Loading...
scanner@losgatosca.gov_20100729_162335`°W" °F, TOWN OF LOS GATOS ~•~•~~ PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT ~°S•GA~os Meeting Date: June 23, 2010 PREPARED BY: Wendie Rooney Community Development Director APPLICATION NO.: Draft 2020 General Plan LOCATION: N/A APPLICANT: Town of Los Gatos PROPERTY OWNERS: N/A ITEM NO: 1 DESK ITEM #1 APPLICATION SUMMARY: Los Gatos 2020 General Plan and Final Enviromnental Impact Report on the Los Gatos 2020 General Plan Update. ATTACHMENTS: 1. List of Goals, Policies and Strategies from the 2000 General Plan that were not carried forward into the draft 2020 General Plan 2. North 40 Specific Plan Overlay Revised Language REMARKS This desk item contains two documents that were inadvertently left out of the Planning Commission Agenda packet distributed for the June 23, 2010, Planning Commission meeting and provides additional information and/or makes corrections to four of the comments on the General Plan Comment Matrix. Attachment 1 is the list of Goals, Policies and Strategies from the 2000 General Plan that were not carried forward into the draft 2020 General Plan. These recommended changes are based on the Town Council's direction to refine or eliminate Goals, Policies and Actions or Strategies from the 2000 General Plan that may not be serving the community as intended, lacked clarity, are no longer current, or have been completed. The table contains the 2000 General Plan Number; the Goal, Policy or Action language; and the explanation for not carrying it forward to the 2020 General Plan. The majority of the changes were due to either duplicative or redundant Goals, Policies or Actions. This table was routed to the General Plan Update Advisory Committee (GPAC) as an informational item. The GPAC was offered the opportunity to ask any questions on the table, but did not discuss it. Attachment 2 contains an edited copy of the North 40 Specific Plan Overlay language that is contained on in the Land Use Element on Page LU-16 of the draft 2020 General Plan. The GPAC discussed the North 40 Specific Plan Overlay language at the May 20, 2010, GPAC IOI -Attachment 1 Planning Commission Staff Report -Page 2 Los Gatos 2020 General Plan and FEIR Report June 23, 2010 meeting. The North 40 Specific Plan Overlay language is included in the section that describes the Town's land use designations and overlays zones. Staff informed the Commmittee that the description and development capacities for the North 40 property were included in the General Plan to help guide the future development of a specific plan. The General Plan overlay designation requires the preparation of a specific plan prior to development of the property. The development capacities were established to allow for a programmatic environment assessment of the potential impacts from the development of the property. Committee members discussed whether the language was too specific and would be duplicative with the Specific Plan that will be prepared and adopted prior to development of the property. The committee ultimately requested that staff suggest revisions to the overlay language to clarify that the principles or guidelines are to be used as the foundation for the future specific plan. Suggested new and deleted text is in underlined and strilcethrough format, respectively. Included in the Planning Commission Agenda packet is a document entitled "Los Gatos 2020 General Plan Coinlnents." The Comment Matrix contains all the outside agency, public and Town Commission and Committee comments that have been received since the release of the draft General Plan in March. Generally the Matrix does not include GPAC comments, since their input has been incorporated into the red-line draft Elements in the Planning Commission agenda packet. Four of the comments and staff and consultant recommendations require further clarification or changes. These clarifications or changes .are as follows; Page 2, Comment No. 5: The Staff/Consultant Recommendation states that "Staff also recommends deleting "g." This recommendation was based on the concern that the Town lacked the resources for providing low cost loans. Staff recently was made aware that Santa Clara County is considering creating a County AB 811 Program Financing District, which may result in low cost loans or grants for energy efficiency retrofit to homes. Consequently, staff recommends leaving item "g" in the list of possible measures to increase energy efficiency in existing buildings. Lastly, please note that the GPAC did provide input on this item and suggested expanding. the list of potential measures. Page 17, Comment No. 40: This comment is related to the Environment and Sustainability General Plan focus area, and should be relocated to that section rather than contained in the "Other Non-Focus Area" Section. The GPAC reviewed this comment and agreed in part to the Transportation and Parking Commission requested change in language. The GPAC's recommendation is incorporated into Action TRA-5.4, which states: Install traffic-calming devices that r~ri-^•T~ ~+N°°+~ ~"~ encourage slower, safer through traffic. Page 15, Comment No. 27: This comment from the Community Services Commission is related to the Senior Needs Section and should be moved to that section. The GPAC did review this comment and agreed with the recommended change. Planning Commission Staff Report -Page 3 Los Gatos 2020 General Plan and FEIR Report June 23, 2010 Page 8, Comment No. 13: Both the GPAC and staff were unclear on the intent of the Park Commission comment, which states: "Suggest new Action -Add action for animal control near trails (under Goals TRA-12)." According to Parks and Public Works Staff, the comment pertained mainly to multi-use trails. The Colnlnission suggested that when the Town constructs trails that allow hiking, bicycling, and horse riding, the trails need to be wide enough to allow for all three uses. The Commission also noted that horse riders need to be able to control their animals and trails need to provide signing as such. The Commmission also made a comment regarding paved trails and the potential conflicts between dogs on leashes, and activities such as roller blading and running. Many dog owners allow their dogs a very long leash (or no leash at all) and this can lead to conflicts and injuries. The Commission suggested posting signs to address these concerns. Staff s opinion on this suggestion is that these are operational issue and should not be addressed in the General Plan. Prepared by: Wendie R. Rooney Director of Community Development WRR: cgt N:\DEV\REPORTS\2010\General Plan Desk Item No, l.doc Goals, Policies or Implementing Strategies from the 2000 Los Gatos General Plan not carried forward into the Dra ft 2020 General Plan. - -;~. 1'I.u~ ~~LII111~C'1'171~. ,:~, (i0al, ~I~II I'V Oi' 1~CLIO71 Lall~Ll.l }~C ~.~x RC1tiOll ~tl]' ~\G111U~dl L.P.3.8 Discourage corridor lots. Confusing with L.L3.9 recommended deleting L.I.4.14 Update the General Plan's Housing You will have to do it for the next Housing Element after the demographic breakouts Element update cycle anyway. of the 2000 census are available. L.P.4.5 Maintain the Town's capacity to meet its Redundant with Housing Element housing needs as identified in the Housing Element. L.I.4.5 In-fill Findings: Review development It is not necessary for the General Plan to applications for consistency with the say the Town will implement adopted required findings for the In-Fill Policy. Town policies. L.I.4.4 Demolition of Historic Structures: Refer Redundant with L.I.4.4 .zoning approvals with demolition of historic structures to Historic Preservation Committee. L.P.7.4 Auto related uses currently existing shall be Redundant with L.P.7.3 allowed to remain indefinitely. L.P.7.8 Commercial and mixed use development This is addressed in the VLR Element north of Lark shall be in keeping with the Vasona Light Rail and Route 85 Element, the North 40 Specific Plan (when adopted) and shall provide/incorporate Boulevard, Downtown and regional transit access accordingly. L.I.7.8 North of Los Gatos-Almaden Road: Redundant with L.P.7.5 Encourage new or relocating auto-related businesses to relocate to available property north of Los Gatos-Almaden Road. L.L7.5 Los Gatos Boulevard Plan: Implement the It is not necessary for the General Plan to Los Gatos Boulevard Plan. say the Town will implement adopted Town policies. L.P.1.3 Encourage economic and social activity Redundant with Goal LG1.1 consistent with asmall-scale, small town atmosphere and image. CD.P.1.5 Avoid abrupt changes in scale and density. Redundant with CD.P.1.8 Attachment 1 2000 (~~ncral ~~ r ~r~~:~~, ~Nrrniberin~ _ Goal, Policy ur ~lctiu^ Lvi~;ua~;c ReasoirforItemoval~ ~~ --~, CD.P.1.9 Building, landscape and hardscape materials Redundant with CD.P.1.7 shall be used that will reinforce the sense of unity of a neighborhood and blend with the natural setting. L.P.4.2 Ensure that new development is a positive Redundant with CD.P.1.7 addition to the Town's environment and does not detract from the nature and character of appropriate nearby established development. L.L4.3 Maintain Neighborhood Character: The The Town will follow adopted Town deciding body shall use F.A.R. and adopted policies. residential design guidelines to maintain - existing neighborhood character. CD.I.1.11 The Los. Gatos Boulevard Plan shall be used It is not necessary to have a General Plan to evaluate projects within the area it policy to follow other adopted Town covers. policies. CD.P.4.2 Establish and maintain strong boundaries Same as L.P.6.4 in Land Use between the commercial area and adjacent residential neighborhoods. CD.I.4.14 Streetscape Plan: Implement the It is not necessary for the General Plan to Downtown Streetscape and Plaza Master say the Town will implement its adopted Plans. plans. CD.P.4.6 Preserve historically, architecturally or Redundant with CD.G.3.1, L.P.4.6, and socially significant buildings. L.P.1.9 L.P.4.6 Preserve and protect historic structures and Redundant with L.P.1.9 use special care in reviewing new buildings or remodels in their vicinity to address compatibility issues and potential impacts. CD.P.3.4 Encourage the preservation and restoration Redundant with L.P.1.9 and CDP.3.2/3.5 of historic sites, and structures and architecturally valuable structures. CD.I.3.4 Historic Codes: Continue to use Town It is not necessary for the General Plan to Code provisions to protect and designate say the Town will implement the Town historic sites. Code. CD.I.3.4 Encourage the use of the State Historic This is required anyway. Building Code for any structural changes to an historic building. )1.111 4.~cNC:: ..,-. ~~llll]~~1~'J III ~6'~';'~~~T(lal, ~U~IC}' ()Y ."~l~ll)I] I.,.111~11:1~1 :. ~\C'-aSl)]1 for Re~RVa~ __. L.I.8.10 Hillside Design Standard: Houses shall be Combined with CD.P.2.3 designed to step down the contours rather than be designed for flat pads. CD.P.1.18 Hardscape and formal landscape areas in Redundant with CD.P.2.3 and CD.P.2.6 hillsides shall be minimized. C.P.4.10 Allow no more than minimal landscaping Redundant with CD.P.2.3 and CD.P.2.6 and turf in hillside areas. L.P.8.4 Emphasize preserving the natural land Combined with CD.P.2.3 forms by minimizing grading. Grading should be limited only to the area needed to place the main house on the property. C.I.4.5 Apply the Hillside Specific Plan and It is not necessary for the General Plan to Hillside Development Standards and say the Town will implement adopted Guidelines to ensure minimal grading, and plans. to protect native plants and landscape vistas. O.L4.1 Ridge Lines: Preservation of ridge lines, Added "ridgeline preservation" "tree trees and open space along scenic roadways preservation" and "open space shall be considered in reviewing every preservation" to list of review topics. in proposed development or circulation CD.I.1.1 system improvement. L.L 1.1 Architectural Standards/Design Criteria: Redundant with CD.L 1.1. Second sentence Use adopted architectural standards and became an Action under same Goal design criteria to review development proposals. Periodically review architectural standards and design guidelines and update as necessary for completeness, clarity, and effectiveness. L.L3.1 Architectural Standards/Design Criteria: Redundant with CD.L1.1 Use adopted architectural standards and design criteria to review development proposals. L.I.4.2 Development Review: Review development Redundant with CD.I.1.1 proposals against adopted Residential Design Standards. CD.I.1.12 Evaluate projects against applicable design Redundant with CD.L1.1 guidelines. L.P.2.1 Review all development applications in Combined with CD.I.1.1 light of the overall mass and scale of the development. 2COG (_,uur~l -~ -_- ~- Plan Numh~ring (~u.ll, I'uli~v ur ;lctiun Laiigu~l,~ r ,__ ~,~~5~"~~=~ =R~asi~il ic~r I~euioval ~`~ __ _ L.I.5.4 Information Handouts: Develop handouts Redundant with CD.I.1.5 and informational materials for use by residents and businesses. L.L7.4 Land Use Policy: Develop land use policy This is the General Plan and, as such, to provide clear direction to potential should by law provide adequate land use developers. policy to potential developers. T.I.1.5 Land Use Patterns: Periodically review the This should happen as part of regular GP impact that future regional and Town land Updates. use patterns will have on the Town's circulation system. L.I.1.5 Traffic Impact Policy: Review development It is not necessary for the General Plan to applications for consistency with the say the Town will implement adopted required findings for Traffic Impact Policy. Town policies. L.I.4.6 Traffic Impact Findings: Review It is not necessary for the General Plan to development applications for consistency say the Town will implement adopted with the .required findings for the Traffic Town policies. Impact Policy. T.P.7.5 .Develop a methodology and implement a Accomplished through the Traffic Impact review procedure for relating future Policy. development decisions to the carrying capacity of Town streets. S.P.6.1 Require and maintain effective circulation It is not necessary for the General Plan to in hillsides in accordance with the Hillside say the Town will implement adopted plan. Specific Plan. T.P.4.10 Preserve the Route 85 median for mass Redundant with policies in the Vasona transit. Light Rail Element. T.P.4.11 Encourage and support the development of Redundant with policies in the Vasona a mass transit facility in the Route 85 Light Rail Element. corridor. T.P.4.7 Encourage development proposals to Redundant with T.I.6.6 include amenities that encourage alternate forms of transportation that reduce pollution or traffic congestion as a form of Community Benefit (e.g. bicycle lockers/racks, showers, dedicated van-pool or car-pool parking areas, dedicated shuttle services, innovative bus shelter designs). / ~'JJv l](_l]~l al~ __. __ l~~ ~~~:111 ~(~. F Numbcrn}; ~'~ Goal, Police or Ac(illn Lui~;uagc , ;~ E~~ lsunfoi Ra~~oval -_ _ _ _ ~. ~ , T.I.4.1 Community Benefit: Encourage developers Conflicts with T.I.6.6 which requires this. to contribute to or provide nearby improvements in pedestrian, bicycle and wheelchair access. T.P.5.1 Encourage the enhancement and Redundant with T.G.5.2 development of multiple use trails within the Town. T.P.5.4 Trail Syste>n: Complete the Town's trail Redundant with new Action TRA-11.1 and bikeways system as shown in the General and Hillside Specific Plans. CD.P.4.9 Develop and promote pedestrian-, bicycle-, Redundant with numerous other policies and transit-oriented supplements to that support pedestrians, bicycling and parking, transit. V.P.7.1 The Town shall .guide future development Not necessary to re-state the legal function in the sub-area. of the General Plan V.P.4.3 Major development projects shall be This is a Town wide policy in the CD processed as planned developments. Element V.I.5.2 Process major development projects as This is a Town wide policy in the CD planned developments. Element V.L7.3 Planned developments: Process major This is a Town wide policy in the CD developments as planned developments. Element V.I.8.3 Planned developments: Process major This is a Town wide policy in the CD development proposals as planned Element developments. V.I.1.1 Mass Transit: Cooperate and coordinate Redundant with V.I.1.2 with all appropriate agencies to facilitate construction of mass transit. V.P.3.1 Sites for recreational open space and Redundant with OSP policies about access playfields shall have convenient access and and adjacent residential land uses be designed with adequate buffers if adjacent to residential uses. V.I.6.1 Orient and site residential units to take Redundant with V.P.6.1 advantage of the amenities of the Los Gatos Creek Trail system and to preserve watersheds, riparian habitats and wildlife corridors. 2 ~~G~iic ~ i) ~ -; ~ ~ '~ i~lumhcrin;; Coal. ('uli~~~ ~u~ ~1cCi~w L:u~Kuagc ~ ~ R~ ~um_I~„• Renun :il ~ ~~ - V.P.6.4 _ - Develop apedestrian/bicycle bridge across - Redundant with V.I.5.5 and V.I.6.4 Los Gatos Creek and a continuous trail system along the east side of Los Gatos Creek from Lark Ave. to the northern Town limit in keeping with the Trails and Bikeways Master Plan. V.P.4.4 The design of structures and open space Redundant with Town-wide policies in CD shall be compatible with the small-town Element character of Los Gatos. V.I.7.1 Design standards: Prepare development Redundant with V.I.4.1 standards that include criteria and provisions for comprehensive design review, recognizing the area as a "gateway" to Los Gatos. V.L8.4 Adopted Plans: Evaluate proposed uses and It is not necessary for the General Plan to designs to ensure they are consistent with say the Town will implement adopted plans the Los Gatos Boulevard Plan and Design Standards Plan. V.G.4.2 To encourage the best mixture of Redundant with V.G.4.1 residential and nonresidential uses within the area which achieves the least impact on traffic, noise, schools, etc. V.P.6.3 The maintenance road along the east side of Redundant with V.L6.3 Los Gatos Creek shall function for emergency access. V.P.8.3 Development shall incorporate features to Redundant with V.I.6.2 buffer dwelling units from noise and other impacts. V.I.8.5 Noise: Applications for projects that front Redundant with V.I.6.2, which has been on Los Gatos Blvd and/or back up to revised to require a noise study property on National Ave. or Camino del Sol shall include a noise study proposing mitigation measures to reduce noise impacts on existing and future residents. V.I.5.6 Evaluate projects as to how the built Redundant with Town-wide policies in CD environment naturally blends into the Element surrounding landscape in such areas as: scale, materials, hadscape, lights and landscape. ~~Q~ ~~l nlr:ll n~ ~ ~ ~ _ ~- ~~ ~~ '~ i ~ ~~l:ltl ,.,. - . __ h~uniher-ink =u~.- - (~~s21, P?oliz5~ ut~ Action Langua~,~ _ I reason-fur I~einov_al V.L7.6 Cut-through traffic: Ingress and egress shall Redundant with Town-wide neighborhood be designed to minimize opportunities for traffic calming policies in the traffic impacts on surrounding residential Transportation Element neighborhoods. O.I.1.3 Safety: Use the policies and implementation It is not necessary for the General Plan to measures of the Safety Element to restrict say the Town will implement adopted development in safety hazard areas. Town policies. O.P.4.1 Preserve the natural open space character of Redundant with the Goal OP4.3 prominent visible hillside lands. O.P.4.4 Require the provision of permanent open Redundant with OI4.2] space in hillside developments. O.P.3.4 Provide access to natural open space, First part redundant with Goal O.G.2.1, protecting the safety, privacy, and security second part combined with O.P.2.1 of adjacent residential areas. O.P.3.1 Provide open space in residential areas. Redundant with Goal O.G.3.1 L.P.8.9 Encourage innovative and efficient This policy is actually a goal. It is not management of natural resources. needed since we have an extensive set of goals focused on specific natural resources. C.P.4.11 Encourage preservation and use of native This is not necessary since C.I.4.1 requires plant species in hillside areas. native plants throughout the Town, not only in hillside areas. C.L4.2 Tree preservation ordinance: Town Redundant with C.P.4.2 ordinances shall Encourage the maintenance of specimen or heritage trees and limit the removal of all trees. C.P.4.12 Enforce the grading standards set forth in It is not necessary for the General Plan to the I~illside Specific Plan and Hillside say the Town will implement adopted plans Development Standards and Guidelines. and standards. C.I.2.11 Enforce protection of riparian corridors. Redundant with Goal C.G.2.6 and Policy C.P.2.14 C.P.4.5 Preserve wetlands. Redundant with Goal C.G.2.6 C.I.5.2 Enforcement: Local, state and national It is not necessary for the General Plan to regulations protecting against the say that the Town will enforce local, state destruction of wildlife and wildlife habitat and national regulations. shall be strictly enforced. C.P.5.4 Establish sound land management practices This is accomplished through this General that will improve wildlife habitats. Plan. ,; ~~0 Gcncr:il I'l vi ti' u mberutg_ ~ ~ava~ ;,(.;;c+al, P~lcti ur .1~tiou Language' ; _ R~~as~~i~ f~,i Rcu~c,~ al , , T - C.P.7.3 Design structures to maximize natural Redundant with new Policy ENV-10.6 heating and cooling (passive solar heating and cooling.) C.P.7.4 Utilize landscaping for passive cooling and Redundant with new Policy ENV-10.7 protection from prevailing winds. C.I.7.2 Energy Rating System: The Town, in This has been accomplished through the conjunction with the local board of realtors adoption of the GreenPoint Rating System. and local developers and architects, shall participate in the development and implementation of an energy efficiency rating system for existing and new residential structures to assist home buyers in selecting energy efficient homes. N.G 1.1 To preserve the quiet atmosphere of the Redundant with N.G.1.2 Town. N.P.1.11 Adopt standards or criteria for the review State standards are used. of noise impacts. N.I.1.19 Establish standards that address ongoing Done operational noise. N.I.1.15 Community noise survey: The Town shall Redundant with NI.12 . periodically conduct a community noise survey. S.G.1.1 To reduce the potential for injuries, damage Redundant with SG1.2 to property, economic and social displacement, and loss of life resulting from earthquakes, and other various forms of geologic failures including mud flows and landslides. S.I.2,2 Site design: In areas identified as potentially Redundant with SP 2.3 susceptible to fire hazards, require special building and site design by ordinance. HS.L 1.2 Continue to use the local media, Town Replaced by new policy HS-7.3 in Draft website and Town newsletter to promote 2020 General Plan senior programs. HS.P.5.1 Provide the minimum library facility Town direction to Remove standards of the American Library Association. LOCO General _,u~,.._.__~ ~ - - - -~ _ I'l.u, ~ ti~unil~cring Gi~al, polaw or AcLiun I ant;ua;;c __.. ~ -''"~6aSUR for Rcmo~~al HS.P.5.2 Build a new library facility that will be Town direction to Remove efficient, flexible and expandable to accommodate the changing informational and educational needs of the community. HS,L5.1 Proceed with planning for a new library Removing since this facility is already facility that will accommodate changing planned. technology and increased information and education needs of Los Gatos for the next twenty years. HS.I.4.1 Study the feasibility of Town-supported Town direction to Remove performing arts events. C.L2.8 Require landscaping in new developments This is already required by the Water and remodels that is based on the principles Efficiency Landscaping Ordinance of water conservation, including the use of drought tolerant plants, limited turf areas and water conserving techniques. C.P.2.6 Promote landscaping that is based on Redundant with CD.P.1.17 principles of water conservation. C.P.2.13 Work with Town businesses and residents Redundant with C.G.2.1, C.G.2,4, C.G.2.5 to encourage water conservation. and S.P.3.4 C.P.2.12 Require new development to demonstrate Redundant with CD.P.1.17 and adopted how it makes efficient use of water. Ordinance. C.P.2.8 Limit land use intensity in areas with Town direction to Remove inadequate water supply. j. North Forty Specific Plan Overlay The North Forty Specific Plan Overlay determines the mix of uses that will occur in this area as well as the maximum development potential. The General Plan Environmental Impact Report (EIR) assessed the potential impacts of the maximum development capacity for the North 40 Specific Plan. Based on the maximum development capacity in the EIR, Rresidential development is shall be limited to not more than 750 dwelling units of mixed residential types. Non-residential uses ~ shall be limited to a total of 580,000 square feet of retail and office development. The development of a hotel i-s shall be permitted in this area. The North 40 Specific Plan shall be based on the following design principles: T'°~~°l~rm°r+ ~~"~°r +1,°,.T,,,,+1, •~ Complement and not compete with Los Gatos's Downtown and the rest of the community. • Be based on sustainable and "smart" development practices. • Incorporate mixed-use development with residential uses to the south and retail mixed- use to the north. • Include public atg_ hexing spaces such as a plazas °+ +1,° „°„+°,. „~+1,° ,,,;.,°,a „~° .,,,°., ,,,,,a „ parks..,++1,° ,. ,,,°„ „~+1,° „ n;,a°„+;.,1 ., • Provide for a variety of residential housing types, both rental and owner occupied. A minimum of 20% of the units shall be affordable to households at the moderate income level or below. 1°..°1 ,,,, 1,°1,,.,. • Include high-quality architecture and design that reflects the rural and agricultural history of the .site. • Provide pedestrian-oriented buildings along the Los Gatos Boulevard frontage, with minimal parking oriented to the street. • Talce advantage of the grade change across the site by including split-level buildings that allow for two floors of retail and "tuck under" parking. • Continue the "boulevard treatment" along Los Gatos Boulevard, with intercomiections from one parcel's drive aisle to the next. • Include connections to existing intersections along Los Gatos Boulevard and Larlc Avenue. • Develop gateway or landmark features. at Los Gatos Boulevard and Larlc Avenue and at Los Gatos Boulevard and the Highway 85 off ramp.. • Provide an easily accessible, hilly connected street network that encourages walking. • Provide a vegetative buffer and screening along Highways 17 and 85. • Preserve Town character and views., ;"- • Preservinge views of the hills from 1=Iighways 17 and 85. e 1J,.°~°,...;,,~. , ~.f+1,° h;lln F,..,,,, T_T;~1,,,..,,.~ 17 .,,,.a QG Attachment 2