Loading...
Item 5 - Staff Report and Attachments 1 to 3PREPARED BY: SEAN MULLIN, AICP Senior Planner 110 E. Main Street Los Gatos, CA 95030 ● 408-354-6874 www.losgatosca.gov TOWN OF LOS GATOS HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMITTEE REPORT MEETING DATE: 08/24/2022 ITEM NO: 5 DATE: August 19, 2022 TO: Historic Preservation Committee FROM: Joel Paulson, Community Development Director SUBJECT: Forward a Recommendation to the Community Development Director on a Request for Variances to the Accessory Structure Lot Coverage Standard and to the Side and Rear Setback Requirements for a Detached Accessory Structure on Property Located in the University-Edelen Historic District Zoned R-1D:LHP. Located at 202 University Avenue. APN 529-04-001. Variance Application V-22-003. Property Owner: Tyler and Kristine Shewey. Applicant: Jay Plett, Architect. Project Planner: Sean Mullin. RECOMMENDATION: Forward a recommendation to the Community Development Director on a request for Variances to the accessory structure lot coverage standard and to the side and rear setback requirements for a detached accessory structure on property located in the University-Edelen Historic District zoned R-1D:LHP located at 202 University Avenue. PROPERTY DETAILS: 1.Date primary structure was built: 1898 (effective year built 1930) per County Assessor’s Database; 1870s per Bloomfield Survey 2.Town of Los Gatos Historic Status Code: +, historic and intact, worthy of special note 3.Does property have an LHP Overlay? Yes 4.Is structure in a historic district? Yes, University-Edelen 5.If yes, is it a contributor? Yes 6.Findings required? No 7.Considerations required? Yes BACKGROUND: On July 28, 2021, the Committee considered a request for construction of a second-story addition to the main residence to exceed floor area ratio standards and for construction of a detached garage with reduced side and rear setbacks of three feet where five feet is required PAGE 2 OF 4 SUBJECT: 202 University Avenue/V-22-003 DATE: August 19, 2022 N:\DEV\HISTORIC PRESERVATION\HPC Reports and Attachments\2022\08-24-22\Item 05 - 202 University Avenue\Staff Report.202 University Avenue.docx BACKGROUND (continued): by the Town Code. The Committee forwarded a recommendation of approval to the Community Development Director and the application was subsequently approved by the Planning Commission on January 26, 2022. The applicant has revised the location and dimensions of the detached garage to further preserve the viewsheds of neighboring properties (Attachment 3). The revised proposal requires approval of a Variance to the accessory structure lot coverage standards of the Town Code and a Variance for a side setback of one foot and a rear setback of one and one-half feet where five feet is required. The development plans for the revised project include a second-story accessory dwelling unit (ADU) above the proposed garage. State regulations and the Town’s ADU Ordinance allow second-story ADUs to be constructed above detached accessory structures on a property with a two-story primary residence with a ministerial review through an ADU permit. The Committee’s review must focus on the lower-level garage and may not consider the ADU. DISCUSSION: The design of the proposed garage is consistent with the previously approved garage and would match the residence in form, materials, and details. Exterior materials include a composition roof, horizontal and vertical wood siding, wood garage doors, and detailing to match the residence. As discussed in the Letter of Justification included as Attachment 1, the applicant has revised the location and dimensions of the detached garage in coordination with their neighbors in order to further preserve the viewsheds of neighboring properties The proposed detached garage requires Variances to the accessory structure lot coverage standards and side and rear setbacks. The size of the proposed garage exceeds the allowable lot coverage for accessory structures, which is limited to 15 percent of the lot area exclusive of the required setbacks. The subject property allows for a maximum of 485 square feet of accessory structures, where the proposed garage is 518 square feet. Additionally, the proposed garage would have a side setback of one foot and a rear setback of one and one-half feet where five feet is required. The applicant has provided a Neighborhood Plan showing how the reduced setbacks for the proposed detached garage are compatible with other properties in the immediate neighborhood (Attachment 3, Sheet NP-1). The applicant’s Letter of Justification discusses how granting of the Variances would allow for development that is consistent with the neighborhood pattern and similar to other detached accessory structures enjoyed by property owners in the vicinity (Attachment 1). PAGE 3 OF 4 SUBJECT: 202 University Avenue/V-22-003 DATE: August 19, 2022 N:\DEV\HISTORIC PRESERVATION\HPC Reports and Attachments\2022\08-24-22\Item 05 - 202 University Avenue\Staff Report.202 University Avenue.docx DISCUSSION (continued): When making their recommendation, the Committee should consider whether the proposed accessory structure lot coverage and the reduced setbacks for the detached garage are compatible with the neighborhood and consistent with the Residential Design Guidelines. CONCLUSION: Should the Committee find merit in the proposed project, it should make the following findings and considerations and make a recommendation of approval to the Community Development Director. FINDINGS AND CONSIDERATIONS: A. Findings Sec. 29.20.165. Variances. The deciding body, on the basis of the evidence submitted at the hearing, may grant a variance if it finds that: 1. Because of special circumstances applicable to the property, including size, shape, topography, location or surroundings, the strict application of this ordinance deprives such property of privileges enjoyed by other property in the vicinity and under identical zone; and 2. The granting of a variance would not constitute a grant of special privileges inconsistent with the limitations upon other properties in the vicinity and zone in which such property is situated. B. Considerations Sec. 29.80.290. Standards for review. In evaluating applications, the deciding body shall consider the architectural style, design, arrangement, texture, materials and color, and any other pertinent factors. Applications shall not be granted unless: In Historic Districts, the proposed work will neither adversely affect the exterior architectural characteristics or other features of the property, which is the subject of the application, nor adversely affect its relationship, in terms of harmony and appropriateness, with its surroundings, including neighboring structures, nor adversely affect the character, or the historical, architectural, or aesthetic interest or value of the district. PAGE 4 OF 4 SUBJECT: 202 University Avenue/V-22-003 DATE: August 19, 2022 N:\DEV\HISTORIC PRESERVATION\HPC Reports and Attachments\2022\08-24-22\Item 05 - 202 University Avenue\Staff Report.202 University Avenue.docx FINDINGS AND CONSIDERATIONS (continued): C. Residential Design Guidelines Section 4.9 of the Town’s Residential Design Guidelines offers recommendations for accessory structures through reference to Section 3.9 (Attachment 2). ATTACHMENTS: 1. Letter of Justification 2. Section 3.9, Residential Design Guidelines 3. Development Plans JA/FLEET SHEWEY ADU202 UNIVERSITY AVENUELOS GATOS, CA 95030 PROJECT DESCRIPTION/JUSTIFICATION TO: Town of Los GatosFROM: Jay Plett Architect The architecture is in the Italianate style, matching its companion Main House. This project has been designed and situated on the Site with significant input from the two adjacent neighbors, requiring a variance to preserve the neighbor's light and view corridors to the hills as much possible. Granting a variance would be consistent with the existing neighborhood patterns. Within the immediate neighborhood there are : 9 Garages with smaller SySb's5 Garages with smaller RySb's2 Garages have larger FAR's1 Garage has larger area (880) sf Reference Sheet NP-1 of the Architectural drawings. Being a corner parcel, the property's net site area compromises it's allowable detached Garage area as compared to interior parcels of the same size and shape. * Allowed Garage by Net Site Area is 485 sf * An interior parcel of identicalsize would have a Net Site Areaallowance for a Garage of 537 sf * The proposed detached Garage is 518 sf In addition, the requested detached Garage area is required by Architectural aesthetic necessity to blend harmoniously with the planned, moderately sized ADU above it. ATTACHMENT 1 This Page Intentionally Left Blank Residential Design Guidelines 33 Town of Los Gatos BUILDING DESIGN3 3.8.3 Use traditional detailing •Treat openings in walls as though they were constructed of the traditional material for the style. For example, be sure to provide substantial wall space above arches in stucco and stone walls. Traditionally, wall space above the arch would have been necessary to structurally span the opening, and to make the space too small is inconsistent with the archi- tectural style. •Openings in walls faced with stone, real or synthetic, should have defined lintels above the opening except in Mission or Spanish Eclectic styles. Lintels may be stone, brick or wood as suits the style of the house. •Treat synthetic materials as though they were authentic. For example, select synthetic stone patterns that place the individual stones in a horizontal plane as they would have been in a load bearing masonry wall. •Select roof materials that are consistent with the traditional architectural style (e.g., avoid concrete roof tiles on a Crafts- man Style house.) 3.8.4 Materials changes •Make materials and color changes at inside corners rather than outside corners to avoid a pasted on look. 3.9 ADDITIONS/ACCESSORY BUILDINGS/SECONDARY UNITS •Site additions in the least conspicuous place. In many cases this is a rear or side elevation - only rarely is it a rooftop. •The existing built forms, components and materials should be reinforced. Heights and proportions of additions and alterations should be consistent with and continue the original architectural style and design. •Additions should be subordinate, and compatible in scale and proportion to the historically significant portions of the existing structure. •When an addition or remodel requires the use of newly constructed exterior elements, they should be identical in size, dimension, shape and location as the original, and Use stone or wood lintels over openings in stone walls Additions, accessory buildings and secondary units should match the form, architectural style, and details of the original house ATTACHMENT 2 Residential Design Guidelines34 Town of Los Gatos BUILDING DESIGN3 should utilize the same materials as the existing protected exterior elements. • When an addition necessitates the removal of architectural materials, such as siding, windows, doors, and decorative elements, they should be carefully removed and reused in the addition where possible. • The introduction of window and door openings not char- acteristic in proportion, scale, or style with the original architecture is strongly discouraged (e.g., sliding windows or doors in a structure characterized by double hung windows and swinging doors). • The character of any addition or alteration should be in keeping with and subordinate to the integrity of the original structure. • The amount of foundation exposed on the addition should match that of the original building. • Do not add roof top additions where the roof is of historic significance. • Second floor additions are discouraged in neighborhoods with largely one story homes. If horizontal expansion of the house is not possible, consider incorporating a second floor addition within the roof form as shown in the example to the left. • Second floor additions which are not embedded within the roof form should be located to the rear of the structure. • The height and proportion of an addition or a second story should not dominate the original structure. • Deck additions should be placed to the rear of the struc- ture only, and should be subordinate in terms of scale and detailing. • New outbuildings, such as garages, should be clearly subor- dinate to the main structure in massing, and should utilize forms, materials and details which are similar to the main structure. • Garages should generally be located to the rear of the lot behind the rear wall of the residence. One car wide access driveways should be utilized. Original structure Addition incorporated into the roof successfully adds space while respecting the integrity of the existing house and the scale of the neighborhood Placing a two story addition to the rear can minimize its impact on the historic resource and the scale of the neighborhood nbr wdw nbr wdw nbr kit. wdw PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL 9'-2" +/- EXISTINGNEIGHBOR GARAGE FIRE RATED WDWS THIS WALL RECESSED CLERESTORY WDW CLERESTORY WINDOW VERTICAL WOOD SIDING WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE 24' - 4" +/- MAX HGT COMP ROOF TO MATCH HOUSE VERTICAL WOOD SIDING JULIET BALCONIES WOOD GARAGE DOORS EAVE DETAILING TO MATCH HOUSE HORIZONTAL WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE ADU ENTRY 72 miles av.residence210 university ave garage (E) TOWN STREET TREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN(s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110.00') ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES TO B E M O V E D A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATEDA/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W/ FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT AT MILES & EDELEN FIRE H Y D R A N T ON GR E Y S L N MID BL O C K CONSTRUCT A (N) DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HANDCITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED XXXXXXXXXXTPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0"72 miles av.residence210 university ave garage (E) TOWN STREET TREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN (s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c) s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c) (s 6 5 °35'47" e ) ( a ) ( 1 1 0 . 0 0 ' ) ( c ) line o f ( E ) s y s b 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY W I R E S T O BE M O V E D A/C MILES A V .UNIVERSITY AV. UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATED A/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED 1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W / FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE H Y D R A N T A T MILES & E D E L E N FIRE H Y D R A N T ON G R E Y S L N MID B L O C K CONSTRUCT A ( N ) DRIVEWAY A P R O N (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HAND CITY SEWER LINE 17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED X X X X X XX X X X TPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0" neighbor house 210 university nbr wdw fence neighbor house 72 miles neighbor house 72 miles neighbor garage 210 university NEIGHBOR VIEW SHEDNEIGHBORVIEW SHED NEIGHBOR VIEW SHED NEIGHBORVIEW SHED 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreen 18" sycamore 12"evergreen 18"evergreen 12" evergreenDRIVEWAY DRIVEWAY SHEWEY ADU7.12.22 A-1 SITE PLAN 1/8" = 1'-0" PROJECT DESCRIPTION PROJECT DESCRIPTION new detached garage WITH REDUCED SIDE AND REAR SET BACKS OWNERSOWNERS tYLER & KRISTINE SHEWEY 202 UNIVERSITY AVE los gatos, ca 95030 PHONE: 408.834.5983 EMAIL: TASHEWEY@SBCGLOBAL.NET SITE PARTICULARSSITE PARTICULARS APN 529-04-001 ZONING R-1 D LHP AREA SUMMARY AREA SUMMARY SITE 6380 SF NET SITE AREA 3234/485 SF corner lot NET SITE AREA 3581/537 SF interior lot garage allowed 485 sf corner lot garage allowed 537 sf interior lot proposed garage 518 sf adu 603 sf ATTACHMENT 3 PROJECT HOUSE PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PLPLPL PL PLPL PL PLPL 20 2 21 0 216 72 68 GA R A G E 12 8 G A R . A. D . U 12 3 G A R . 20 1 20 5 20 9 215 217 G A R . G A R . SH E D UNIVERSITY AVEMI L E S A V E G R A Y S L N 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE216 UNIVERSITY AVE 72 MILES AVE 68 MILES AVE university ave looking at the project MILES ave looking at the project MILES ave looking ACROSS the project 129 EDELEN AVE (house across the street, Height similar to project house) 128 UNIVERSITY AVE 126 UNIVERSITY AVE university ave looking across the project 123 UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE 205 UNIVERSITY AVE 209 UNIVERSITY AVE 215 UNIVERSITY AVE 217 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE PROJECT MILES AVE UNIVERSITY AVE EDELEN AVE GA R . EDELEN AVE 128 UNIVERSITY AVE UNIVERSITY AVE GRAYS LN A. D . U 19'-0" +/- 216 UNIVERSITY AVE 23'-0" +/- 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE 128 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE 30'-0" +/- 25'-0" +/- 126 UNIVERSITY AVE68 MILES AVE 30'-0" +/-27'-0" +/- 72 MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE 202 university AVE 28'-6" +/-28'-6" +/- P R O J E C T GA R A G E 30'-0" +/- 201 university AVE G A R . grays ln miles ave 23' - 9" +/- GA R A G E GA R A G E project site PROJECT HOUSE PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPL PL PLPL PL PLPL 20 2 21 0 21 6 72 68 GA R A G E 12 8 G A R . A. D . U 12 3 G A R . 20 1 20 5 20 9 215 217 G A R . G A R . SH E D UNIVERSITY AVEMI L E S A V E G R A Y S L N 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE216 UNIVERSITY AVE 72 MILES AVE 68 MILES AVE university ave looking at the project MILES ave looking at the project MILES ave looking ACROSS the project 129 EDELEN AVE (house across the street, Height similar to project house) 128 UNIVERSITY AVE 126 UNIVERSITY AVE university ave looking across the project 123 UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE 205 UNIVERSITY AVE 209 UNIVERSITY AVE 215 UNIVERSITY AVE 217 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE PROJECT MILES AVE UNIVERSITY AVE EDELEN AVE GA R . EDELEN AVE 128 UNIVERSITY AVE UNIVERSITY AVE GRAYS LN A. D . U 19'-0" +/- 216 UNIVERSITY AVE 23'-0" +/- 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE128 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE30'-0" +/- 25'-0" +/- 126 UNIVERSITY AVE68 MILES AVE 30'-0" +/-27'-0" +/- 72 MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE 202 university AVE 28'-6" +/-28'-6" +/- P R O J E C T G A R A G E 30'-0" +/- 201 university AVE G A R . grays ln miles ave 23' - 9" +/- G A R A G E G A R A G E project site PROJECT HOUSE PLPLPLPL PLPL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPL PL PLPL PL PLPL 20 2 21 0 21 6 72 68 GA R A G E 12 8 G A R . A. D . U 12 3 G A R . 20 1 20 5 20 9 215 217 G A R . G A R . SH E D UNIVERSITY AVEMI L E S A V E G R A Y S L N 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE216 UNIVERSITY AVE 72 MILES AVE 68 MILES AVE university ave looking at the project MILES ave looking at the project MILES ave looking ACROSS the project 129 EDELEN AVE (house across the street, Height similar to project house) 128 UNIVERSITY AVE126 UNIVERSITY AVE university ave looking across the project 123 UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE 205 UNIVERSITY AVE 209 UNIVERSITY AVE 215 UNIVERSITY AVE 217 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE PROJECT MILES AVE UNIVERSITY AVE EDELEN AVE GA R . EDELEN AVE 128 UNIVERSITY AVE UNIVERSITY AVE GRAYS LN A. D . U 19'-0" +/- 216 UNIVERSITY AVE 23'-0" +/- 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE128 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE30'-0" +/- 25'-0" +/- 126 UNIVERSITY AVE68 MILES AVE 30'-0" +/-27'-0" +/- 72 MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE 202 university AVE 28'-6" +/-28'-6" +/- P R O J E C T G A R A G E 30'-0" +/- 201 university AVE G A R . grays ln miles ave 23' - 9" +/- G A R A G E G A R A G E project site PROJECT HOUSE PLPLPLPL PLPLPLPLPLPL PLPLPL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPL PL PLPL PL PLPL 20 2 21 0 21 6 72 68 GA R A G E 12 8 G A R . A. D . U 12 3 G A R . 20 1 20 5 20 9 215 217 G A R . G A R . SH E D UNIVERSITY AVEMI L E S A V E G R A Y S L N 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE216 UNIVERSITY AVE72 MILES AVE68 MILES AVE university ave looking at the project MILES ave looking at the project MILES ave looking ACROSS the project 129 EDELEN AVE (house across the street, Height similar to project house) 128 UNIVERSITY AVE126 UNIVERSITY AVE university ave looking across the project 123 UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE 205 UNIVERSITY AVE 209 UNIVERSITY AVE 215 UNIVERSITY AVE 217 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE PROJECT MILES AVE UNIVERSITY AVEEDELEN AVE GA R . EDELEN AVE 128 UNIVERSITY AVE UNIVERSITY AVE GRAYS LN A. D . U 19'-0" +/- 216 UNIVERSITY AVE 23'-0" +/- 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE128 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE30'-0" +/- 25'-0" +/- 126 UNIVERSITY AVE68 MILES AVE 30'-0" +/-27'-0" +/- 72 MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE202 university AVE 28'-6" +/-28'-6" +/- P R O J E C T G A R A G E 30'-0" +/- 201 university AVE G A R . grays lnmiles ave 23' - 9" +/- G A R A G E G A R A G E project site NEIGHBORHOOD PLAN 1" = 50' UNIVERSITY AVE LOOKING ACROSS FROM PROJECT 1/16" = 1'-0" UNIVERSITY AVE LOOKING AT PROJECT 1/16" = 1'-0" MILES AVE LOOKING AT PROJECT 1/16" = 1'-0" MILES AVE LOOKING ACROSS FROM PROJECT 1/16" = 1'-0" SETBACK & FAR COMPARISONS SHEWEY RESIDENCEREMODEL & ADDITION202 UNIVERSITY AV.06.30.22 NP-1 EXISTING NEIGHBORHOOD GARAGE CONDITIONS EXISTING NEIGHBORHOOD GARAGE CONDITIONS ADDRESS SIZE (SF) SIDE SB (F) REAR SB (F) LOT SIZE (SF) FAR 123 UNIVERSITY AVE 400 +/- 0 1 4949 0.081 126 UNIVERSITY AVE 240 +/- 0 0 4070 0.059 128 UNIVERSITY AVE 360 0 0 6490 0.055 201 UNIVERSITY AVE 420 3 3 5566 0.075 205 UNIVERSITY AVE 284 1 6 5550 0.051 209 UNIVERSITY AVE 441 5 6 5550 0.079 210 UNIVERSITY AVE 216 2 3 5830 0.037 215 UNIVERSITY AVE 360 +/- 0 0 5566 0.065 216 UNIVERSITY AVE 160 0 0 5995 0.027 217 UNIVERSITY AVE 0 N/A N/A 3673 N/A 129 EDELEN AVE 880 0 0 10560 0.083 68 MILES AVE 412 3 3 4260 0.097 72 MILES AVE 240 +/- 0 20+3400 0.071 PROPOSED GARAGE PROPOSED GARAGE 202 UNIVERISTY AVE 518 1'- 6" 1'- 0"6380 0.081 ANALYSIS ANALYSIS * 9 NEIGHBORHOOD GARAGES HAVE SMALLER SIDE YARD SETBACKS ** 5 NEIGHBORHOOD GARAGES HAVE SMALLER REAR YARD SETBACKS AND 1 IS THE SAME *** 2 NEIGHBORHOOD GARAGES HAVE LARGER FARS AND 3 ARE THE SAME/SIMILAR PROJECT HOUSE PLPLPLPL PLPLPLPLPL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PLPLPLPLPLPLPLPLPL PL PLPL PL PLPL 20 2 21 0 21 6 72 68 GA R A G E 12 8 G A R . A. D . U 12 3 G A R . 20 1 20 5 20 9 215 217 G A R . G A R . SH E D UNIVERSITY AVEMI L E S A V E G R A Y S L N 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE216 UNIVERSITY AVE72 MILES AVE68 MILES AVE university ave looking at the project MILES ave looking at the project MILES ave looking ACROSS the project 129 EDELEN AVE (house across the street, Height similar to project house) 128 UNIVERSITY AVE126 UNIVERSITY AVE university ave looking across the project 123 UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE 205 UNIVERSITY AVE 209 UNIVERSITY AVE 215 UNIVERSITY AVE 217 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE PROJECT MILES AVE UNIVERSITY AVE EDELEN AVE GA R . EDELEN AVE 128 UNIVERSITY AVE UNIVERSITY AVE GRAYS LN A. D . U 19'-0" +/- 216 UNIVERSITY AVE 23'-0" +/- 202 UNIVERSITY AVE210 UNIVERSITY AVE128 UNIVERSITY AVEINTERSECTION OF UNIVERSITY AND MILES AVE MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE30'-0" +/- 25'-0" +/- 126 UNIVERSITY AVE68 MILES AVE 30'-0" +/-27'-0" +/- 72 MILES AVE PROJECT HOUSE UNIVERSITY AVE 201 UNIVERSITY AVE202 university AVE 28'-6" +/-28'-6" +/- P R O J E C T G A R A G E 30'-0" +/- 201 university AVE G A R . grays lnmiles ave 23' - 9" +/- G A R A G E G A R A G E project site SHEWEY ADUgarage plan 1/4" = 1'-0" A-2 7.12.22 nbr wdw nbr wdw nbr kit. wdw PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL NEIGHBOR GARAGE FIRE RATED WDWS THIS WALL RECESSED CLERESTORY WDW CLERESTORY WINDOW VERTICAL WOOD SIDING WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE 24' - 4" +/- MAX HGT COMP ROOF TO MATCH HOUSE VERTICAL WOOD SIDING JULIET BALCONIES WOOD GARAGE DOORS EAVE DETAILING TO MATCH HOUSE HORIZONTAL WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE ADU ENTRY 72 miles av.residence210 university ave garage (E) TOWN STREET TREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN(s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110.00' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES TO B E M O V E D A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATEDA/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W/ FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT AT MILES & EDELEN FIRE H Y D R A N T ON GR E Y S L N MID BL O C K CONSTRUCT A (N) DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HANDCITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED XXXXXXXXXXTPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0"72 miles av.residence210 university ave garage (E) TOWN STREET TREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN (s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110. 0 0 ' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES T O BE MOVED A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATED A/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W / FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT AT MILES & EDELEN FIRE H Y D R A N T ON GR E Y S L N MID B L O C K CONSTRUCT A (N) DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HAND CITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED X X X X X XX X X X TPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0" neighbor house 210 university nbr wdw fence neighbor house 72 miles neighbor house 72 miles neighbor garage 210 university NEIGHBOR VIEW SHEDNEIGHBORVIEW SHED NEIGHBOR VIEW SHED NEIGHBORVIEW SHED 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreen 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreenDRIVEWAY DRIVEWAYSHEWEY ADUroof plan 1/4" = 1'-0" A-3 UPSTAIRS plan 1/4" = 1'-0" 7.12.22 nbr wdw nbr wdw nbr kit. wdw PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL NEIGHBOR GARAGE FIRE RATED WDWS THIS WALL RECESSED CLERESTORY WDW CLERESTORY WINDOW VERTICAL WOOD SIDING WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE 24' - 4" +/-MAX HGT COMP ROOF TOMATCH HOUSE VERTICAL WOOD SIDING JULIET BALCONIES WOOD GARAGE DOORS EAVE DETAILING TO MATCH HOUSE HORIZONTAL WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE ADU ENTRY 72 miles av.residence210 universityave garage (E) TOWN STREET TREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN(s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110.00' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES TO B E M O V E D A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATEDA/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0"1'-6" (N) GARAGE W/ FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELECMETERTO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT AT MILES & EDELEN FIRE H Y D R A N T ON GR E Y S L N MID BL O C K CONSTRUCT A (N) DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HANDCITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED XXXXXXXXXXTPZ II TREEPROTECTIONZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0"72 miles av.residence210 university ave garage (E) TOWN STREETTREES TO REMAINAND BE MAINTAINEDBY TOWN (s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110. 0 0 ' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BEREMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES TOBE MOVED A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATED A/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W / FUTURE ADU OVER POWERPOLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT ATMILES & EDELEN FIRE HYDRANTON GREYS LNMID BLOCKCONSTRUCT A (N)DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HAND CITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED X X X X X XX X X X TPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0" neighbor house 210 university nbr wdw fence neighborhouse72 miles neighbor house 72 miles neighbor garage 210 university NEIGHBOR VIEW SHEDNEIGHBORVIEW SHED NEIGHBOR VIEW SHED NEIGHBORVIEW SHED 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreen 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreenDRIVEWAY DRIVEWAY nbr wdw nbr wdw nbr kit. wdw PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL NEIGHBOR GARAGE FIRE RATED WDWS THIS WALL RECESSED CLERESTORY WDW CLERESTORY WINDOW VERTICAL WOOD SIDING WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE 24' - 4" +/-MAX HGT COMP ROOF TOMATCH HOUSE VERTICAL WOOD SIDING JULIET BALCONIES WOOD GARAGE DOORS EAVE DETAILING TO MATCH HOUSE HORIZONTAL WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE ADU ENTRY 72 miles av.residence210 universityave garage (E) TOWN STREET TREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN(s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110.00' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES TO B E M O V E D A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATEDA/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0"1'-6" (N) GARAGE W/ FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELECMETERTO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT AT MILES & EDELEN FIRE H Y D R A N T ON GR E Y S L N MID BL O C K CONSTRUCT A (N) DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HANDCITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED XXXXXXXXXXTPZ II TREEPROTECTIONZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0"72 miles av.residence210 university ave garage (E) TOWN STREETTREES TO REMAINAND BE MAINTAINEDBY TOWN (s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110. 0 0 ' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BEREMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES TOBE MOVED A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATED A/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W / FUTURE ADU OVER POWERPOLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT ATMILES & EDELEN FIRE HYDRANTON GREYS LNMID BLOCKCONSTRUCT A (N)DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HAND CITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED X X X X X XX X X X TPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREEPROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0" neighbor house 210 university nbr wdw fence neighborhouse72 miles neighbor house 72 miles neighbor garage 210 university NEIGHBOR VIEW SHEDNEIGHBORVIEW SHED NEIGHBOR VIEW SHED NEIGHBORVIEW SHED 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreen 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreenDRIVEWAY DRIVEWAY nbr wdw nbr wdw nbr kit. wdw PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL NEIGHBOR GARAGE FIRE RATED WDWS THIS WALL RECESSED CLERESTORY WDW CLERESTORY WINDOW VERTICAL WOOD SIDING WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE 24' - 4" +/- MAX HGT COMP ROOF TO MATCH HOUSE VERTICAL WOOD SIDING JULIET BALCONIES WOOD GARAGE DOORS EAVE DETAILING TO MATCH HOUSE HORIZONTAL WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE ADU ENTRY 72 miles av.residence210 universityave garage (E) TOWN STREET TREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN(s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110.00' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES TO B E M O V E D A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATEDA/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W/ FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT AT MILES & EDELEN FIRE H Y D R A N T ON GR E Y S L N MID BL O C K CONSTRUCT A (N) DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HANDCITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED XXXXXXXXXXTPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0"72 miles av.residence210 university ave garage (E) TOWN STREETTREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN (s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110. 0 0 ' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES T O BE MOVED A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATED A/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W / FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT ATMILES & EDELEN FIRE H Y D R A N T ON GR E Y S L N MID B L O C K CONSTRUCT A (N)DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HAND CITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED X X X X X XX X X X TPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0" neighbor house 210 university nbr wdw fence neighbor house 72 miles neighbor house 72 miles neighbor garage 210 university NEIGHBOR VIEW SHEDNEIGHBORVIEW SHED NEIGHBOR VIEW SHED NEIGHBORVIEW SHED 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreen 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreenDRIVEWAY DRIVEWAY nbr wdw nbr wdw nbr kit. wdw PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL PL NEIGHBOR GARAGE FIRE RATED WDWS THIS WALL RECESSED CLERESTORY WDW CLERESTORY WINDOW VERTICAL WOOD SIDING WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE 24' - 4" +/- MAX HGT COMP ROOF TO MATCH HOUSE VERTICAL WOOD SIDING JULIET BALCONIES WOOD GARAGE DOORS EAVE DETAILING TO MATCH HOUSE HORIZONTAL WOOD SIDING TO MATCH HOUSE ADU ENTRY 72 miles av.residence210 universityave garage (E) TOWN STREET TREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN(s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110.00' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES TO B E M O V E D A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATEDA/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W/ FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT AT MILES & EDELEN FIRE H Y D R A N T ON GR E Y S L N MID BL O C K CONSTRUCT A (N) DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HANDCITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED XXXXXXXXXXTPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0"72 miles av.residence210 university ave garage (E) TOWN STREET TREES TO REMAIN AND BE MAINTAINED BY TOWN (s 21°10'00" w 55.00') (c)s 68°46'42" e 109.82' (109.82') (c)(s 21°10'00"61.20') (c)(s 65°35'47" e) (a) (110. 0 0 ' ) ( c ) line of (E) sysb 30" FIR 12" sycamore 12" sycamore (e) tree to be removed (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED (E) TREE TO BE REMOVED WM (E) GAS METER TO REMAIN ELEC GUY WIRES T O BE MOVED A/C MILES AV.UNIVERSITY AV.UPGRADE TO 200A RELOCATED A/C NEW PRIMARY RESIDENCE N/C PROPOSED1'-0" 1'-6" (N) GARAGE W / FUTURE ADU OVER POWER POLE (E) ELEC METER TO REMAIN (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E 6' FENCE TO TERMINATE AT BUILDING CORNER AS DRAWN FIRE HYDRANT ATMILES & EDELEN FIRE H Y D R A N T ON GR E Y S L N MID BL O C K CONSTRUCT A (N)DRIVEWAY APRON (E) W (E) S (E) G (E) UG E (n) concrete DRIVEWAY excavation within 15' of trees TO BE DONE BY HAND CITY SEWER LINE17'-0" +/- EXISTING N/C PROPOSED X X X X X XX X X X TPZ II TREE PROTECTION ZONE FENCING TPZ III TREE PROTECTION WRAP. typ. LIGHTWELL 2'-0" neighbor house 210 university nbr wdw fence neighbor house 72 miles neighbor house 72 miles neighbor garage 210 university NEIGHBOR VIEW SHEDNEIGHBORVIEW SHED NEIGHBOR VIEW SHED NEIGHBORVIEW SHED 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreen 18" sycamore 12" evergreen 18" evergreen 12" evergreenDRIVEWAY DRIVEWAY SHEWEY ADUEAST SOUTH (FROM MILES AV) NORTH WEST ELEVATIONS 1/4" = 1'-0"A-4 7.12.22 This Page Intentionally Left Blank