The URL can be used to link to this page

Desk Item #19COUNCIL AGENDA REPORT DATE: JUNE 12, 2012 MEETING DATE: 06/18/12 ITEM NO: 19 DESK ITEM TO: MAYOR AND TOWN COUNCIL FROM: GREG LARSON, TOWN MANAGER TITLE: DOGS OFF - LEASH: PILOT PROGRAM IMPLEMENTATION Since production and distribution of the June 18 Town Council meeting agenda packet, staff has received additional public comment regarding this agenda item. Correspondence received through 9:00 a.m. June 13 was included in the staff report for Agenda item #19 of the June 18 Council agenda packet. Correspondence received after 9:00 a.m. June 13 through 3:00 p.m. June 18 (the submittal deadline for Council meeting agenda material) is included in this Desk Item as Attachment 4 to the staff report. Attachments: L-3. (Previously distributed with staff report) 4. Additional Public Cormnent — correspondence received 9:00 a.m. June 13 through 3:00 p.m. June 18 PREPARED BY : TODD CAPURSO Director of Parks and Public Works Reviewed by:kP�Assistant Town Manager i _Town Attorney _Finance N: IPPWiMANAOEMENTCOUNCILCOUNCILREPORT $`20L2 ReportWune 180ogs Off- LeeshkDESK ITEM.Dogs0flLeash.6- 18.doc THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK From: Stoboys < sto boys CcDverizon.net Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 9:27 AM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice@losgatosca.gov > Subject: I vote no on off- leash! "I am opposed to all off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks." Michelle Stojanovich Citizen against off -leach law in our neighborhood parks Sent from myiPhone From: Barbara McInerney [mailto:barbara _ mcinerney@yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 11:11 AM To: Council Cc: jon_a_ lambert @yahoo.com Subject: I am a citizen against off -leash dogs in our parks Hello Town of Los Gatos, I am opposed to all off -leash dog programs in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. Barbara McInerney, mother of 2 56 Ellenwood Ave Los Gatos, CA From: harry campbell < harrvrcampbellCd)gmail.com > Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 11:23 AM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice a@losgatosca.gov Subject: Off Leash Dog Proposal for our Town parks Dear Steve Rice, I am a 40 year resident of our lovely Town of Los Gatos and I have enjoyed the use of our wonderful parks with my children when they were young, and now with my grandchildren. I have carefully followed the "Dogs Off Leash" proposal for our Town's parks both in person and via the articles and letters in our weekly newspaper. I attended the first of the three community meetings and also the Town Park Commission meeting and at both I expressed my strong opposition to such a proposal. My reasons are many: Child Safety, health concerns (baby's crawling on the park grass after a dog off leash session), liability (for incidents, bites or attacks), enforcement of restrictions, monitoring of the project and my fear that if this proposal is implemented our parks will be a magnet for many residents of nearby communities to overload our already quite busy parks. I have also read the proposal presented to the Town's Parks Commission by staff and I found it to be missing clear objectives, measurement criteria, reporting specification, etc. In other words I don't think it is a valid and implemental proposal. However, my main objection is that it did not adequately describe the opposition to this proposal that I saw at the public meeting by physicians (a pediatrician and a plastic surgeon - both residents), dog owners, several children and other concerned residents. So, in summary, I feel that the endorsement of this proposal by the parks commission (6 yea votes, 2 nay votes and two abstentions, if my recollection is correct) does not reflect the will of the people as expressed in public meetings. I respectfully request that you vote to not implement this off leash proposal. Ciao. Harry Campbell 282 Casitas Bulevar Los Gatos From: John Boucher <John Boncher@CEI.com> Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:22 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" <srice @losgatosca.gov> Subject: Off leash hours for Bachman Park Steve, I am opposed to this proposed off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. Thank you From: Tracey Enfantino <tnfantino @esite.net> Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:32 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" <srice @losgatosca.gov >, BSpector <BSpector @losgatosca.gov >, Steve Leonardis <SLeonardis @losgatosca.gov >, "drncnutt @losgatsoca.gov" <dmcnutt @losgatsoca.gov >, "jprizynski @losgatosca.gov" <jprizynski @losgatosca.gov> Cc: Todd Capurso <tcapurso @losgatosca.gov >, "kpaisley @verizon.net" <kpaisley @verizon.net> Subject: Off Leash Opposition 'jpirzynski @losgatosca.gov' June 13, 2012 Los Gatos Mayor and Council Dear Mayor Rice, Vice Mayor Spector, and Council Members Leonardis, McNut,t and Pirzynski, I am adamantly opposed to the off leash dog hours for Bachman Park. This poses a health hazard from feces left around to the most serious; dog attacks and bites. If a child is playing in the sandbox at the park - and a dog attacks the child, the Town is responsible- not just the dog owner! Where will the responsibility lie when a non - vaccinated dog bites? Why is the council entertaining this! Please consider the HEALTH and SAFETY of park goers over the dogs, and dog owners off - leash gratification. Tracey Enfantino 18611 Decatur Rd Monte Sereno Monte Sereno Resident 18611 Decatur Rd since 1995 Monte Sereno Resident Kavin Lane 1992 -1995 Los Gatos Resident 1972 -1983 cc: Todd Capurso via email From: Lu Ann [mailto:lualmf @comcast.net] Sent: Monday, June 18, 2012 12:34 PM To: Janette Judd Subject: Re: Dogs off -leash and unfenced and Park Commission meeting - dog bite statistics for Los Gatos, 2011, 2012 I forgot to mention that there were 12 dog bites in 2010. And please note the incident with the pitbull in town square doesn't seem to have been reported, though I am told it took place by others. I will have the info available at the meeting if the council would like to verify this info. I only have it online and wanted to black out the actual address and just leave the street and dog breed info. - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Lu Ann [mailto:luannf @comcast.net] Sent: Monday, June 18, 2012 11:36 AM To: Council Subject: Dogs off -leash and unfenced and Park Commission meeting - dog bite statistics for Los Gatos, 2011, 2012 I wrote earlier saying that I have attended all 4 meetings in regards to dogs off -leash and unfenced pilot program in our parks. I mentioned that I was shocked that Todd put the proposal through and completely ignored all the concerns that were brought up at the meetings, which included these things that are already taking place in our parks as a result of the city ignoring the on -leash dog rules. Dogs knocking down children, some taking kids food, dog pooping and peeing all over, and SOME owners not picking up after them, creating a smelly, dirty environment that also passes contagious disease into the ground, off -leash dogs attacking on- leash dogs, snaking it a place to avoid, and also ignoring the advice of expert dog behaviorists and trainers, professionals, and organizations like San Jose Animals Services, The Humane Society and most veterinarians about unfenced off -leash dogs and www.kidshealth.org's info about contagious diseases found in the grounds that are used as dog parks. I asked two pediatricians what their opinions were about shared space and they would not recommend that. I was shocked to learn afterwards that none of the many letters that people sent in were ever given to the Parks Commissioners and that the Chair of the committee's wife is actually active supporter of off -leash unfenced dogs at our parks. So most of these commissioners were voting on an issue they really had very little info on since only a few of them even attended any of the meetings. I have to say the two that did attend, with the exception of the Chair, one was against off - leash, and one wanted to have our concerns addressed, which I greatly appreciated. I found the whole process unprofessional. In your own town page, and response letter to people that write in, you specifically list ppw @losgatosea.gov as the address to write in. Why then, would this information not be provded to every parks commissioner ?! San Jose Animal Care & Services has provided me with the following dog biting humans information. In 2011, there were 28 bites, in 2012, 9 for up to end of May, and 2 of those bites were from the same dog on 2 people trying to protect their leashed dog from being attacked by an unleashed dog. (One of the people sent you a letter too.) This "family" dog had never done something like this they said and they have a baby in the home. I'm sure all these dogs' owners would swear they never thought their dog would do this. California is now the top dog bite state and children make up half of the total. These statistics do not even include dog on dog attacks, again mostly off -leash dogs approaching or attacking an on- leash dog. Humans are also bit in many of these cases trying to protect their dog. Dogs off -leash and unfenced is unsafe and unfair to park goers that do not want to risk encountering dogs, and the other more than 95% of the dog owners that do not let their dogs off - leash. What we really need is a remote fenced dog park that will serve the needs of the majority of dog owners and keep our parks safe and clean. - - - -- Original Message--- - From: Thomas Babula [mailto:Babula @iname.com] Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 1:43 PM To: Town PPW Subject: Against Bachman Park Dog Proposal When we first heard about this proposal, we ignored it because we could not imagine anyone in a leadership role supporting this proposal. This Is not about a love or hate of dogs, this is a matter of personal safety and enjoyment for all. We have a dog & will walk our dog through Bachman, on leash, in the morning. Our dog does not want to play with other dogs. However, when an unleashed dog approaches a dog on leash, it is a problem and a danger. Ask any "dog person ". By giving the off leash hours, you are taking away the rights of on leash dogs and their owners to enjoy the park. If we see a community need for a park, by all means, let's approach this by looking for suitable venues that will support everyone's rights. We can not believe this discussion has gotten this far. Let's put this to a vote and not sneak it in when most people are on vacation. Tom & Laurie Babula -Original Message---- - From: Whitney Spagnola [mailto:Wspagnola @aol.com] Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 1:31 PIN To: Council Cc: Town PPW Subject: Against Off -Leash Dogs in Public Areas Dear Council Members & Parks Commission, I had a dog who was aggressive towards other dogs when on a leash. She was a wonderful rescue dog who worked hard to protect me. It was extremely difficult and dangerous when someone's off leash dog would come runnin towards me and my 85 pound dog. People would always be saying, "no worries my dog is friendly" and I'd have to yell at them saying, "well mine is not ". It never even occurred to most people that the "other dog" may not want to be approached. Dogs should absolutely remain on a leash when in public areasl Sincerely, Whitney Spagnola Los Gatos - - -- Original Message---- - From: Julie Conlisk [mailto:jconlisk @mac.com] Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2012 10:55 AM To: Town PPW Cc: Conlisk Brian; Kate Paisley Subject: CITIZENS AGAINST OFF LEASH IN OUR TOWN PARKS ATTN: PARKS DEPT This letter has been sent to each member of the Los Gatos Town Council We think it is great that the Town of Los Gatos tries to accommodate many of the diverse and sometimes conflicting desires of its citizens. A great example is considering the request of off leash hours at three neighborhood parks. Instead of focusing on what has already been written about the obvious concerns of the public, especially child safety and changing the complexion of these neighborhood parks, we would like to point out a few practical issues if the town decides to adopt, even for a trial period, off leash hours at these park. CONFLICT RESOLUTION: It has been proposed by Parks staff that these parks would be self - policing. We all recognize that this is not realistic. When there are conflicts under current code the attending ranger or police officer can easily resolve it by enforcing the dog owner to put their dog on leash. Simple. This removes the necessity of det erminin g guilt. However if the dogs requirement to be leashed is removed then future conflict resolution will become completely subjective and difficult. It puts the officer in the middle of an argument instead of just enforcing the off leash code. ENFORCIBILITY: Even after a determination of guilt by the officer during a dispute or complaint it is much more difficult to ensure compliance since dogs are allowed off leash. What would be the penalty? Can the officer tell the party at fault that they had to leave the park? Citafiohs can be written. However, citations will likely be more severe than just telling the owner to put their dog on leash, which then makes the determination of guilt and resolution more important and more problematic. The town has been very flexible with off leash offenders under current code and we have been told doesn't go out patrolling for offenders as much as responding to complaints. In other words, the town has been more interested in having a flexible atmosphere at our parks than going out and generating citation revenue. That's great. We propose that off leash at parks will INCREASE the amount of conflict and actually create LESS flexibility for its citizen's ultimately from the practical results of combining kids and their parents with off leash dogs' and their owners. It is a certainty that more complaints will occur. And a certainty that resolutions will be more difficult. We believe that the Town will not allow this to happen and thank you for your stewardship. We also believe that if this is adopted at these parks„ even as a trial, then the town citizens who are now skeptical that the town will consider it and are not yet active, will become much more involved in the future. Even a trial program, once adopted becomes difficult to take back. Word spreads and even if rescinded enforcement needs will be greater. We also believe that those dog owners in favor are already out in force, and their size of support is already witnessed. We also behove if this continues further then there will be a growing contingent against off leash, with greater animosity and more polarization, an unfortunate end result for everyone. Sincerely, Brian and Julie Conlisk Neighbors of Bachman Park CITIZENS AGAINST OFF LEASH IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Patti tovetro- Clarkeimailto .opulent.interiors@yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:13 PM To; Town PPW; Council Subject: FW: unleashed dog attack From a local doctor's wife: On the heels of Jen's e-mail I wanted to share this story with everyone: My husband is a plastic surgeon and today a family came in with their 3 year old girl that was attacked by a friendly dog at the park. This 3 year old girl has over 10 scars on her face; a large out all the way to her skull across her forehead, cuts on both her cheeks, on her lips and across her neck. This is going to result in numerous obvious scars all over this little girl's face for the rest of her life. If you oppose to having off leash dogs in parks where our children play, I urge you to come to this meeting so one of our babies doesn't become a victim like the little girl my husband treated today. Unfortunately these accidents happen all the time. - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Kate Paisley [mailto:kpaisley @verizon.net] Sent. Saturday, June 16, 2012 9:42 AM To: Steve Leonardis; Diane McNutt; Jae Pitzynski; BSpector; Steve Rice; Council Cc: Town PPW Subject: No Dogs Off -Leash Petition Dear Council Members, This is a PDF copy of the petition that I emailed to you separately, and may be an easier -to -read format. Nothing has been edited or altered. It contains 162 signatures and dozens and dozens of comments. The petition is not closed and we expect more signatures by Monday. I hope you will have time to review it, especially the comments. I think it will be a good resource for you as you weigh the decision. Thank you for your service to the town. It is much appreciated Kate Paisley 211 Belmont Ave. Los Gatos, CA 95030 408- 605 -2300 No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures Home > Categories > Other > No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks http:ll %vww.ipetitions.comlpetitionino- off- leasb- dogs- at- bachman -... Sign Slog Signatures Emall friends Signatures 159 TOTAL Sign Petition Page: 4, 2, 3, 4 r n Nowl - - Sponsored links 1 Name: Kate Paisley on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 2 Name: Donna Fox on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 3 Name: VIkk1 Boyd on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: I am against off leash dogs In our parks Flag 4 Name: Jean Learning on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: PLEASE do not allow dogs to run free around our children Flag 5 Name: Bob And Carol Braham on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 6 Name: Marybeth Maclean on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: I am a dog owner and Almond Grove resident and am against designating Bachman Park for Off Leash doffs. Flag 7 Name: Bill MacLean on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag a Name: Jeff Gruefter on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: We are dog owners and we have 4 and 6 year old daughters that play at Bachman Flag 9 Name: Jeff Gruefter on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 1 of 5 6/15/2012 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures http: / /www.ipetitions.com/pefition /no -off- leash- dogs -at- bachman -... 10 Name: The Lucia Family on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: As a neighbor of Bachman Park I oppose the pilot. It is not an appropriate location. Flag 11 Name:. .J, Mary F. Cimino Lucia on Jun ti, 2012 Comments: Flag 12 Name: Jeffrey A. Barnett on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 13 Name: Rene Neuner on Jun 11, 2012 Comments; I am a dog lover, however, dogs should be on leash at all times, parks, streets, anywhere that they are not within their home boundaries. Flag 14 Name: Hal Chase on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 1s Name: Barbara Delderis on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: I am a Bachman neighbor and dog owner. I this this of leash idea is a bad one as is well outlined in this petition and the many letters about the issue. The Town Council should be looking to put a fenced dog park in LG. Flag 16 Name: Glenn Boyd on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Dog owner who believes that dogs In public need to be on a leash and under control. Flag 17 Name: David Dury on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Children's parks and dog parks are and should be two different places. No one would take their baby to crawl around and play on the grass of a dog park] Why should we force our children to play In the same place a dog defecates and pees? ' Flag 18 Name: Rick Delderis on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: We do not want off leash dog hours at Bachman Park. Flag 19 Name: Jocelyn Penner on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 20 Name: Bill Francis on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Any off leash dog that comes near my kid will became very familiar with my boot. This Is political favoritism at work here. Flag 21 Name: Kell! Granum on Jun 11, 2012 2 of 5 6/15/2012 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures http:/ /www.ipetitions.com/petition /no- off - leash- dogs- at- bachman -... Comments: Flag 22 Name: Bryan Grenum on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 23 Name: Laura And Scott Kuper on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: WE DO NOT WANT off leash dog hours. Please do not vote for this! Flag 24 Name: Gary & Sara Walker on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: As I see it the Issue is quite simple, there Is a security Issue for children and adults. (am apposed go an off - leashdog program in Los Batas. Flag 25 Name: Susan Mortzheim on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 26 Name: Madeline Raff on Jun 11, 2012 Comments: Flag 27 Name: Laum Marie Lucia on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: I grew up across from this park and have been bitten by a loose dog in the park during a Cat Hill Race. Police ran the dog down, It's shots were not current. Dogs and children playing together Is wrong. Flag 28 Name: Paula Lucia on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: I also grew up across from Bachman Park. When I was four a black lab strolled Into our backyard from the park. It scared me to death. Took many years for me to not be scared. Flag 29 Name: Elaine Cardinale on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: off leash animals should be conducted in a fenced area for safety of other animals and parkgoers. Flag 30 Name: Shamn on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: off leash, is for dog parks, last I checked this is a family park... sounds like a disaster waiting to happen .... I say "no" Flag 31 Name: Bianca Gme6er on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 32 Name: Anne Smets on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 33 3 of 5 6/1512012 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" in Los Gatos Packs signatures http:/ Iwww.ipetitions.com/potition/no -off- leash- dogs- at- baQhman -.,. Name: Stacey Olson on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 34 Name: Taryne Kraus on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: I like dogs, but people are afraid or allergic and should NOT be subjected to an unleashed dog in our beaullful parks. They are for people I rstlll Flag 35 Name: Hallle Barnes on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: No off -leash dog parks anywhere In Los Gatosl Flag 39 Name: Kerr! Dlcicco on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 37 Name: Mall Dicicco on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 39 Name: Mary Goheen on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 39 Name: Jon Lambert on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: It is completely inappropriate and irresponsible to run dogs off leash In the Ins Gatos parks. No one has the right to put others at risk like this. Flag 40 Name: Julie Winters on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: I love all animals... it is Just the owners that I am concerned about. Thank you. Flag 41 Name: John Cook on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 42 Name: Nicky Mcallister on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 43 Name: Nick Talesfore on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: I am strongly against allowing a trial and dogs off4eash at the neighborhood Bachman Park! Flag 44 Name: Jennifer Lambert on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: I am against this program as it is completely unsafe and wrong. These are neighborhood parks. Please consider the safety of everyone. Flag 45 Name: John Connolly on Jun 12, 2012 4 of 5 6/15/2012 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures http:// www. ipetitions .com/potition /no- off-leash- dogs- at- bachman -... Comments: children and off-leash dogs should not be anywhere close to one another. I am a Flog 46 Name: Raquel Connolly on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: em Flag 47 Name: Holly Bins on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Dogs are wonderful creatures that deserve to be domesticated with dignity. Leashes are a security measure for them and for us. Please use them. Flag 46 Name: Eric Raff on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: I live across the street from Bachman Park and don't want to see a neighborhood park turn Into a destination location for people who want to let their dogs off leash. The park simply does not have the facilities and shre to support the more intensive use proposed. Flag 49 Name: Lort Ingle on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag s6 Name: Pattl Lovetra- Clarko on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: "I am opposed to all off-leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks." Flag Page: 1, 2, 3, 4 > n Petitions is owned and operated by Angle Three Associates, LLC -All material ® Copyright Angle Three Associates, LLC, 1996 -2012 - Terms of Use 5 of 5 6/15120I2 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures - Page 2 Home > Categories > Olher> No "Dogs Off Leash' In Los Gatos Parks No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks Sign Blog Signatures Email friends http:/ /www.ipe6tions.com/petition/no- off - leash- dogs- at- bachman -... Signatures 159 TOTAL Sign Petition Page: c r 1, 2, 3, 4> u Nowl Sponsored links 51 Name: Sowmya Shona on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 52 Name: Suzanne Cochran an Jun 12, 2012 Comments: I DO NOT WANT "Off Leash Dog Hours" at Bachman Park, or any of the Los Gatos neighborhood parks. Also I just had a incident last week with a off -leash dog attacking my dog while walking my leashed dog in a LG neighborhood. This is a recent example of owners not controlling their off leash dogs. Flag 53 Name: Anonymous on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 54 Name: Anonymous on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Please keep this park safe and friendly for our kids who love to play therel Flag 55 Name: Anonymous on Jun 12, 2012 Comments; Flag 55 Name: Llanne Verheyden on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 57 Name: Barbara Alioto on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: notjust Bachman Park, ALL parks In LG Flag 58 Name: Anonymous on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 59 Name: Phil And Kathryn Parkman on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: 1 of 5 6/15/2012 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures -Page 2 http:// www.ipetitions.com/petition/no- off - leash- dogs- at- bachman -... Flag 66 Name: Erin Leigh on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 61 Name: Curtis Leigh on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 62 Name: Anonymous on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 63 Name: Gregory P. Lucia on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Live directly across from Bachman Park for over 30 years. It Is a neighborhood famlly /children's park. NOT a dog park. Flag 64 Name: Anonymous on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 65 Name: Jacquelyn Rider on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Glemidge area resident Flag 66 Name: Jeanie Kane on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: 1 agree, no dogs off leash at Bachman Park. Flag 67 Name: Janis Just on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 66 Name: Anonymous on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Not all dog owners are not Irresponsible: but plenty ere. I don`t want to run Into an out -of- control dog while walking down my street and parks. Some owners can hardly control their dogs when an leash, certainly hale to see those dogs off leash. Flag 69 Name: Jennifer Stapleton on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 70 Name: ma Kelly on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: "I am opposed to all o6 -leash dog programs in Los Gatos. It Is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks." Flag 71 Name: Sara Krings on Jun 12, 2012 Comments: Flag 2 of 5 6/15/2012 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" 1n Los Gatos Parks signatures - Page 2 http:/ /www.ipetitions.com/pefition/no- off - leash- dogs- at- bachman -,.. 72 Name: Mary O'Connor on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: we lived thm an attack by a dog when our son was a toddler Flag 73 Name: Malread Brodie on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: I have seen off-leash parks in operation in San Francisco and they are not safe for children. As the parent of a young baby, I think we need to prioritize child safety in our local parks. Flag 74 Name: Neide Hall on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: I'm against of dogs without leashes Flag 75 Name: Diane Roberts on Jun 13, 2012 Commenta: We a liability Issue. Flag 76 Name: Tracey Enfamino on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Monte Sereno Resident since 1992, Los Gatos Resident prior since 1072 Flag 77 Name: Whitney Spagnola on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Flag 78 Name: Sydney Ogborn an Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Flag 79 Name: Kathleen Normington on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Flag 80 Name: Vlcke Johnson an Jun 13, 2012 Comments: I am against the off leash probram Flag 81 Name: Anonymous on Jun 13,2012 Comments: Dogs should be on- leash. There are dog parks that they can go to so they can run free. Flag 82 Name: Christine F. on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: I am a dog lover and have one of my own. If I want her to run around without a leash, I lake her to the dog park. She is a very sweet pup but can be bothered by small children, I would hate for her to bite someone and then have to be put down. There are places other than family parks for dogs to roam freely. Flag 83 Name: Lamay Richardson on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: I love dogs.... However, I do NOT believe In turning our public parks Into off leash dog parks. When I walk the dam and see all those dog poop begs left behind or dog poop left where it was deposited, well it is very frustrating to me. Do you really think that people will pick up all of the dog 3 of 5 6/15/2012 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures -Page 2 http :flwww.ipetitions.com/pettflon/no -off- leash- dogs -at- Nachman -,.. poop at the new off leash parks? Who will patrol the dog poop situation? Who will patrol the dogs that knock down little kids or are aggressive? Where will the owners use the restroom? What about visitors from other cities that come to our parks to run their dogs? (Think Halloween and the visitors we get.) I think the town will be making a big mistake to legalize free running dogs at our parks. Flog 84 Name: Bess Zientek on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Dogs, being animals (however much they are trained and devoted pets) can and do exercise unanticipated behavior when confronted with additional sensory experiences: sound, smell etc. It is unrealistic to think they will not do so and It Is Irresponsible behavior on the pad of the town to consider "off leash" park time. Flag 85 Name: Brian And Julie Conlisk on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Flag 86 Name: Christi Mcnay on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Flag 67 Name: Barbara McInerney on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Flag 68 Name: Eddie Wagner on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Bachman Park neighbor Flag 89 Name: Dan Snyder on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Flag 90 Name: Sharon Cunningham on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: 1 am totally against unleashed dogs in our parks. It poses health and safety issues and 1 am in agreement with this petition. Flag 91 Name: Catherine Grabinski an Jun 13, 2012 Comments: We live on the park at 233 Belmont Ave. We are totally against the passage of this pilot program. Flag 92 Name: Jan Williams on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Dogs should be on a leash at all times when In a public park. If they are to run around, take them to a specified dag.park Flag 93 Name: Laude Babula on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: We love dogs & have a dog ourselves. We live in Almond Grove and are completely opposed to having an off -leash dog park even with limited hours. The liability alone should have tabled this discussion long ago. It's not a matter of "if something happens, its a matter of "when' an incident occurs. Gnfortunately, rules are typically put In place to manage the minority population and, although most dog owners are responsible, quite a few are not responsible and pose a hazard to others. If this is a community need, let's figure out where we can support an organized, fenced, 4 of 5 6/15/2012 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" Sn Los Gatos Parks signatures - Page 2 http: / /www.ipetitions.com / petition/no- off - leash- dogs- at- bacitman -... controlled atmosphere for true canine play. Flag 04 Name: Tom Babula on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Opposed to dog perk at Bachman. Not an environment for off-leash dogs, children, and people. Would be in support of a designated dog park in an area that can be controlled& contained. Flag 95 Name: John Boucher on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: I am a Glenridge area resident. We love dogs and take our pup on walks all over Los Gatos ... on a leash. I do not tike the idea of making Bachman Park an off leash park at any time of day. Off leash dogs are not safe and that park is constantly frequented by small children. Additionally, people wlu travel from out ad the area to use the park. Where will these people park? Restrooms? Please do not let this pass) Flag 90 Name: Auto Kovac on Jun 13, 2012 Comments: Flag 97 Name: Anonymous on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 9B Name: Anonymous on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 99 Name: Matt Sachse on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: My family and I go to Bachman frequently with our young children (5, 3 1) and would stop coming to the park if this initiative moves forward. I have communicated our concerns to Christy Wolter, Los Gatos' Parks and Facilities Superintendent, and absolutely support a petition against this Initiative. Flag 100 Name: Sara Walker And Gary Walker on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Bachman neighbor, concur with all points on letter. I agree there are many owners already showing up with dogs off leash, chaffing not able to control the animals. I have been charged by 3 while owners at a dislanc i called their dogs to stop. Owners cannot control their dogs or the other dogs who join In. This Is a park for the people who live her not the dogs. The safety of Los Gatos attracts people to buy property and supports the prices and tax base of the homes Flag Page: a r 1, 2, 3, 4 0 » IPelitlons Is owned and operated by Angle Three Associates, LLC - All material © Copyright Angle Three Associates, LLC, 1998 -2012 - Terms of Use 5 of 5 - 6/15/2012 2:29 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" Tn Los Gatos Parks signatures - Page 3 Home > Categories >Other> No'Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks http:/ /www.ipetitions.com/potidon/no- off - leash- dogs- at- bachman -.,. Sign Slog Signatures Email friends Signatures 159 TOTAL Sign Petition Page: e c 1, 2, 3, 4> u Nowl -- ........,._�� -. _ — ___..___..._.........,,.. -- _— .._.._`_._ Sponsored links 101 Name: Shannon Susick on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: i have a very well trained coon hound, only uses our yard for bathroom, loves people and kids, but he runs free only if i am miles From others on the trails above the bay. Flag 102 Name: Andrea Allardyc , on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 103 Name: Anonymous on Jun 14, 2D12 Comments: "I am opposed to all off -leash dog program In Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks' Flag 104 Name: Anonymous on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I live close to Bachman Park. Flag 105 Name: Sue Dailor on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: it's common sense. Our children's safely Is the most important issue! Back yards are where you let your dog run free... Flag 106 Name: Charles Learning on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Member: CITIZENS AGAINST OFF LEASH IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS Flag 107 Name: Penelope ONeIII on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I love dogs, but kids and dogs running together is a disasterwaliing to happen. Please don't let this pass. Flag 108 Name: Karen Lekashman on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 199 Name: Doug Hartsell on Jun 14, 2912 1 of 5 6/1512012 2:30 PM No `Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures - Page 3 http: /Avww.ipetitiom.comfpedtion /no- off - leash- dogs -at- bachman -... Comments: Flag 110 Name: Anonymous on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 111 Name: Nancy Lux on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: There are so many young children that enjoy this park -It's a danger. I'm also confused why we need it -don't we have a dog park at Vasona? The parking Issue Is also another issue -It's crowded as is at times Flag 112 Name: Richard Titus on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Unleashed dogs are dangerous, especially to children and seniors, as they are out of control of their owners, who rarely pay attention to what their dogs are doing when off- leash. Flag 113 Name: Anonymous on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 114 Name: Mario Jere on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 115 Name: Mario Jere on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 110 Name: Mario Jars on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 117 Name: Mary Kalris on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I do not want "off leash" dogs hours. Keep them on a leash Flag 119 Name: Mary Kairls on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I do not want "off leash" dogs hours. Keep them on a leash Flag 119 Name: Lu Ann Flechsig on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Running and screaming children can excite and cause some dogs to bite. Dog poop is already a problem at our parks and Increasing usage of off -leash dogs is only going to make the problem worse. The greater majority of dog owners who walk their dogs on leash, are not comfortable being approached by off -leash dogs and some have been attacked by off -leash dogs. Why would Los Gatos even consider this when none of these concerns have been addressed? I attended all 4 meetings concerning offdeash dogs and the best and only answer the Parks Commission could give us is don't use the parks during the off -leash hours ?I I love and own dogs, but I don't think our parks should become an enter at your own risk because a very small group of people want to run their dogs unleashed and UNFENCED. Flag 120 2 of 5 6/15/2012 2:30 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures - Page 3 htt p:// www.ipetitions.com/petitiontno- off - leash- dogs- at- bachmm -.., Name: Eileen Fassler on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: 1. All dogs have the potential to be unsafe. (or the injured party) A leash allows control and safety for all concerned. It is very diffucult to separate off -leash dogs. If mine is on a leash and yours off ... both ere more likely to be Injuredl 2. The liability to the town is huge If there Is a problem with biting, property damage, etc. 3. There are fenced areas nearby where dogs can run unleashed... why put them into an open area and put all at risk? 4. Please, do NOT vote for an off -leash dog program In the Town of Los Gatos. Flag 121 Name: Kdsty Heston on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Yost I support this group. I'm deathly afraid of dogs. (was bitten riding my bike as a child) I have had to leave the park before because there was dogs off leash. Once when I asked the owner to leash his dog, he Just laughed. Thera are too many dogs taking over our parks. This has got to slopll Flag 122 Name: Irrational Douchebag on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: The world will come to an end If dogs are allowed off leash for two hours. Everyone knows that peak picnicking hours are between 7-gam 11 Flag 123 Name: Judy Glickman on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I'm opposed to "Off Leash Dog Hours" because of safety and enforcement Issues. Flag 124 Name: Mark Uniat on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 125 Name: Gary Walker on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I agree, the City is, in my opinion, aiding and abetting an unsafe environment for citizens and in particular Children. Flag 126 Name: Sandra Vaurs on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: It is irresponsible not to have a fence. Who will be sued when a dog bites a passerby? I hope not the town of Los Gatos, because my tax money will then pay for this bad idea. Flag 127 Name: Harry Campbell on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I strongly urge the LG Town Council to turn down the off4essh proposal. This Is an urgent child safety and security issue. Flag 12B Name: Anonymous on Jun 14, 2012 Comments; Flag 129 Name: Virginia Fiorentino on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: My dog was attacked by an off leash dog when I was at a park in La Jolla, CA. I will never forget IL If the town wants to have off leash areas, I suggest that they erect small encircled areas within each park..... Can be one area for small dogs and one for large dogs. Owners enter These areas at [heir own risk. Flag 130 3 of 5 6/15/2012 2:30 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures -Page 3 http: //www.ipetitions,com/petition/no -off- leash- dogs- at- bachman -... Name: 0 Poems RaJaroman on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 131 Name: Randy Martin on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 132 Name: Diane Schmidt on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Los Gatos needs a dedicated dog park to keep dogs and people safe Flag 133 Name: Kathy Hardin on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I am opposed to all off leash dog programs in Los Gatos. It Is not safe for anyone and It will change the nature of our nelghborhood parks. Flag 134 Name: Brad Clawsie on Jun 14, 20t2 Comments: Flag 135 Name: Christina Harms on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: This is an unsafe Idea. Please DO NOT put children at risk or being knocked over or worse yet, being bit by an off leash dog. Please keep our parks safe for kids Flag 136 Name: Claire Nippress on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: We are homeowners in the Glenridge neighborhood and our children often play at Bachman Park. We prefer dogs to stay an leash in the park for the safety of our children. Flag 137 Name: David Tdpier on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 138 Name: Bill Schmidt on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Please keep our parks safe and clean. Flag 138 Name: Anonymous on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I am a responsible dog owner, but there are simply too many irresponsible dog owners and too many unpredictable dogs that make this proposal ludicrous, Run your dog In your own backyard, or If you don't have the space, get your lazy butt In your car and drive over to one or the local dog parks. Flag 140 Name: Rebecca Hanson on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I AM STRONGLY OPPOSED TO THE OFF LEASH POLICY AT BACHMAN PARKIIIIIIII Flag 141 Name: Pamela Abaci on Jun 14, 2012 4 of 5 6/15/2012 2:30 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures - Page 3 htt p: /hvvm'.ipeti6ons.com/petition/no -off- leash- dogs- at- bachman -... Comments: While I may like dogs, I DO NOT WANT'Off Leash Dog Hours' at Bachman Park, or any of the Los Gatos neighborhood parks. I am opposed to all off -leash dog programs in Los Gatos. It Is not safe for anyone and It will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. Flag 142 Name: Anonymous on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 143 Name: Cathy Horton on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: A separate dog park should be built with fences around It. Pit Bulls are especially dangerous in a park with no fences. Flag 144 Name: Steph Harrison an Jun 14, 2012 Comments: Flag 145 Name: Gary P on Jun 14, 2012 Comments: I agree that the unfenced area being considered is not workable. It would have been better to look at a regular dog park with fence at the same time as alternative, at least we Could understand the trade -offs. Or could the town make a deal for free parking at the county dog park? Don't know how Bachman got picked here - this is more of a little kid's park than in ost in town. Flag 146 Name: Penny Blackwell on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: This is a terrible, terrible Idea to let people leave dogs unleashed. My son has been Jumped on and terrified twice at Alta Vista Elementary and both times the dog owners were barely apologetic. And this is WITH a leash law. Flag 147 Name: Anonymous on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: Flag 148 Name: Vida Pami on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: off leash dogs are dangarousl Don't take our parks from our children) Flag 149 Name: Anonymous on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: I live next to Bachman Park. I am a dog owner. I am against off -leash dogs. Flag 150 Name: Rosalinda Luna an Jun 15, 2012 Comments: I was attacked by an off leash dog that was "kid friendly° when I was a young girl and it - - - was wry traumatic. l would hate for my daughter or anyone's child to suffer and be fearful of dogs the rest of their lives. Please don't allow this. There are way too many careless dog owners out there. If this passes I will not be coming to Los Gatos parks any longer. Flag Page: e t 1, 2, 3, 4> s iPatifions is owned and operated by Angle Three Associates, LLC -All matenal is Copyright Angle Three Associates, LLC, 1998.2012 - Terms of Use 5 of 5 - 6/15/2012 2:30 PM No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks signatures - Page 4 Home > Categories > Other > No "Dogs Off Leash' In Los Gatos Parks No "Dogs Off Leash" In Los Gatos Parks Sign Slog Signatures Email friends http:// www.ipetitions.com/pelltion/no- off - leash - dogs -at- bachman -... Signatures 162 TOTAL Sign Petition Page: a t t, 2, 3, 4 Now! 151 Name: Carol Witter on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: Flag Sponsored links 152 Name; Lorena Martinez an Jun 15, 2012 Comments: Flag 153 Name: Nelson J. Rodrigues on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: When dogs are outside the home keep them on leashes for everyone's solely. Flag 154 Name: Anonymous on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: Dogs should never take priority over people. Period. I am tired of seeing people disregard law, safety and the concerns of others while letting their dogs run free In parks NOT designated as off - leash. If they have such disregard now, what makes anyone think they will have any when parks are made off- lea5h? To make a playground whom children play an area when; dogs can ran free, chase, coral, pee, poop and otherwise be a nuisance, is unsanitary and unsafe. To say it is already being done so we might as well make it legal so no one gets in trouble Is like saying we might as well make smoking marijuana legal, It's crazy. Just because they're doing it doesn't make it safe or right. Its simple, ticket them. Its the law. Perhaps use the money earned to find a separate, fenced off -leash area; that way dog owners can pay for what they want, not the rest of us. Flag 155 Name: Dolores McCarthy on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: Live walking distant from Buchman Park. The area Is too small to MIK people and unleashed dogs. Afenced area for the dogs or playground might work. Flag 156 Name: Janet Lehr on Jun 15. 2012 Comments: There has got to be a better area/park where a fenced in area can be created. My family just moved to the area and walk to this park almost daily. Love Its neighborhood atmosphere. Flag 157 Name: Kim Daly on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: As the former Lead of Los Gatos Unleashed, a committee dedicated to create an unleashed dog park, I do not support an unfenced dog park. Safety is at the biggest concern and I certainly hope council members get it. For well over a year a 112 block of Edaten has had dogs running off leash. Over the past few months one of the dogs has shown aggression and now has charged a Volunteer in Policing, a neighbor, myself, the Vice Mayor and her husband and the 1 of 2 6/1612012 9:14 AM IQo "Dogs Off Leash' In Los Gatos Parks signatures - Page 4 http: / /www.ipetitions,com/petit ion /no -off- leash - dogs- at- bachman -... mailman cannot deliver mail with a dog off leash. Hence soma days we do not get mall. The cost of having Animal Control, LGPD and Dave The Ranger spend welt over an hour trying to get the dog is nonsense. Los Gatos has budget constraints - is this the best use of our dollars with an out of control unfenced dog park? Can I also add the the Vice Mayor and her husband never reported the incident to the proper agencies, They contacted me and I in turn filed a report with Anima Control and LGPD. The dog was eventually picked up and later that day, back on the street off - leash. This Is an perfect example of dog owners behaving badly. If you can't control 112 block with one dog off leash, how the hell are you going to control severe[ parks with owners behaving badly and dozens of dogs off leash? Flag 158 Name: Anonymous on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: Flag 159 Name: Deborah Weinstein on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: Bachman Park Neighborl Please don't let more dogs make our park unsafe. My smell kids play there often. We love dogs, but off unknown leash dogs can be very frightening for my children. Flag 160 Name: Anonymous an Jun 15, 2012 Comments: Resident of Massa] Cf. Flag 161 Name: JoAnne Swing on Jun 15, 2012 Comments: Flag 162 Name: Mami Hunsaker on Jun 16, 2012 Comments: My dog was attacked and nearly killed at a Los Gatos by an off -leash dog. Flag Page: e r 1, 2, 3, 4 iPelitions is owned and operated by Angle Three Associates, LLC -AO material © Copyright Angle Three Assocates, LLC, 1998-2012- Terms of Use 2 of 2 6/16/2012 9:14 AM - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Tracey Enfantino [mailto:tenfantlno @eslte.net] Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:33 PM To: Steve Rice; BSpector; Steve Leonardis; dmcnutt @losgatooca.gov; jprizynskl @losgatosca.gov Cc: Todd Capurso; kpaisley @verizon.net Subject: Off Leash Opposition'jpirzynskl @losgatosca.gov' Importance: High June 13, 2012 Los Gatos Mayor and Council Dear Mayor Rice, Vice Mayor Spector, and Council Members Leonardis, McNut,t and Pirzynski, I am adamantly opposed to the off leash dog hours for Bachman Park. This poses a health hazard from feces left around to the most serious; dog attacks and bites. If a child is playing in the sandbox at the park - and a dog attacks the child, the Town is responsible- not just the dog owner! Where will the responsibility he when a non - vaccinated dog bites? Why is the council entertaining this! Please consider the HEALTH and SAFETY of park goers over the dogs, and dog owners off - leash gratification. f mo t: Tracey Enfantino 18611 Decatur Rd Monte Sereno Monte Sereno Resident 18611 Decatur Rd since 1995 Monte Sereno Resident Kavin Lane 1992 -1995 Los Gatos Resident 1972 -1983 cc: Todd Capurso via email - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Vikki Boyd, CCPDT -KA fmaflto :k9s4happiness(alyahoo,com] Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2012 12:42 PM To. Council Subject: Canine Body Language- A Pfctorial- CITIZENS AGAINST OFF LEASH DOGS IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS To the Council, "My dog loves kids ". A common statement made by many dog owners. The truth is, many dogs tolerate kids until threshold has been crossed. Dogs give very clear signals, yet these signals are missed or ignored by owners. When wamings are ignored, a dog may bite as a last resort. If more people were educated on canine body language this would significantly reduce the number of bites. California is the dog bite capital of the nation. This needs to change by A. keeping children under 6 years of age out of dog parks, and B. keeping dogs from accessing children (and visa versa). Examples of Potential Scenarios and Canine Warning Signals: Basic Facial Expression "Worried" Closed mouth, bard eye (staring), high set ear. This dog would not be safe to pet until he is relaxed. Ynt wuWnd,rsftyaway I likiayoa This toddler is approaching this dog with "love" attempting to feed it. This dog is clearly not comfortable with toddler as is evident by the dogs feet planted and the neck stretched in an attempt to keep it's distance while taking the food. If this toddler stumbled it may startled the dog and trigger an attack. The only reason this dog is tolerating this distance is because the child has food. This young pup is learning it can steal food from a children. This pup will grow up thinking it is acceptable to steal food from ALL children which leads to resource guarding behaviors. (Mine, stay away or Pll bite). In the event a child refuses to "share ", this can provoke a bite. This dog has learned it is acceptable to steal food fiom children. It is boldly attempting to snatch the food from the child's hand which is very close to the child's face. This child is approaching this dog with "love ". The child has no negative experiences that would cause him to be cautious around dogs. If he reached toward the dog, this dog may bite. The dog's lifted paw, weight on bind legs indicates this dog is unsure about children. This dog is NOT safe to pet. This dog is giving the ultimate and usually last resort, e.g., the child crossed this dogs distance threshold and the dog is not happy! The toddler is to young to understand he should be afraid. If the child began to scream, or rum away, there is a high likelihood this dog's prey instinct would be triggered. If council considers approving this pilot, how would the council propose to screen for dogs that weren't bombproof around children? Please remember, not all dogs will look like this dog in the last photo. For example, Cocker Spaniels are one of the top biters. And, how would citizens be ensured no close contact would occur between a dog and their child? "I am oppose to all off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks." "CITIZENS AGAINST OFF LEASH IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS ", Thank you. Sincerely, Vikki Foley -Boyd, CCPDT Member: Council for Certified Professional Dog Trainers AICC Obedience Competitor AKC Certified Canine Good Citizen Instructor and Evaluator Member: Association ofPet Dog Trainers Member: Therapy Dog International Advocate for Bite Prevention through Education Los Gatos Resident since 1963 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Zlata Kovac [ma ilto:zlata hmsvictorv.orel Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 3:10 PM To: Council Subject: CITIZENS AGAINST OFF LEASH Please DO NOT pass OFF -leash dogs in our parks. Zlata Kovac - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Susanne Moore [ mallto :susannejmoore(o)gmail.coml Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2D12 1028 AM To: Council Subject: Citizens Against Off Leash Dogs in our Neighborhood Parks I am opposed to all off leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. I am also opposed to dogs on or off leash at Music in the Park and Jazz in the Plazz in Los Gatos. Citizens Against Off Leash In Our Neighborhood Parks --- Original Message---- - From: Arnold Moore rmailtommoldmooreCfymail.coml Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2012 11:10 AM To: Council Subject: Citizens Against Off Leash Dogs in our Neighborhood Parks I am opposed to all off leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. I am also opposed to dogs on or off leash at Music in the Park and Jazz in the Plazz in Los Gatos. Citizens Against Off Leash In Our Neighborhood Parks - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Becky Hanson < becky.hanson@gmail.com > Date: Thursday, June 14, 2012 12:56 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @losaatosca.aov Cc: " kpaislev @verizon.net < koaislev @verizon.net Subject: CITIZENS AGAINST OFF LEASH IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS I am opposed to all off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. Becky Hanson visit us at www.hansonl(ids.com - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Carol Witter rmailto :carolwitter(&gmail.coml Sent: Friday, June 15, 2012 8:38 AM To; Council Subject: CITIZENS AGAINST OFF LEASH IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS I am opposed to all off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. Sincerely, Carol Witter resident of LG mother of a 7 year old and a 3 year old 2nd grade teacher at Blossom Hill School who uses Blossom Hill Park as a place to bring her class for field trips each year - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Jay Plett fmailtolay@schloh.coml Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 5:13 PM To: Council Subject: Dog leash law opposition I am opposed to all off -leash dog programs in Los Gatos. It will not be safe for the public, especially children. Such a policy would be detrimental to the nature of our neighborhood parks. Please vote against this proposal. Thank you, Jay Plett - -- Original Message--- - From: Architecture bySchloh Imailto: arch itect(aschloh.coml Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 5:14 PM To: Council Subject: Dog leash law opposition I am opposed to all off -leash dog programs in Los Gatos. It will not be safe for the public, especially children. Such a policy would be detrimental to the nature of our neighborhood parks. Please vote against this proposal. Thank you, Gary Schloh - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Barbara McInerney [mallto :barbara mcinerneK@yahoo.coml Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 11:11 AM To: Council Cc: ton a lambertf 1hoo com Subject: I am a citizen against off -leash dogs in our parks Hello Town of Los Gatos, I am opposed to all off -leash dog programs in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. Barbara McInerney, mother of 2 56 Ellenwood Ave Los Gatos, CA - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Stoboys < stobovsftverizon.net > Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 9:27 AM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice@1osaatosca.aov > Subject: I vote no on off- leash) "I am opposed to all off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks." Michelle Stojanovich Citizen against off -leach law in our neighborhood parks Sent from my !Phone - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Raquel Connolly lmailto :raquelconnolly0yahoo.com1 Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 5:39 PM To: Council Subject: OFF LEASH DOG ATTACK Dear Council Members, I feel compelled to share this story with you: My husband is a plastic surgeon and yesterday a family came in with their 3 year old girl that was attacked by a friendly dog at the park. This 3 year old girl has over 10 scars on her face: a large cut all the way to her skull across her forehead, cuts on both her cheeks, on her lips and across her neck. This is going to result in numerous obvious scars all over this little girl's face for the rest of her life. Unfortunately these accidents happen all the time and no one likes to talk about them. We love dogs and they should have a place to run free in a designated fenced in area, away from children. Please take this case into consideration when you decide if dogs should be allowed off leash in some of our parks. Raquel Connolly - - --- Original Message---- - From: adonkathy rmalito:adonkathk @ aol Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2012 8:37 AM To: Council Subject: Off leash dog parks Dear Council, I am a dog lover and owner for over 60 years. I have adopted two dogs from rescue shelters. I believe dogs need a place to run free. BUT the place for the dogs to run free MUST be a fenced in dog park similar to the Campbell dog park. I do not believe in an off leash dog park that is not fenced in and designated a dog park. I feel strongly that the Council if it approves an off leash dog park is just asking for a law suit. It would not be a responsible decision to approve such a park. I would request that Council look into a fenced dog park much like the one in Campbell. I am sure most dog owners would much prefer a safe fenced in park for their dog than an unfenced park. I hope you vote down the Off Leash Dog Park and consider a fenced in dog park. Sincerely, Kathy Anderson 17670 Foster Rd. Los Gatos, 95030 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: harry campbell < harrvrcampbell@gmalI.com > Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 11:23 AM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice losgatosca.eov Subject: Off Leash Dog Proposal for our Town parks Dear Steve Rice, I am a 40 year resident of our lovely Town of Los Gatos and I have enjoyed the use of our wonderful parks with my children when they were young, and now with my grandchildren. I have carefully followed the "Dogs Off Leash" proposal for our Town's parks both in person and via the articles and letters in our weekly newspaper. I attended the first of the three community meetings and also the Town Park Commission meeting and at both I expressed my strona opposition to such a proposal. My reasons are many: Child Safety, health concerns (baby's crawling on the park grass after a dog off leash session), liability (for incidents, bites or attacks), enforcement of restrictions, monitoring of the project and my fear that if this proposal is implemented our parks will be a magnet for many residents of nearby communities to overload our already quite busy parks. I have also read the proposal presented to the Town's Parks Commission by staff and I found it to be missing clear objectives, measurement criteria, reporting specification, etc. In other words I don't think it is a valid and Implemental proposal. However, my main objection is that it did not adequately describe the opposition to this proposal that I saw at the public meeting by physicians (a pediatrician and a plastic surgeon - both residents), dog owners, several children and other concerned residents. So, in summary, I feel that the endorsement of this proposal by the parks commission (6 yea votes, 2 nay votes and two abstentions, if my recollection is correct) does not reflect the will of the people as expressed in public meetings. I respectfully request that you vote to not implement this off leash proposal Ciao. Harry Campbell 262 Casitas Bulevar Los Gatos - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Patricia Ford [mailto:fordsr5@comcast.net] Sent: Friday, June 15, 2012 9:34 AM To: Council Cc: Lu Ann Subject: Off leash dogs in Los Gatos Parks Hello, I know that there is a pilot proposal to allow off leash dogs in Los Gatos parks before you on Monday. I definitely oppose the approval of the pilot program. Just last month I was attacked by an off leash dog in the neighborhood adjacent to Oak Meadow park and Vasona park. I was walking with my small dog (on a leash) and a friend on the sidewalk and an off leash dog two houses away from where I was rushed at us and attacked me and my friend. We had done nothing to provoke the attack, I picked up my dog before this boxer could get to him and he leapt up on me and bit my arm and my leg in a frenzy to get to me or my dog. I handed the dog to my friend and then the boxer attacked my friend's arm. I received a deep dog bite on my arm and a shallower one on my leg with multiple scratches. My friend sustained a dog bite that went to the bone. The dog was hanging off my friend's arm. The owner came out and subdued the dog and we went to the emergency room for our injuries. The owner told us that her dog had never injured anyone before and this behavior had never been manifested before. She even had an infant in her house. Both myfriend and I have been somewhat traumatized by this incident and so has my dog. We are wary of any large dog now and carry red pepper spray with us on our walks. You never know what may happen when you are dealing with dogs. It is much much better to be safe than sorry, so I urge you to not allow off leash dogs in parks where there is a potential for people and other dogs to be injured. There is a perfectly good dog park nearby in Campbell where I take my dog. If you want to have off leash dogs, then why don't you create a fenced in dog park? Thank you, Pat Ford resident of the town of Los Gatos -Original Message---- - From: John Boucher Q ohn Boncherna CEI.coin Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:22 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice@los¢atosca.gov > Subject: Off leash hours for Bachman Park Steve, I am opposed to this proposed off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. 'thank you -Original Message---- - From: Tracey Enfantino < tenfantino@esite.net > Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:32 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice @loseatcsca.gov >, BSpector < BSpector @loseatosca.eov Steve Leonardis < SLeonardis @lossatosca.eov " dmmutt@loseatsoca.¢ov " < dmcnutt@loseatsoca.gov >, " jprizynski @Ioseatosca.Rov < jprizynski @loseatcsca.aov Cc: Todd Capurso < tcaourso @losaatosca.¢ov >, " koaislev @verizon.net < koaislev @verizon.net Subject: Off Leash Opposition 'ipirzvnski @losgatosca.eov June 13, 2012 Los Gatos Mayor and Council Dear Mayor Rice, Vice Mayor Spector, and Council Members Leonardis, McNutt and Pirzynski, I am adamantly opposed to the off leash dog hours for Bachman Park. This poses a health hazard from feces left around to the most serious; dog attacks and bites. If a child is playing in the sandbox at the park - and a dog attacks the child, the Town is responsible- not just the dog owner! Where will the responsibility lie when a non - vaccinated dog bites? Why is the council entertaining this! Please consider the HEALTH and SAFETY of park goers over the dogs, and dog owners off - leash gratification. Tracey Enfantino 18611 Decatur Rd Monte Sereno Monte Serene Resident 18611 Decatur Rd since 1995 Monte Serene Resident Kavin Lane 1992 -1995 Los Gatos Resident 1972 -1983 cc: Todd Capurso via email - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Pamela Maher fmailto•g_maher(caneuropace coml Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2012 11:16 AM To: Council Subject: Off -Lease Dogs Not A Good Idea To Whom It May Concern: I am writing as urged by the folks supporting the petition against the proposed off -leash pilot program to express my opposition to the Idea of enabling or encouraging off -leash dogs. The suggested language is: "I am opposed to all off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks." Additionally, it seems to me that the town's money or risk allocation ought to be spent on something that serves the humans, not the domestic pets, in the community. Where is the money going to come from it the town gets sued If someone gets hurt by an off -leash pitbull or Rottweiler? Has someone run some numbers about this? If this is going to be the only off -lease option for people outside of Los Gatos, does it make sense for the town to take on the liability? Also, in Los Angeles at least, people used to abandon unwanted dogs at dog parks all the time, and there was always an Increase in this behavior whenever the economy was depressed. This is bad for the dogs that are abandoned, bad for the dogs with owners who still want them when they show up at the park and some abandoned dog is trying to defend its territory, bad for the humans who use the parks, bad for the people who are charged with maintaining the parks, and a strain on the limited resources of the town's (or the county's) animal control organization (assuming that there is one). I am a dog owner, and there are times that I would love to let my dogs just run free someplace other than my backyard, but want I want and what I think is best for the community (including the humans who just aren't "dog people" or who have had some traumatic experience with dogs) are in this circumstances not the same thing. Thank you for your consideration. Pamela Maher - - - -- Original Message---- - From: suman seshadn rmailto:suman sesha(c)yahoo.comj Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 10:29 PM To: Council Subject: Off -Leash dog park Dear Council members, "I am opposed to all off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks." Thanks! Suman Seshadn 128 Lester Lane Los Gatos, CA 95032 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: richard carlson < tovcarlsonfthotmail.com > Date: Thursday, June 14, 2012 9:43 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice@Iosgatosca.gov >, BSpector < BSpector@losgatosca.gov >, Steve Leonardis < SLeonardis(@losgatosca.gov >, Diane McNutt < dmcnutt@Iosgatosca.gov >, Joe Pirzynski < JPirzvnski@ losgatosca.gov Subject: Opposed to off leash dog program Los Gatos Parks Richard Carlson who resides at 231 Belmont Avenue at Bachmann Park declare "I am opposed to all off - leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks." Elizabeth Carlson who resides at 231 Belmont Avenue at Bachmann Park declare "I am opposed to all off - leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and It will change the nature of our neighborhood parks." We have lived across the street from Bachmann Park for 38 years. We need to encourage responsible behavior from dog owners. The law enforcement agencies, the police and the parks departments, have always encouraged and enforced the leash laws for dogs in public to promote good will and safety among citizens and to avoid endangerment to everyone's well being, be it human or animal, and avoid destruction of public and private property. Dogs are animals and the primary reason why people own dogs as pets is for protection. One may argue for companionship. Dogs are great companions but their primary motive is to protecttheir owner. To protect, dogs attack. Any unharnessed dog can cause harm or death to others and to property, or even Injury or death to Itself when it runs across a busy street chasing another animal. A dog on a leash can be better controlled and held back from attacking and injuring human beings and other animals and from destroying property when their innate natural instincts take over, Even a dog on a leash can exhibit great strength and be out -of - control although their master is close at hand. A dog off leash will be just an accident waiting to happen. - - - -- Original Message---- - From: richard Carlson fmailto :toycarlson(ilhotmall.coml Sent: Friday, June 15, 20121:27 PM To: Janette Judd Cc: richard Carlson Subject RE: Opposed to off leash dog program Los Gatos Parks I assure you that if one incident ever occurs like the one reported today in San Diego that the Town will be sued for millions. By NBC News and msnbccom staff An 8 -month -old infant boy was mauled and killed by at least one dog Thursday evening in a San Diego suburb, according to the county Sheriffs Department, Follow (dinsabc us Up to three dogs may have been involved in the attack, which happened just before 5 p,m, on the 3000 block of West Street in Lemon Grove, east of downtown San Diego, NBC5anDieno -com reported. The circumstances of the attack were unclear, but deputies arrived within four minutes of getting the cal, San Diego sheriff's homicide Lt. Larry Nesbit told The San Diego Union - Tribune Advese / AdChaices Read the ghgaatNBCSanDlego.com The child was pronounced dead at Rady's Children Hospital, the Los Angeles Times reported, Authorities confirmed that three pit bulls were hauled away from the scene by Animal Control officers, N6C5anD1ego.com reported 'They were aggressive, "Nesbit told N8CSanDiego,com. "They were restralned by animal control officers with the tools they have," Its not clear if the bay's family owned the dogs or If the attack happened at their home, 7 can't even imagine losing a child and to know that a family pet did It," next-door nelghbor Regina Marlow told NBCSanDiego,com, 'That's horr/fic. I can't even imagine what the family would be going through," Neighbor Deirdra Canty said the dogs had been known to attack cats before, I don't think that a dog like a pit bull, rotfweller, large dogs should be around little infants, "Canty said. Da, Hello, this is just one reason dogs must be on a leash: Miles and miles of State beaches do not allow dogs off - leash. I wonder why. Do you suppose there are children playing at the beach? City parks in Pleasanton have fenced off dog runs and play areas for dogs at the far back end of parks, Hello, the dog area is fenced off with about a 4' high wire fence to protect the kids and picnic areas with one gate entrance for the dog and dog owner. Kids do not enter the dog run area and dogs do not enter the kids park play area. Why does Los Gatos want to be the only city that allows dogs to run free. Wow, as soon as this hits the newspapers, people from Santa Cruz County, Scotts Valley and Santa Clara valley can bring their dogs to Los Gatos and let em run wild. That means more people will be parking in front of our homes on Bachman and Belmont avenue even though there are "No Parking Sign /poles" posted now and people still park and use our driveways to make u -turns and back in and out of our driveways constantly or block our driveways. Ellenwood Avenue is extreemly narrow and hardly room for two cars to pass by where the dog owners take their dogs and night and the owners park there cars on Ellenwood which adds mor congestion to a narrow street by the park. The city does not enforce the "No parking rules on our streets across from Bachman Park, and the city does not enfore the dogs on leash law now and the city does not police the "Park Closed at Dark" rule - so why change any laws or rules at all since the city does not enforce the laws now. Ok, you may save a few hundred dollars by not having to pay an officer to enforce the parking sign laws or the dog leash laws or the park closed rule at night, but one lawsuit will quickly eliminate any money saved by non - enforcement of current park rules and dog leash rules and /or street parking rules across from the park. Allowing dogs to run loose only in Los Gatos parks makes no sense at all. It is either political friends or a city trying to save a few bucks by eliminating any enforcemnet code costs. The only dog runs I have seen at city parks have been fenced in. When this first hit the papers, one of the council members said great, this will give us time to evaluate what the other cities are doing. So what was the result of contacting all the other cities in santa clara county - or did he even contact any other cities. lust 20 minitues ago I drove home to my house on Belmont Avenue, and a 1 -2 year old child was playing in the same grass area(hill) where all the dog owners now congregate in the evenings to let their dogs run loose - as few people at Bachman park honor the dog leash law. The child likes to roll down the hill - which could be contaminated with do poop. Some of these dogs are huge. Dogs like to chase the squirrels, cats and other dogs in the park now. Owners park their trucks(with big dogs) and or cars any direction on the street, any side of street even though there are no parking signs posted on one side of the street and the dog owners come at all times of the morning, day or night, Many of the owners use a ball throwing apparatus to toss a ball 100 -200 feet in the park area so that the dog can chase it down and bring the ball back(sometimes). then the owner is mean to the dog if the dog does not bring the ball back. Some owners are rude and abusive to their own pets when In the park when the dog does not respond properly. bad rule change - leave the dogs on a leash and or build a fenced off area for the dogs. Maybe the dog owners will pay for a fenced off area. of course dog run areas in other city parks do not have the green grass to play In so the owner would not like It without grass. bad Idea If dogs allowed off leash. Richard Carlson 231 Belmont Avenue Los Gatos, CA 95030 - - -- Original Message---- - From: Julie Martinez [ mailto :seedzmeanfruitz@gmail.coml Sent: Friday, June 15, 2012 8:36 AM To: Council Subject: Opposed to off leash dogs in the parks I am expressing my opposition to the measure that would allow dogs to be off -leash in Los Gatos parks. I use the parks with my two small children, who would be put in danger by this proposal. Fenced -in dog parks are wonderful places for dogs and their owners to play. I have often taken my dog to dedicated dog parks. However, I also find them to be full of poop and dogs of questionable safety for small children — rambunctious pit bulls and the like. This is not the experience that I want to have when I go to a neighborhood park or playground with my children. Please keep the dogs on -leash in the neighborhood parks. Best, Julie Martinez - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Barbara Dodson < btdodson @aol.com Date: Friday, June 15, 201211:02 AM To: Joe Pirzynski < JPirzvnski @losgatosca.go_v >, BSpector < l33Spector @losgatosca.gov >, "Stephen M. Rice" <srice @losgatosca.9ov >, Steve Leonardis <SLeonardisC@losgatosca.Rov >, Diane McNutt < dmcn utt @losgatosca.gov Cc: " kpaislev @verizon.net < kpaisley @verizon. net >, " k9s4haooiness @vahoo.com < k9s4hapoiness @yahoo.com " luannf @comcast.net < luannf @comcast.net Subject: Opposed to Off -Leash Dog Program I am opposed to having an off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone, and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. Barbara Dodson Supporter of Citizens Against Off -Leash in Our Neighborhood Parks - - - -- Original Message--- - On 6/15/1212:39 AM, "Laura Murphy - Wilkens" < ]auramwCcbverizon.net > wrote: >Please do not implement an off leash dog policy even on a trial basis >at any of our neighborhood parks. It is simply too dangerous to have >dogs off leash when children are present. I live near Bachman Park, and >I often visit the park with my two boys and friends after school until >dinner time or later during the summer and they love to run around and >play on the grass and up on the hill. I would never be comfortable >having them play at the park if dogs were present off leash. I do not >think it is fair to restrict our enjoyment of the park. >I am an avid dog lover. My dog was my first "child ", and I had him > longer than I've known my husband or my children. He was the type of >dog my friends were comfortable having their child get to know because >he was so trustworthy, but as he got older, I could no longer trust him >around children and the last two years of his life, I had to be so >careful with him around my two boys that I had to keep them physically >separated when I could not be right there watching. Many dog owners, >especially those without children, believe their dog would never harm a >child, but young children do not always understand limits and may move >too abruptly or touch with too much force to cause even a gentle >dog to snap or bite. Young children naturally approach dogs and want >to pet them, so it is not practical to assume that parents will be able >to keep their children away from off leash dogs. >We visit parks often and I encounter dogs on leash that have to be >restrained by their owner who are barking and straining to get at a dog >or my child. I have no idea how you can prevent owners of these dogs >from visiting our parks and allowing these dogs off leash. One off > leash dog chasing and biting a child is one trial too many. We simply >can't risk the life of any child in our town. I am not even sure how >the town legal council could allow such a trial to be initiated. The >real solution is to create a fenced dog park where dogs and only dogs >are allowed so they can run free without endangering any child. >Realize that I have used these dog parks in other towns and I have >witnessed dog fights. Last year I was helping a woman whose dog was >bitten in the campbell dog park. There is simply no way to rationally >justify exposing any child using our town parks to this possibility. > There can be no guarantee the dog owner is responsible and the dog >will remain in control no matter what a child does. - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Handrsi < handrsiPaol.com > Date: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 8:53 PM To: "Stephen M. Rice" < srice(@1osaatosca.aov > Subject: opposition off leash dog parks I have been a Los Gatos Bachman Park Neighbor for 32 years now. My husband and I are adamantly opposed to use of Bachman and other neighhood parks for off leash dogs. The current move by the Recreation Department for legalizing off leash use of our neighborhood park is a considerable safety - hazard , liability for the City and Tax payers, and not in the best interestes of the citizens of Los Gatos or Los Gatos Property Values and Tax base. We came to Los Gatos for the safe environment for our children who literally grew up using this park. We came to Los Gatos for the "Family Centered" environment that put children and educational excellence high on the list. Dogs unleashed in a 1 blk park with a children's play area and sand box is irresponsible. Already I have had a direct view of multiple groups of owners entering the park and unleashing their dogs. While they chat in a close group the dogs are free. I entered the park and was charged within 2 -3 seconds by 3 dogs. while the dog owners called at a distance hoping their dogs would stop. The largest dog was at least chest height on me. Do you truly expect adults or children to be safe with dogs off leash. If they could reach me in 3 seconds, they could reach the children or other pedestrians In 3 seconds. With dogs off leash there is increased risk of physical injury and biohazard from residual waste on lawns and sandboxes. These facilities were designed and meant for people to use. These lawns and parks are not meant to dog runs. Just for the few dog owner meetings to the park, there has been unsafe parking along the road on Ellenwood which is narrown and no designed for parking. The neighborhood and local users need the existing parking. The simple annoucement of the possible opening of this park attracted too many cars already. I do NOT see the majorigy owners "cleaning up " after their dogs, but I have witnessed them encouraging the dogs to use lawns or bush areas for excrement versus exercise. Not even the dog owners suggest that they would ever clean up the dog urine or repair the damage to lawns which are already suffering from neglected maintence. I also see more dog left avers left behind in front of our home by dogs on the way to and from the park even though it is not yet a dog park. I am very disappointed in the conduct shown by the team leading the community meetings. They made it quite clear that the town has not been interested in enforcing the existing law , nor do they think they will have a responsibility to enforce any changes. Instead it is quite clear that they expect vague, loosely organized citizens in favor of dog parks to "police the use of the off leash hours ". I was clear told that these groups will have now additional legal liability insurance requirements . This is unbelievable. This means that ordinary neighbors , not a part of these groups are left to intervene in an "unsafe" dog situation or call the Los Gatos Police. Being in the medical field I have personally taken care of the hands, arms and faces of the damage from unleashed dogs . These Injuries can be disabling, and disfiguring and leave life long physical and psychological damage. This is what city leadership will be voting on. A yes vote of the city council makes the council, town and tax payers liable for the town decision. A responsible decision is NO, off leash use of neighbor hood parks. Let the off leash dog groups raise funds for an off leash park. They can do the fund raisers, buy the land or pay the city and county for use of existing areas and provide the insurance. This would be similar to the effort to get a skate board park for the special interest group. - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Anne - Michelle Frances [mailto:ampfrances(a gmail.com Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2012 2:52 PM To: Council Subject: Opposition to Dogs Off -Lease Pilot Program Dear Council Members, I am opposed to all off -leash dog program in Los Gatos. My 51/2 -year old son is deathly allergic to dog saliva, and there is no way to control his proximity to dogs unless they are on a leash. Sincerely, CITIZENS AGAINST OFF LEASH IN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD PARKS - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Randy Martin [ mailto :randyemartin(8cimail.coml Sent: Thursday, June 14, 2012 11:46 AM To: Council Cc: Lu Ann Subject: opposition to off -leash program I am opposed to all off -leash dog programs in Los Gatos. It is not safe for anyone and it will change the nature of our neighborhood parks. - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Patti Lovetro- Clarke [mailto:opulent interiors(alyaheo com] Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:13 PM To: Town PPW; Council Subject: FW: unleashed dog attack From a local doctor's wife: On the heels of Jen's e-mail I wanted to share this story with everyone: My husband is a plastic surgeon and today a family came in with their 3 year old girl that was attacked by a friendly dog at the park. This 3 year old girl has over 10 scars on her face: a large cut all the way to her skull across her forehead, cuts on both her cheeks, on her lips and across her neck, This is going to result in numerous obvious scars all over this little girl's face for the rest of her life. If you oppose to having off leash dogs in parks where our children play, I urge you to come to this meeting so one of our babies doesn't become a victim like the little girl my husband treated today. Unfortunately these accidents happen all the time. -Original Message---- - From: Kate Paisley [mallto :kpaisley @verizon.net] Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 8:19 AM To: Council; Town PPW Subject: Tragic incident... A reminder that these kind of tragic incidents do occur. Please do not pass the off -leash dog hours at any of our parks. - - -- Forwarded Message - - - -- From: Raquel Connolly < raouelconnollvCo).vahoo.com > Sent: Tuesday, June 12, 2012 10:04 PM Subject: Re: [LMLGS20091 Re: Unleashed Dogs On the heels of Jen's e-mail I wanted to share this story with everyone: My husband is a plastic surgeon and today a family came in with their 3 year old girl that was attacked by a friendly dog at the park. This 3 year old girl has over 10 scars on her face: a large cut all the way to her skull across her forehead, cuts on both her cheeks, on her lips and across her neck. This is going to result in numerous obvious scars all over this little girl's face for the rest of her life. If you oppose to having off leash dogs in parks where our children play, I urge you to come to Us meeting so one of our babies doesn't become a victim like the little girl my husband treated today. Unfortunately these accidents happen all the time Raquel - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Patti Lovetro- Clarke [mailto :opulent.interiors @yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2012 2:11 PM To: Town PPW; Council Subject: unleashed dog attack On the heels of Jen's e -mail I wanted to share this story with everyone My husband is a plastic surgeon and today a family came in with their 3 year old girl that was attacked by a friendly dog at the park. This 3 year old girl has over 10 scars on her face: a large cut all the way to her skull across her forehead, cuts on both her cheeks, on her lips and across her neck. This is going to result in numerous obvious scars all over this little girl's face for the rest of her life. If you oppose to having off leash dogs in parks where our children play, I urge you to come to this meeting so one of our babies doesn't become a victim like the little girl my husband treated today. Unfortunately these accidents happen all the time. - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Alison McGann fmailto:alimcgann @yahoo.com] Sent: Monday, June 18, 2012 9:47 AM To: Steve Rice; BSpector; Steve Leonardis; Diane McNutt; Joe Pirzynski Cc: Town PPW Subject: OPPOSE Off -Leash Dear Council Members, I strongly oppose the proposal to allow off -leash dog hours at Bachman Park. I live in the immediate vicinity of the park on Alexander Avenue. My children have grown up playing at Bachman Park. It's a lovely neighborhood park and a haven for families with young children. Our neighborhood is very tight -knit and we have enjoy several annual neighborhood parties, including a community Easter Egg hunt every year as well as an end- of- school party (the most recent party took place on Friday, June 8, 2012). Allowing dogs off -leash is not compatible with a neighborhood park and playground suited for young children. No time slot is a good time slot for off -leash dogs. I remember an occasion when a neighborhood dog escaped the confines of his yard. Parents were very nervous, play was disrupted, and the dog ate my picnic sandwich right off the picnic table. From this experience, it's clear that allowing dogs off -leash will change the nature of our park. I urge you to vote no to this proposal. Thank you, Alison McGann Citizens Against Off -Leash in Our Neighborhood Parks - - -- Original Message--- - From: Kate Paisley [mailto:kpaisley@verizon.net] Sent: Monday, June 18, 201211:30 AM To: Council; Steve Leonardis; Diane McNutt; Steve Rice; Joe Pirzynski; BSpector; jpropp@losgatos.gov; manager @losgatos.gov; Town PPW Subject: Letter from the Petition from Ian and Gail Jardine I'm forwarding this letter from the petition (signature #175). It has not been altered or change. Name: Ian and Gail Jardine on Jun 18, 2012 Comments: Dear Council Members, Our property on Glen Ridge Avenue literally backs up to Bachman Park.ln our recent experience, the presence of many off -leash dogs in Bachman Park (not currently allowed) has resulted in some frightening episodes with large dogs accosting ourfour -year grand- daughter and us. Our grand- daughter became terribly afraid, and we have had to abandon our own nearby park -- Bachman -- in our efforts to protect her. The outcome for us has been that Bachman Park has now become nearly unusable for us - -and this is without no -leash hours. Further, to open this park would bring in hundreds of dogs from the surrounding areas, and Bachman Park would cease to be a "people" park for Los Gatos, it will soon become a dog -only park, full of dogs without restraints. We have had much difficulty with many dog owners who regard their own dogs as harmless when, in fact, their dogs are far more aggressive that the owners will permit. There is no talking sense to them, there is no way to reach them, and they appear to feel entitled to have their dogs "roam free," as many have told us. We urgently request that the Town Council VOTE DOWN this proposal for the safety reasons. In addition, we do not want the Bachman Park area clogged with the traffic of hundreds of extra cars, nor the peace of our area broken by turning it into an open dog area. To allow off - leashed dogs at Bachman Park will change our neighborhood drastically for the worse, and we urge the Town Council, PLEASE, please to vote it down. We also request greater vigilance at the present in citing owners who have dogs off leash. Sincerely yours, Ian and Gail Jardine !an.d.iardine @amail.com abieail.iardine@amail.com - - - -- Original Message--- - From: Kim Greenway [ mailto :greenaprils(ilamall.coml Sent: Monday, June 18, 2012 8:52 AM To: Council Subject: Bachman and Live Oak Manor — In Support of Proposal Dear Council Members, I would like to voice my support for the proposed off -leash hours at Bachman and Live Oak Manor Park. I feel that it is good public policy, creating possible revenue to the city with increase usage of these spaces and will not decrease the overall safety of the park. Additionally, it gives the community a chance to interact with the good dogs and good dog owners of the community. Thank you, Kim Cneenway South Bay Resident, Dog Owner - - -- Original Message---- - From: Joe Madden rmallto:joe snorkelboyftahoo.coml Sent: Monday, June 18, 2012 9:50 AM To: Council Subject: Dog Park Please do not make Live Oak Manor a dog park .... the neighborhood kids play there and putting up fences throughout the park will ruin their baseball and soccer games. I'm happy to coexist with dogs, and in fact this park already serves as an off -leash dog park a lot of the time. Nobody seems to mind much because the park is fairly self - contained. The problem would be that the park would be ruined for other purposes if you put up barriers for various kinds of dogs. There is no need to change the layout of the park. Please do not put up a bunch of fences to break the park up into small blocks. Joe Madden Neighbor 408 499 8747 - - - -- Original Message---- - From: Lu Ann imailto:luannfecomcast.netl Sent: Monday, June 18, 2012 11:36 AM To: Council Subject: Dogs off -leash and unfenced and Park Commission meeting - dog bite statistics for Los Gatos, 2011, 2012 I wrote earlier saying that I have attended all 4 meetings in regards to dogs off -leash and unfenced pilot program in our parks. I mentioned that I was shocked that Todd put the proposal through and completely ignored all the concerns that were brought up at the meetings, which included these things that are already taking place in our parks as a result of the city ignoring the on -leash dog rules. Dogs knocking down children,-some taking kids food,.dog.poopingand peeing all over, and-SOME owners not picking up after them, creating a smelly, dirty environment that also passes contagious disease into the ground, off -leash dogs attacking on -leash dogs, making it a place to avoid, and also ignoringthe advice of expert dog behaviorists and trainers, professionals, and organizations like San Jose Animals Services, The Humane Society and most veterinarians about unfenced off -leash dogs and www.kidshealth.or¢'s info about contagious diseases found in the grounds that are used as dog parks. I asked two pediatricians what their opinions were about shared space and they would not recommend that. I was shocked to learn afterwards that none of the many letters that people sent in were ever given to the Parks Commissioners and that the Chair of the committee's wife is actually active supporter of off - leash unfenced dogs at our parks. So most of these commissioners were voting on an issue they really had very little info on since only a few of them even attended any of the meetings. I have to say the two that did attend, with the exception of the Chair, one was against off - leash, and one wanted to have our concerns addressed, which I greatly appreciated. I found the whole process unprofessional. In your own town page, and response letter to people that write in, you specifically list ppw@losgatosca.gov as the address to write in. Why then, would this information not be provdedto every parks commissioner ?I San Jose Animal Care & Services has provided me with the following dog biting humans information. In 2011, there were 28 bites, in 2012, 9 for up to end of May, and 2 of those bites were from the same dog on 2 people trying to protect their leashed dog from being attacked by an unleashed dog. (One of the people sent you a letter too.) This "family" dog had never done something like this they said and they have a baby in the home. I'm sure all these dogs' owners would swear they never thought their dog would do this. California is now the top dog bite state and children makeup half of the total. These statistics do not even include dog on dog attacks, again mostly off -leash dogs approaching or attacking an on -leash dog. Humans are also bit in many of these cases trying to protect their dog. Dogs off -leash and unfenced is unsafe and unfair to park goers that do not want to risk encountering dogs, and the other more than 95% of the dog owners that do not let their dogs off - leash. What we really need is a remote fenced dog park that will serve the needs of the majority of dog owners and keep our parks safe and clean. --_Original Message- - From: Lu Ann [mailto:luannf(acomcast.netl Sent: Monday, June 18, 2012 12;34 PM To: Janette Judd Subject: Re: Dogs off -leash and unfenced and Park Commission meeting - dog bite statistics for Los Gatos, 2011, 2012 I forgot to mention that there were 12 dog bites in 2010. And please note the incident with the pitbull in town square doesn't seem to have been reported, though I am told it took place by others. I will have the info available at the meeting if the council would like to verify this info. I only have it online and wanted to black out the actual address and just leave the street and dog breed info. - - - -- Original Message - - -- From: Hartmut Esslinger < Hartmut.Esshnger cr,froedesien.com Date: June 18, 2012 11:18:25 AM PDT To: " srice ,losgatosca.gov < srice ,losgatosca.eov Subject: Dogs on Leash Please! Dear Major Rice, Tonight will be another meeting with "dogs on leashes ?" on the agenda. I don't know, how you and your council members define democracy, but when the constitutional rights of people for health and safety are pushed away for the sake of irresponsible dog owners, you are crossing a line. My daughter has a serious dog phobia after she and my wife got attacked by an un- leashed dog at age two (without the instant help of two construction workers she and my wife would have been badly hurt). So we had to cancel our near daily walks to Oak Meadow and Vasona, because dogs are still at large there. The other problem you are supporting by your current policies is sickening hygienics: there is no place without dog poop and urine contamination left in Los Gatos. I grew up on a farm with animals including a wonderful German Shephard: dogs by themselves are innocent, guilty are the owners and at least one City Council member. Sincerely Hartmut Esslinger Prof. Dr. Hartmut Essliuger 15920 Rose Avenue Los Gatos, CA 95030, USA Global Mobile: +1(408)431 -5025 Mail: hral�esimeom blog: ws Sroemutxom twitter w xwittecuumif uraut - - - -- Original Message--- - From: Kate Paisley Imailto:koaislev @verizon.netl Sent: Monday, June 18, 201211:30 AM To: Council; Steve Leonardis; Diane McNutt; Steve Rice; Joe Pirzynski; BSpector; ior000@losgatos.gov manager @losgatos.gov; Town PPW Subject: Letter from the Petition from Ian and Gail Jardine I'm forwarding this letter from the petition (signature #175). It has not been altered or change Name: Ian and Gail Jardine on Jun 18, 2012 Comments: Dear Council Members, Our property on Glen Ridge Avenue literally backs up to Bachman Park.ln our recent experience, the presence of many off -leash dogs in Bachman Park (not currently allowed) has resulted in some frightening episodes with large dogs accosting our four -year grand- daughter and us. Our grand - daughter became terribly afraid, and we have had to abandon our own nearby park- - Bachman— in our efforts to protect her. The outcome for us has been that Bachman Park has now become nearly unusable for us- -and this is without no -leash hours. Further, to open this park would bring in hundreds of dogs from the surrounding areas, and Bachman Park would cease to be a "people" park for Los Gatos; it will soon become a dog -only park, full of dogs without restraints. We have had much difficulty with many dog owners who regard their own dogs as harmless when, in fact, their dogs are far more aggressive that the owners will permit. There is no talking sense to them, there is no way to reach them, and they appear to feel entitled to have their dogs "roam free," as many have told us. We urgently request that the Town Council VOTE DOWN this proposal for the safety reasons. In addition, we do not want the Bachman Park area clogged with the traffic of hundreds of extra cars, nor the peace of our area broken by turning it into an open dog area. To allow off - leashed dogs at Bachman Park will change our neighborhood drastically for the worse, and we urge the Town Council, PLEASE, please to vote it down. We also request greater vigilance at the present in citing owners who have dogs off leash. Sincerelyyours, Ian and Gail Jardine ian.d.iardine(@gmail.com abigail.iardine gmail.com - - - -- Original Message--- - From: "Vikki Boyd, CCPDT -KA" < k9s4happiness@vahoo.com > Date: June 18,2012 10:59:22 AM PDT To: Diane McNutt < dmcnutta1os atosca.gov >, Steve Rice < Sricena los atg osca gov >, " sleonardis@los atg osca.gov < s1eonardis(a1os tosca.gov >, Joe Pirzynslci < pkzvnskina los atosca.gov >, B Spector < BSPECTOR@W0SGATOSCA.G0V >, " inro @l1os ag tos.goy < jpropp@ osgatos.eov >, " mana erna losgatos.gov < managerPJosgatos.gov > Cc: Urbane Concierge < kimna,theurbaneconcicr eg com Subject: off leash dogs -my experience at the Park on Friday -very predictable Reply -To: "Nikki Boyd, CCPDT -KA" < k9s4happiness R yahoo.com > Attn: Council Members If a citizen can sue the city after getting hit by a car In a poorly designed parking lot on Blossom Hill road, it doesn't seem out of the realm of possibility that the city could be liable If a person was badly injured from not only a serious dog bite, but from a fall as result of a loose dog running at them or hitting them. Head Injures from falls can be fatal. (see dog bite law -local governments article) As an experiment last Friday, I visited Bachman Park at 5:00. If I was a person who was afraid of dogs I would not have been able the walk the paved path because the the owners and their loose dogs were next to the path. Think of a senior or strollers trying to walk by ten loose large dogs! As I stood quietly about 50 yards away observing the dogs, two dogs (separately) ran directly up to me to investigate me. One was a male Brittany Spaniel, and the other was a very rambunctious female Lab so these were not small dogs. I am not afraid of dogs, but some people are. Just to add one more layer of complexity, if I had had my Springer Spaniel with me, who doesn't like other dogs, I would have had to pepper spray these dogs to avoid a dogfight. Dogs don't scare me - -dog fights do! I I ViNd Foley -Boyd Pasted from < http://dogbitelaw.com/dog- parks - liability- for - dog- bites /suits - against- local- govemments.btml The victim of a personal injury or injury to the victim's dog probably will not prevail on a claim against the local government entity that established the dog park. Generally, there are immunities that protect government entities from many claims; if the entity believed that it was doing something beneficial for the enmmunity. it is hard to act around the immtmity. are Dog Bite Law Recommendations for Dog Parlcs • There should be adequate fences that dogs cannot dig under or jump over • There should be adequate parking so that dog owners can drive to the dog park and park their cars in the parking area, as opposed to walking large numbers of dogs on nearby streets, and taking up precious parking spaces required by the residents . There should be at least one gate that securely latches (consider using two gates, so that a dog rushing through the first cannot get past the second) Visible sians should establish rules • The number of dogs per person must be limited • The age of users must be limited Professional dog walkers should register (at least) • Every dog must wear a collarEvery owner must possess a leash upon the person of the owner (for taking the dog to and from the car or the park) . Every dog must display its license or registration tag (illegal dogs are denied privileges in the park; important if there are problems in the park) 0 Every dog must be current on its vaccinations • Every person bringing a dog to the park must possess a driver's license or government- issued identification card (important if there are problems) No dog shall be left unattended by its owner No dogs allowed if previously adjudicated to be dangerous No dogs allowed that previously have bitten or injured a person or another animal • No dog allowed that is known to initiate fights with other dogs Dogs to remain on leash at all times, coming to and from dog run All violations will be investigated and one of the possible penalties is revocation of privilege There is a prominently posted address for complaints, which will be reviewed in a timely manner • There will be a board or other body that will make decisions regarding enforcement and application of penalties - - - -- Original Message---- - On 6/17/12 7:30 AM, "rath arm mcnees" < ruthann.mcnees@mnail.com > wrote: >Dear Counsel Members, >I live directly across from Bachman Park on Belmont Ave. I see daily >how the park is used and cared for. Based on what I see, I do not > support the proposed off -leash hours. Bachman simply cannot support >the numbers of people and dogs that will be attracted to the park for >the off -leash hours. It is already often at capacity with people from the neighborhood who have already had their dogs off -leash for the last few years. I often see 10 -15 dogs off -leash at the park, and all parking spaces taken. The size and nature of the park (it is especially geared toward small children) do not make it a good option for having dogs off - leash. >Since this proposal became known to the community, dogs at Bachman are >off -leash at any time of the day, and in all areas of the park. In >order forthe off -leash hours to work, there should be a commitment >from the Parks Department to monitor the park during the on -leash hours >for a significant period of time in order to ensure adherence to the > regulations. I have not heard that the Department has made such a commitment. Given the level of disregard dog owners have already shown for the Bachman Park regulations, why would anyone believe that the specific hours will be honored? Rather, I believe the current situation will be exacerbated by a much greater number of cars, people, dogs and their waste. Please consider this, and the negative impact on the surrounding neighborhood, when you make your decision. >Thank you for your consideration, >Ruth Ann McNees - - - -- Original Message--- - From: Alison McGann < alimcgannna,yahoo.com > Date: June 18, 2012 9:46:43 AM PDT To: < sriccQos atg osca. og_v >, < bsT)ectorAlosgatosca.gov >, < sleonardis a los atg osca,gov >, < dmcnutt@I1os av�toggL.&ov >, < jpirzynskina e los atg osca.gov Cc: < VVwna lqsgatosca.gov Subject: OPPOSE Off -Leash Dear Council Members, I strongly oppose the proposal to allow off -leash dog hours at Bachman Park. I live in the immediate vicinity of the park on Alexander Avenue. My children have grown up playing at Bachman Park. It's a lovely neighborhood park and a haven for families with young children. Our neighborhood is very tight -knit and we have enjoy several annual neighborhood parties, including a community Easter Egg hunt every year as well as an end -of- school party (the most recent party took place on Friday, June 8, 2012). Allowing dogs off -leash is not compatible with a neighborhood park and playground suited for young children. No time slot is a good time slot for off -leash dogs. I remember an occasion when a neighborhood dog escaped the confines of his yard. Parents were very nervous, play was disrupted, and the dog ate my picnic sandwich right off the picnic table. From this experience, it's clear that allowing dogs off - Ieash will change the nature of our park. I urge you to vote no to this proposal. Thank you, Alison McGann Citizens Against Off -Leash in Our Neighborhood Parks