graaiiig ·--
520 t"Aieppopfne ;9 --)!=afr -ho!i6/14 --(Reioove· '.·Grading --------------
t
521 iA1eppo pme :13 '.Fair --pID:!0114 -:Remove -.Graainf -
s22 !Aleppo i>ine · :9 --'.Poor --:1ow11"4 -'~emow 'Grading ·
1
525 :Aleppo pine · ho :Fair · -\fot2ClJf4 · -Remove :(lrailing
1,21 · if license ·cec1ar· 17 ----: Fair --: 107l0fl 4 -Remove -'Grading
!s21 \incense cec1"ar ·1s ---'Poor --!10r.10114 --'Remove ·-\~rad1riQ ·
s21 ·:7'1eppc) pr1e -· 11 Poor · '.101201n -:·Remove :<lrailing
I ' . I -!~ --·---· · :·n :-F~oor -ifOl'i<l714 · iffemow ,, __ :Griifng -
:
2
-·:.~-·~--~7_;:_~~ ·h3 Fafr ---·horio,14 _;"Re"'inoiie :Grading"
53 : -pine '11 -·'Fair -\10/20/14 -·-Remove -;Grading -
534 1A1eppopine \1s ·--'Fair --1101"2011.:f ,Remove -··:Grading --
544· 1_v-y oak : H> il:xi:eleiit /11081'13 -'. Preserve '.Siwriily Damaged by"Gniding anif/:ietafning
l54s ;eoast Uve oak
1546 iCoasf live oak
1511 \'aley·oak
!sn jwildplum
572 ; Momerey cypress
~~~iks ~a<:ro<:~! 573 'w-,;;;y08
' ,574 Incense cedar
575 ;Souitiem magnolia
·~agnolla grandlflora
576 Coast live oak
is11 ·cypress I 'C~pressus ~ies
578 :Coast live oak
I ' I• Valleyoak
1590 Monterey pine
I' 591 Valley oak
1592 Coastliveoak
~-~-
Prepared .,. Mlcllail Beach
Ceualtin& Arborist
' Wall Construction
:5 '.Good ·-i1~13 ,Preserve 'seiierelybamage<ibyGradirigaridRetaining
, Wal Construction
: 12 ·Good / 1Ot8i/14 Preserve -Severely-Damaged by Grading and Retafnirig
\ WaU Consl'uction
118 'Good '.10/20714 -'.Preserve 'RoadQ>nstruction • Moderate Impact ---
\e· --.0eitc:i ;H>ti0114 -· ;F~emove Jloaciwayeoiistruciion
' I :7 'excellent ·10/20714 Preserve ·RoadwayCorisirudiori
Giiod '10/11/12
'.Excellent ;10111112
'Good --!10!l0/14
i
'Good/Fair (10i'20/14
' ~Good/Fair '10/20114
[
:excellent !10/11/12
"Fair :10/20/14
:40 :Fair .10/20/14
' :33 Fair 10/'l0/14
,32 'Good ;10/20/14
:Trarisplait
. Transplant
'Preserw
Preserve
: Presel'\/9
Transplant
Remowi
Preserve
Preserve
:Preserve
Ro.idway ConstriJction
Aoadway"Constn.iction
'Roadway Constrlietion
'Roadway Constructlon ·
Roadway Construction
Grading for Retention Pond
_Sanitary Sewer Construction
:Retention Pond Cohstruciion-Low Impact
Retenion Pond Construction-l.Ow Impact
'Grading for Pond-Moderate
Los Gatw, Califoraia
October 21, 2114
Surrey Farm Emtes
1soa · fCoasfnve oaK
rsM ·frncense ceclar ·---·
1595 11:uropean··or.ve· --·-,.
Prepared by Michail Balch
Con,altin& Arboriat
Impacts to Trees
ByPropoled
Plus A-1 ud A-lA
Los G1to1, Clllifornia
October 20, 2014